Editor's Choice

Could the plot of Rebecca work in 21st century America? Why or why not?

Quick answer:

The plot of Rebecca could work in 21st-century America, as its themes of jealousy, insecurity, and hidden truths remain relevant. Modern technology, such as social media, could amplify the haunting presence of Rebecca, while advances in forensic science might challenge the plot's feasibility. However, the persistence of disinformation and insecurities in modern society could allow for a plausible adaptation, with the narrator's obsession fueled by curated online personas and manipulated information.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Since the plot of Rebecca does not hinge on historical, national, or global events in any meaningful way, someone with a clever imagination could very easily adapt it to any time period or physical setting, and America in the twenty-first century would be no exception. Even in our modern times, when people are supposed to be more educated by history and reason than ever, one only has to live in America to realize that there is no shortage of impetuous young persons, both men and women alike, eager to consider a passing fling or "one night stand" to be true love. A naive young woman marrying a wealthy man would still be easy to believe in modern times.

Furthermore, modern technology could put an even more haunting spin on the memory of the titular character. More than just portraits, there could be photographs, videos, even lingering online accounts that still...

Unlock
This Answer Now

Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access


cause her to have a very tangible presence both within and without the modern Maxim's household. The twenty-first century is an age of surface-level appearances, particularly in our romantic lives. There would be numerous ways to consider that Maxim and Rebecca's relationship had in fact been hateful and spiteful behind closed doors. Indeed, a twenty-first century version of this haunting tale might be evenmore effective.

The only reason that the events of the play may not work as described is that, with advances in forensic science, authorities would likely have seen through Rebecca's apparent suicide. However, faking someone else's suicide is still a haunting reality in our modern world, and someone, particularly a man of Maxim's means, could certainly have found a way.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

The plot of Rebecca could make sense if it were set in twenty-first century America.

Two elements would have to be in place: first, a similar lack of information about who Rebecca really was and second, a narrator so insecure and lacking in self-worth that she would readily assume that Rebecca must be infinitely superior to her.

Admittedly, both elements would be more difficult in twenty-first century America, which is the implication behind the question. Stories don't always just transfer seamlessly from one culture to another.

In our culture, the differences are that we have the internet and, thus, far more easy access to immense amounts of information than the second wife. Further, we live in a culture than brings up both males and females to be assertive and have a high sense of self-worth.

Nevertheless, these are not insurmountable—or even, in the end, difficult—obstacles. Americans today, and almost everyone else, have the internet and social media at their fingertips, but fake news and disinformation are also rampant. People even hire PR firms to make sure search engines show only tops hits about them that are positive. They control their image and carefully craft a fake self that appears on social media. One can easily imagine Rebecca doing that (of course, she would), and Mrs. Danvers maintaining the carefully idealized legacy.

Second, while we raise children to be more assertive, as we know, levels of suicide have gone up in recent years, and many young people have a low sense of self esteem. We can easily imagine creating a narrator who has been bullied at school, who grew up in an unstable home, and who cut herself or attempted suicide in high school. Such a person would come into this situation without having sufficient ego or confidence to challenge the version of the Rebecca story she is told.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

The plot of Daphne du Maurier's Gothic classic Rebecca hinges on the fact that the unnamed narrator does not have and cannot easily get all the information about her new husband's ex-wife, the beautiful Rebecca. The narrator's husband, Maxim de Winter, refuses to talk about Rebecca, so the only sources the narrator has for information on Rebecca are her portrait and her loyal and therefore unreliable housekeeper, who is still in charge of maintaining Maxim and her house.

I could see arguing this question either way. A Rebecca updated for 2018 could make excellent use of social media to feed the heroine's obsession. Now, instead of staring at her portrait, the narrator would scroll through the dead woman's instagram feed. Her jealousy would be fueled not only by what the fawning housekeeper says about her but also by all the fawning messages of grief people who barely knew her have now posted on her facebook wall.

That said, because of social media and the internet at large, the narrator would have much greater access to information about Rebecca, and it's possible that through this access she would figure out on her own that Rebecca was, in actuality, no one to be jealous of. There have also been many advances in detective and police work, and it's possible that with things like DNA evidence at play, the late Mrs. de Winter's death would not go unsolved for as long as necessary for the events of the plot to unfold.

Approved by eNotes Editorial