Editor's Choice
How did the Wade-Davis Bill differ from Lincoln's Ten Percent Plan for reconstruction?
Quick answer:
Lincoln's Ten Percent Plan aimed for leniency and reconciliation, allowing Southern states to rejoin the Union once 10% of voters pledged allegiance. It restored property to most rebels and let states decide how to handle emancipated slaves, barring top Confederate leaders. In contrast, the Wade-Davis Bill required a majority of voters' allegiance, enfranchised African-American men, and barred Confederates from voting, reflecting a harsher stance. Lincoln vetoed it, favoring a more forgiving approach.
Abraham Lincoln's Ten Percent Plan, also known as the Proclamation of Amnesty and Reconstruction, and the Wade-Davis Bill were both proposals for reconstruction of the South after the American Civil War. However, they differed radically in the severity of their terms.
Lincoln devised his Ten Percent Plan in the spirit of reconciliation, with a view to making it easy for Southerners to accept. It stipulated that a new state government could be formed and the state could be reintegrated into the Union when at least 10 percent of eligible white male voters took an oath of allegiance to the United States. Property would be restored to all rebels except the highest ranking military and political leaders. The states could devise their own plans on how to handle former slaves as long as the slaves remained fully emancipated.
Many congressmen were opposed to Lincoln's plan because they felt it was too lenient, so Benjamin Wade of Ohio and Henry Winter Davis of Maryland sponsored an alternative Bill that was much harsher. The Wade-Davis Bill insisted that a majority of white male voters had to pledge allegiance to the United States before a state could be readmitted to the Union. The bill also gave African-American men the right to vote and prohibited officers and veterans of the Confederacy from voting.
Lincoln objected to the Wade-Davis Bill not only because it was too harsh, but also because the bill implied that the Southern States had committed treason in leaving the Union and had to rejoin, whereas the official government stance was that it was unconstitutional for them to have seceded in the first place. He also felt that slavery should be a federal rather than a state issue, which would soon prove true with the 13th Amendment to the Constitution. Although the Wade-Davis Bill passed Congress, Lincoln pocket-vetoed it, and it was not resurrected.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.
References