Purple Cane Road
Dave Robicheaux thought the worst of his past was over years ago when he was as an active alcoholic, but when a pimp tells him he knows something about the murder of Dave's mother back in the late 1960’s, Robicheaux is sent down a road of drugs, prostitution, and dirty cops which seems to have no end, and a trail which draws in even the attorney general and governor of Louisiana. Fortunately, much of the violence takes place offstage, where characters with names like Zipper Clum and Little Face Dautrieve carve each other up, but the violence threatens Dave and wife Bootsie when a hit man starts to stalk their adopted daughter Alafair. The unrelieved tension in James Lee Burke’s mystery is exactly what readers have come to expect from Burke. “It's the violence,” Dave confesses to Bootsie. “Nobody should have to live around it.” The Robicheaux family does, and readers will enjoy it from a safe distance.
The elements that put Burke a cut above most contemporary crime writers are his settings and language. Dave works as a homicide investigator and runs a boat-rental and bait business on the bayou south of New Iberia, outside of New Orleans, and the muggy Louisiana atmosphere adds to the tension. Burke is also adept at capturing the dialect of his characters, sprinkled as it is with words like “loupgarou,” “juju,” and “boudin.” The language, like the setting, defines another first-rate Dave Robicheaux mystery.
Literary Techniques
The Dance of Dualities
In his distinctive style, Burke masterfully employs the art of doubling, weaving a tapestry where the boundaries between virtue and vice dissolve into ambiguity, reflecting a contemporary world devoid of clear-cut certainties. Johnny Remata, a character echoing Robicheaux's own traits, embodies intelligence, a wary skepticism of authority, and a soft spot for Alafair. Both men are rooted in the rustic charm of the South—Robicheaux hailing from the mysterious depths of the Louisiana bayou, whilst Remata emerges from the secluded wilderness of Southern Appalachia. As Robicheaux embarks on a mission to end Remata’s life to shield his family from danger, an unexpected hesitation grips him, staying his hand. Similarly, Remata finds himself incapable of carrying out a hit on a young mother and her child. When three corrupt lawmen from New Orleans conspire to end Remata's life, Robicheaux intervenes, rescuing him, and in the ensuing chaos, one officer meets his demise. The narrative twists again when Axel Jennings, another of the corrupted trio, targets Robicheaux, only for Remata to repay the favor by eliminating Jennings.
The Artful Shift in Perspectives
Burke further explores the fluidity of narrative perspective and setting, ingeniously sidestepping the pitfalls of first-person storytelling by seemingly disregarding them altogether. Robicheaux often recounts tales relayed to him by others, granting himself a poetic latitude to fill in the gaps with vivid detail. His poignant retelling of his mother's final hours, based on scant facts, is forgiven as an emotional embellishment, a son's yearning connection. Yet, Robicheaux's description of Jim Gable's final moments, laden with precision despite the absence of witnesses, stretches credulity, for both Gable and his assailant lie dead, leaving no room for such intimate knowledge. Nevertheless, Burke's seamless narrative transitions carry the reader along so effortlessly that these lapses are scarcely noticed. Considering Robicheaux's penchant for receiving critical insights through dream-like revelations, one might overlook the occasional bending of reality's laws, as his sources sometimes drift beyond the realm of the tangible world we know.
Ideas for Group Discussions
James Lee Burke's Literary Duality
The renown of James Lee Burke as a Southern storyteller and a stalwart of hardboiled fiction has only flourished...
(This entire section contains 447 words.)
Unlock this Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
with each new creation he unveils. His novels masterfully weave significant motifs and structures from these literary traditions, delving deeper with every release into the realms they inhabit. Burke's ingenuity as a contemporary hardboiled author is widely acknowledged, particularly because he seamlessly fuses the two genres into a singular, cohesive body of work, unconfined by the constraints of each.
Universal and Timeless Themes
Burke asserts that his themes reach beyond regional confines, addressing universal issues. Certainly, ailments such as racism, crime, and the intrinsic evil within human hearts are not bound to the South alone. Burke's widespread acclaim suggests a resonance that stretches far beyond the remnants of the Confederacy. Despite this, he remains acutely aware of the influence of history on current narratives, with his novels reflecting a sensitivity to the enduring shadows cast by slavery and the Civil War on the modern South.
Exploring Humanity's Darkness
1. Burke seems to propose the presence of evil within humanity. But, where does he believe this darkness originates? Is it an inherent facet of human nature, as Jim Gable might suggest, or is it something acquired, as in Johnny Remata's case?
Robicheaux's Moral Dilemma
2. Having stood witness to two executions, Robicheaux appears firmly opposed to capital punishment. Why is this so? How should we reconcile this stance with his willingness—even occasional inclination—toward violence that stops short of killing?
The Hardboiled Tradition
3. Examine the novel within the context of the hardboiled school of literature. In what ways does Burke uphold the hardboiled tradition, and in what ways does he chart his own path?
Southern Literature: A Distinct Flavor
4. Consider the novel as a piece of Southern literature. Beyond its Louisiana setting, what elements align it with this literary tradition? How does it diverge from the "typical" Southern narrative?
Character Divergence
5. Despite sharing similar upbringings, Remata and the Labiche twins grow into markedly different individuals. To what does Burke attribute these differences?
Religious Undertones
6. Robicheaux's religious practices seem to bear little direct significance to his life, aside from the family's routine attendance at mass. Yet, religion and Christianity surface repeatedly in the novel. What commentary does Burke offer on the role of religion in the New South?
The Allure of Past Conflicts
7. Remata longs for the era of the Civil War, Axel Jennings yearns for World War II, and Jim Gable wishes to have served in Vietnam. Conversely, Clete, Robicheaux, and the Sheriff have all honorably served in foreign wars. Is Burke making a statement regarding the military, the past, war, or perhaps all three?
Literary Precedents
Much like its predecessors in the Robicheaux saga, Burke's Purple Cane Road seamlessly weaves the essential strands of Southern charm and detective tradition. Edgar Allen Poe, a Southerner by birth, is credited with launching the detective genre with the enigmatic "The Murders in the Rue Morgue" (1841). Although Mark Twain's Pudd'nhead Wilson (1899) might resonate more with Southern nuances than Poe's tales of the astute French investigator Auguste Dupin, Burke has been affectionately dubbed the "Faulkner of crime fiction." He stands as a true successor to William Faulkner's legacy, whose ventures into detective narratives include the memorable Intruder in the Dust (1948).
Whenever a novel casts a spotlight on the labyrinthine world of Louisiana politics, it's almost inevitable to draw parallels with Robert Penn Warren's All the King's Men (1946). In this instance, the echoes between the two works are explicit and plentiful. Governor Belmont Pugh mirrors Willie Stark not only in his predilection for women and drink but also in his theatrical oratory, faux-iconoclastic charm aimed at the blue-collar crowd, his stint as a door-to-door salesman, and his forfeited innocence and idealism. Furthermore, numerous scholars have noted Warren’s fascination with the same gritty techniques that Burke skillfully employs in his narrative.
Without question, Purple Cane Road adheres to the classic tropes of hardboiled crime fiction, as exemplified by Dashiell Hammett's The Maltese Falcon (1930), Raymond Chandler's The Big Sleep (1939), Mickey Spillane's I, the Jury (1947), Ross MacDonald's The Moving Target (1949), and Robert B. Parker's The Godwulf Manuscript (1973). Robicheaux's struggle with alcoholism, and his journey toward recovery with the help of Alcoholics Anonymous, bear a striking resemblance to the gritty experiences of Matt Scudder in Lawrence Block's The Sins of the Fathers (1976) and subsequent tales. Burke's nuanced take on violence, his penchant for character dualities, and his occasional forays into environmental themes perpetuate the enduring motifs and techniques seen in John D. MacDonald's expansive series of hardboiled adventures centered on the houseboat-dwelling, salvage specialist Travis McGee, introduced in The Deep Blue Good-By (1964).
Adaptations
In the year 2000, Simon & Schuster Audio unveiled a shortened audio rendition of Purple Cane Road, brought to life by the captivating voice of Will Patton.