Student Question

Is Machiavelli's argument in "The Prince" about a leader only needing the appearance of morality still valid in modern times?

Quick answer:

Machiavelli's argument in "The Prince" about the necessity for leaders to maintain the appearance of morality remains relevant today. Politics often require leaders to project an image that aligns with public expectations, regardless of their true actions. While ideally, leaders would embody the virtues they profess, the reality is that appearances frequently do not match actions. As long as leaders effectively govern and avoid scandal, the public may overlook discrepancies between their image and behavior.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

While I hate to say it I totally agree with Machiavelli on many points including this one. When I first began studying Machiavelli I thought his system was too black and white and way too cold, but as I delved into the study of his politics I began to see that politics are just that- cold. In order to be a good politician one must appear to be what the people want. To think that appearances will always match actions is ludicrous. It would be nice to think that politicians were everything they say they are, but we all know that it isn't true. Politicians and world leaders are representatives of their respective populations and I know that not one soul is perfect, but we do want to be well represented at all times. Not only do I think this statement hold water now, but it has and will continue to throughout time. "The people" do not generally support politicians who "get caught" being immoral. What "the people" don't know, won't hurt them and if the job is getting done "the people" don't generally care if their politicians are immoral, as long as no one knows about it.

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Approved by eNotes Editorial