The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie

by Muriel Spark

Start Free Trial

Discussion Topic

The narrative structure of The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie and its contribution to the themes

Summary:

The narrative structure of The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie is non-linear, using flash-forwards and flashbacks to explore themes such as the passage of time, the influence of the past, and the complexity of human character. This fragmented storytelling mirrors the intricate and multifaceted nature of Miss Brodie's impact on her students' lives.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

How does the narrative structure of The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie contribute to the themes?

The response generated is correct. The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie uses a narrative structure that relies on a non-linear timeline, shifting between different periods in the lives of the characters. This contributes to the theme of loss and also highlights how events influence the future and, as the response notes, allows readers to understand whether the influence Miss Brodie has on her students is lasting. Specifically, moving forward and revealing the girls’ eventual fates gives the reader insight into how Miss Brodie has contributed to their fates.

This technique colors the reader’s understanding of how certain events lead to eventual outcomes, helping develop the theme of free will versus predestination. Gaining insight into how lasting or ephemeral Miss Brodie's influence is on her students also enables the reader to see that her influence can be indirect. For example, Miss Brodie chides Sandy about her relationship with Teddy Lloyd, saying,

"A girl with a mind, a girl with insight.  He is a Roman Catholic and I don't see how you can have to do with a man who  can't think for himself."

Sandy seems to dismiss Miss Brodie's influence and continues to see Teddy Lloyd. Yet, eventually she “left the man and took his religion and became a nun in the course of time.” Was this indirectly also the result of Miss Brodie’s influence, as Sandy became involved with Teddy because

“she was  curious about the mind that loved the woman [Miss Brodie].”

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Identify significant features of the narrative structure of The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie (chronology, repetition, narrative perspective, insertion of fantasies) and discuss how it enhances the themes.

The response generated is correct. Distinctive narrative structures in The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie, including chronology, repetition, perspective and the insertion of fantasies enhance themes in the book. 

  1. The non-linear timeline and shift between different periods in the characters' lives underscore how current and past events influence the future. This also serves to highlight whether Miss Brodie has lasting influence on her students. We learn the girls’ fates early on, so there are no surprises, but we must determine how much their fates are the result of Miss Brodie's instructions and molding, which helps develop the theme of free will versus predestination.
  2. Repetition is another literary device that underscores, or negates, certain themes. For instance, the girls are "the Brodie set," a phrase that is repeated over and over. Yet, are the girls an homogenous set that follows Miss Brodie? We see that over time, they are not, implying that the repetition of the term also contains some irony, as does repetition of "prime" relative to Miss Brodie. Miss Brodie is a spinster who, for the times, was past her prime. The generated response rightly notes this as a contrast between Miss Brodie's self-image and reality.  
  3. Perspective, as noted in the generated response, gives the reader insight into the thoughts and feelings of multiple characters, which enhances our understanding of the characters and their motivations. It also provides a broader view of the consequences of Miss Brodie's influence on the girls, enhancing the theme of her abuse of power and the complex nature of mentorship.
  4. Fantasies give further insight into the characters' introspection and aspirations. As noted in the response, Miss Brodie fantasizes about her romantic and heroic exploits and shares these fantasies with her students as if they were reality. This ironically underscores Miss Brodie as a sad and pitiable character, not the woman in her prime she pretends to be. As the response notes, it highlights the theme of illusion versus reality, revealing Miss Brodie's delusions and abuse as she imposes her views on her students, which Sandy begins to understand. 
Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What narrative structures are used in The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie and how are they relevant?

The narrative structure of Spark's novel is a fluid one that moves freely backward and forward in time. It is not so much a case of multiple flashbacks as it is a framework where there is no single principal time period in which the story is set. It is a series of equally significant time-pictures across the years in the lives of Miss Brodie and "her girls."

The reason Spark adopts this structure is probably because it shows the changeability of the relationships between Brodie and the girls as they all mature over time. The pre-adolescent Sandy, for instance, has a connection with Miss Brodie that cannot be maintained once Sandy has matured and begun posing for Mr. Lloyd, eventually becoming his lover. When the girls are at their youngest in the story, they have no way of understanding the wrongness of Miss Brodie's admiration for Mussolini or the fascists in Spain (many others in Europe, of course, made the same mistake). The constant movements through time and the juxtapositions of past and present are Spark's method of getting across a message that human understanding and human relationships are in a constant state of flux. It also brings up the question of whether the same "self" exists through time or whether none of us has a fixed identity. Perhaps we are just collections of "impressions" and "experiences," as David Hume—the Scotsman who might have been Miss Brodie's favorite philosopher—speculated.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What narrative structures are used in The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie and how are they relevant?

Although the story follows a broad chronological framework, following events from 1930-1939, the narrative flashes forward every so often to offer glimpses of the future. This juxtaposition of different time frames is extremely relevant to the novel's purpose as a whole as it deals with Miss Brodie's influence on a select company of her pupils, the Brodie set, throughout their lives. The irony is that while Miss Brodie is supremely confident of exerting a lifelong influence on these girls, the flash-forward technique shows that, with the exception of Sandy, this does not turn out to be the case. Though they remember her from time to time, they end up leading quite different lives from what she imagined for them. For instance Rose, whom Miss Brodie imagined would turn out to be a great lover, a 'Venus incarnate', settles down to a conventional role:

Rose ... made a good marriage soon after she left school. She shook off Miss Brodie's influence as a dog shakes pond-water from its coat. (chapter 6)

Rose, then, emphatically does not fullfil Miss Brodie's exalted plans for her, and discards her teacher's influence with barely a thought.

The only girl on whom Miss Brodie has a profound and lifelong effect is Sandy. The narrative perspective generally reflects this, as events are mostly filtered through Sandy's consciousness, although we also get a direct insight into other characters' minds on occasion. Sometimes the narrative structure shifts to an omniscient narrative voice, for example at the beginning of chapter 3, which provides some background commentary on women of Mrs Brodie's type: educated and cultured women who were bereaved in the First World War and subsequently sought some outlet for their energies. This somewhat complex structure allows for multiple viewpoints on Miss Brodie and her actions, and other people's reactions to her. This is again very relevant to the novel's overall purpose of highlighting Miss Brodie's ideas and influences on others. 

The narrative also makes frequent use of repetition, referring to some incidents more than once. This kind of narrative structure allows for events to be considered from different angles. One example is the death of Mary Macgregor. First this is shown from Mary's own point of view, evoking some pathos, then it is discussed by the other girls and Miss Brodie, showing how they come to feel remorse for not having treated her more kindly. 

See eNotes Ad-Free

Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Last Updated on