Rabindranath Tagore Cover Image

Rabindranath Tagore

Start Free Trial

Student Question

How does Tagore describe friendship and heartbreak in "Kabuliwala?"

Quick answer:

```xhtml

Tagore describes friendship and heartbreak in "Kabuliwala" through the evolving relationship between Mini and the Kabuliwala. Their initial bond, marked by shared jokes and daily visits, represents pure friendship. However, Kabuliwala's imprisonment and Mini's growth lead to their eventual estrangement, highlighting the transient nature of friendship. This emotional shift underscores the heartbreak when past connections no longer hold the same meaning.

```

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Tagore shows that friendship and heartbreak are closely related in "Kabuliwala."

The association between Mini and her Kabuliwala represents the essence of friendship.  While Mini is at first scared of the Kabuliwala, they wind up the best of friends.  They share jokes and laughter.  He gives her dates and raisins, and she has found a companion that allows her to be her chatter-box self.  Neither one of them gets tired of the other, as Kabuliwala dutifully visits each day.  When he is arrested, he makes sure that she is one of the last people he speaks to before being taken away.

Over his eight year sentence, Mini grows up.  His absence and her maturation combine to bury the friendship that was once there.  When Kabuliwala returns to see his friend, she is a soon-to-be bride who does not acknowledge the previous depth of their connection.  She has moved...

Unlock
This Answer Now

Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

on to the pressing affairs of her own life.  The joke about her "father-in-law's house" has an entirely different meaning to her.  Kabuliwala rushes out of prison to see if his friendship still exists.  He finds nothing except heartbreak.

Friendship and heartbreak go together in "Kabuliwala."  The laughter and excitement created in the midst of friendship become sources of pain when we see that it has come to pass.  Tagore shows friendship to be contingent, dependent on a particular moment of time in people's lives.  It is an instant in time where connection is forged, but its lack of permanence causes heartbreak.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

How does Tagore describe friendship and heartbreak in "Kabuliwala"?

One of the most powerful ways in which Tagore describes the bonding of a friendship is through a shared vocabulary that few others understand.  When Mina and the Kabuliwallah would exchange their traditional greeting of "O Kabuliwallah, Kabuliwallah, what have you got in your bag?" and "Well, little one, and when are you going to the father-in-law's house," a pure form of communication is established.  It is innocent, full of an old man's joy and the little girl's peals of laughter.  No one else understands it, but they do.  This communication underscores the story.  When the old man is arrested, Mina asks him the same question and he responds in the same way.  This comes full circle at the end of the short story.  On the girl's wedding day, after a prolonged absence due to the old man's imprisonment, he appears and asks her the same question.  It has gained greater significant because of the time that has passed.  From a child laughing with innocence, the girl has become a young woman, ready to embark on the next stage of her life.  The bonding of friendship over shared communication has given way to a heartbreak. It has become clear that the girl understands what "father in law" now means to her.  While the communication has remained constant, spanning time, it means different elements.  When the narrator sees this communication, he understands how time has passed and how there used to be a bond that has given way to time.  This creates a sense of poignancy in the moment.

The narrator's function itself is another means through which a sense of emotional connection is established. It is poignant that the father who saw his chatterbox of a daughter commiserate with the old man now sees his girl about to be married.  It is also in this light where he understands the pain of the old man, who sees in the girl his own daughter and his own life before him:  "Tears came to my eyes. I forgot that he was a poor Kabuli fruit-seller, while I was--but no, what was I more than he? He also was a father. That impression of the hand of his little Parbati in her distant mountain home reminded me of my own little Mini."  In the moment where two fathers experience  an emotional rollercoaster, one sees Tagore's greatness in establishing the bonding of attachment and the pain of heartbreak.

Approved by eNotes Editorial