A Preface to Morals

by Walter Lippmann

Start Free Trial

Historical Context

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

The Industrial Revolution

Lippmann's thought-provoking discourse in A Preface to Morals revolves around the role of religion amidst the hustle and bustle of the "modern age," or what he dubs the "age of modernity." He doesn't pinpoint the exact dawn of modernity but offers sweeping insights into the evolution of Western civilization over the past few centuries. The seismic shifts ushered in by the Industrial Revolution frequently feature in his narrative, marking a pivotal era many regard as the gateway to modernity. This transformative period, catalyzing in early 19th century England, propelled agrarian societies into bustling urban industrial landscapes, forever altering the fabric of economies.

The Progressive Era

Often entwined with the spirit of the Progressive Era, Lippmann's early writings and political musings resonate with the ideals of a transformative chapter in American history. Emerging in the tumultuous 1890s as a counter to economic strife in both rural outposts and burgeoning cities, the Progressive movement championed a wave of social reforms and demanded legal curbs on industrial magnates. It orchestrated the organization of social services to uplift the poor, while simultaneously enacting legal frameworks to dismantle industrial monopolies. The inception of the National Municipal League in 1894 was a clarion call to eradicate corruption lurking within local governance.

Additionally, the movement ardently advocated for workers' rights, including groundbreaking child labor laws. The dynamic presidency of Theodore Roosevelt, spanning from President McKinley's assassination in 1901 through the election of 1904 to 1908, saw remarkable advancements in these progressive issues. Similarly, President Woodrow Wilson's tenure from 1912 to 1920 bore witness to the vigorous pursuit of Progressive ideals, marking a significant chapter in the American socio-political landscape.

World War I

As Lippmann embarked on his career in journalism and public policy, World War I loomed large. When the conflict ignited across Europe in 1914, the United States steadfastly embraced a stance of neutrality. Yet, as hostilities dragged on, American sentiment gradually swayed towards the Allies, adopting a more cautious outlook towards Germany. A series of pivotal events catalyzed this shift in public opinion and governmental policy, nudging America towards military involvement in the European theater.

In May 1915, the harrowing incident of a German U-boat sinking the unarmed British liner Lusitania, claiming the lives of 128 Americans, sent shockwaves across the Atlantic. By early 1917, Germany's decision to escalate unrestricted submarine warfare against both civilian and military vessels led to a severance of diplomatic ties with the United States. The subsequent targeting of American ships culminated in the United States entering the fray in April 1917, ultimately contributing to the Allies' triumph over the Central Powers by late 1918.

President Wilson and the Paris Peace Conference

In the season of hope early in 1918, President Wilson unveiled to Congress his visionary Fourteen Points, encapsulating his administration's aspirations for a peaceful world after war's end. Lippmann, handpicked as part of the Inquiry—Wilson's think-tank tasked with sculpting these guiding principles—played a role in drafting the Fourteen Points. These encompassed a clarion call for national self-determination and the formation of a League of Nations to safeguard global peace.

January 1919 saw the congregation of the Paris Peace Conference, poised to shape the post-war future, heavily drawing from Wilson's Fourteen Points. Although invited to accompany Wilson's delegation to Paris, Lippmann's disenchantment with the unfolding peace talks led to his resignation. The Treaty of Versailles, the offspring of these international negotiations, incorporated several of Wilson's ideals, albeit with notable compromises. However, despite its significance, the U.S. Congress twice rebuffed the treaty, leaving the United States conspicuously absent from the League of Nations' inaugural roster.

Style and Technique

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Writing Style

Walter Lippmann has garnered widespread acclaim for his striking ability to convey...

(This entire section contains 428 words.)

Unlock this Study Guide Now

Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

intricate ideas and perform nuanced historical and political analysis through prose that is both eloquent and approachable. This mastery of expression has played a significant role in his enduring popularity, drawing a broad audience to both his journalistic columns and his philosophical works. Ronald Steel, inWalter Lippmann and the American Century, extols Lippmann's writing as "superbly lucid." Similarly, Barry D. Riccio, in Walter Lippmann, lauds his choice of the vernacular over specialized jargon. D. Steven Blum, also in Walter Lippmann, highlights how Lippmann tackled perennial political and moral debates in a straightforward style that appealed to the educated layperson. Meanwhile, Hari N. Dam, in The Intellectual Odyssey of Walter Lippmann, acknowledges "the superb craftsmanship" of his writing, noting its classical virtues of balance, precision, purity, and clarity. David Elliot Weingast, in Walter Lippmann, describes his compelling style as "clear, logical, and inevitably persuasive." John Patrick Diggins, in a 1982 introduction to A Preface to Morals, concurs, calling Lippmann's writing "relaxed, lucid, crisp, and unencumbered by heavy philosophical jargon." Diggins further admires Lippmann's journalistic and literary prowess, which often achieved epigrammatic brilliance.

Epigraph

Each section of Lippmann's A Preface to Morals commences with a thoughtfully chosen epigraph that encapsulates the essence of the upcoming discourse. Part I, titled "The Dissolution of the Ancestral Order," begins with the evocative line "Whirl is King, having driven out Zeus," by the ancient Greek playwright Aristophanes. Here, Zeus symbolizes the deity of an ancient belief system, now supplanted by the chaos of modernity—an embodiment of Lippmann's assertion that traditional religious faith has been eroded by the forces of modern culture, leaving a void.

Part II, "The Foundations of Humanism," introduces its theme with the biblical phrase "The stone which the builders rejected / That same is become the head of the corner," from Luke XX:17. Through this, Lippmann suggests that humanism should rise to become the cornerstone of a renewed moral structure in contemporary society. The third section, "The Genius of Modernity," opens with the poignant question, "Where is the way the light dwelleth?" from Job 38:19. Unlike its predecessors, this epigraph asks where the guiding "light" of moral authority exists if not within the confines of traditional religion.

Interestingly, while Lippmann argues against the sufficiency of traditional religious frameworks in the modern era, he invokes biblical sources for two of his epigraphs. This paradox highlights his recognition of religion's enduring role in addressing humanity's eternal concerns, even as he contends that religion alone can no longer meet these needs.

Compare and Contrast

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

1890s: The Rise of the Progressive Movement

In the United States, the economy falters, spiraling into a depression that ignites a sweeping demand for change. This era witnesses the birth of the Progressive movement, a powerful force advocating for profound economic and social reforms.

1930s: From Collapse to War-Induced Recovery

Just as Lippmann unveils A Preface to Morals, the catastrophic stock market crash of 1929 sets the stage for the Great Depression in America. Yet, as Europe plunges into World War II, increased production lifts the nation out of its economic slump, rejuvenating American industry.

1990s: A Decade of Economic Flourish

The United States basks in a golden era of prosperity, marked by minimal unemployment and widespread wealth generation through stock market investments. Average Americans find themselves reaping the rewards of a booming economy.

1914–1918: The United States Joins the Great War

World War I erupts across Europe, drawing the United States into the conflict in 1917. American intervention proves pivotal for the Allied forces. The war's end leads to the Paris Peace Conference in 1919, where Lippmann, disenchanted by the peace treaty's terms, resigns from President Wilson’s delegation.

1939–1945: The Second World War and Lippmann's Correspondence

As World War II unfolds, the attack on Pearl Harbor thrusts the United States into the fray in 1941. Lippmann takes on the role of a war correspondent, providing a firsthand account of the turmoil in Europe.

1990–1991: The Persian Gulf War

August 1990 sees Iraq, led by President Saddam Hussein, invading Kuwait, a nation rich in oil reserves. The United States, alongside a coalition of international forces, launches Operation Desert Storm on January 16, 1991. By February 28, 1991, Kuwait is liberated, marking the conflict's end.

1914: Founding of the New Republic

Lippmann emerges as one of the pioneering editors of New Republic, a weekly publication dedicated to championing the ideals of the Progressive movement.

1917–1919: Lippmann's Wartime Contributions

During World War I, Lippmann steps away from his editorial duties at New Republic to serve in government roles tied to the war effort.

1946: A Change in Editorial Leadership

Henry A. Wallace, former Vice President, takes the helm of New Republic as editor but soon faces resignation demands due to his leftist views.

1980s: New Republic Shifts Political Gears

Through the 1980s, New Republic evolves, shedding some of its liberal tenets to embrace a broader political spectrum.

1990s: Continuing Influence of New Republic

Even into the 1990s, New Republic maintains its stature as a leading voice in political discourse, shaping opinions and debates.

1919: Formation of the League of Nations

With the Treaty of Versailles, the League of Nations is born, aiming to ensure "collective security" worldwide. Despite the establishment of its headquarters in Geneva, the United States abstains from joining.

1940s: From League to United Nations

During the chaos of World War II, the League of Nations loses its sway, ultimately disbanding in favor of the newly formed United Nations in 1946. This organization, including the United States, sets its headquarters in New York City.

1990s: New Challenges for the United Nations

The collapse of the Soviet Union and the conclusion of the Cold War usher in fresh obstacles for the United Nations, which now grapples with mediating international and ethnic conflicts on a global scale.

Bibliography

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Sources

Adams, Larry L., Walter Lippmann, Twayne Publishers, 1977, pp. 9–10.

Blum, D. Steven, Walter Lippmann: Cosmopolitanism in the Century of Total War, Cornell University Press, 1984, pp. 9–11, 97.

Childs, Marquis, Introduction to Walter Lippmann and His Times, edited by Marquis Childs and James Reston, Harcourt, Brace and Company, 1959, p. 2.

Dam, Hari N., The Intellectual Odyssey of Walter Lippmann, Gordon Press, 1973, pp. 161–162.

Diggins, John Patrick, Introduction to A Preface to Morals, by Walter Lippmann, Transaction Publishers, 1982, pp. x–xi, xiv, xiv, xxxv–xxxvi, xli.

Kirkhorn, Michael, Dictionary of Literary Biography, Volume 29: American Newspaper Journalists, 1926–1950, edited by Perry J. Ashley, Gale Research, 1984, pp. 174–189.

Riccio, Barry D., Walter Lippmann: Odyssey of a Liberal, Transaction Publishers, 1994, p. xii.

Rossiter, Clinton, and James Lare, eds., The Essential Lippmann: A Political Philosophy for Liberal Democracy, Random House, 1963, pp. xi, xiii.

Steel, Ronald, Walter Lippmann and the American Century, Atlantic Monthly Press, 1980, pp. xiii–xvi, 263.

Weingast, David Elliott, Walter Lippmann: A Study in Personal Journalism, Rutgers University Press, 1949, pp. xiii, 125, 127, 130.

Further Reading

Adams, Larry L., ‘‘The New Morality,’’ in Walter Lippmann, Twayne Publishers, 1977, pp. 123–147. Adams discusses the philosophical, religious, and social underpinnings of Lippmann’s work.

Auchincloss, Louis, Woodrow Wilson, Viking Penguin, 2000. Woodrow Wilson is a biography of the progressive President Woodrow Wilson by whom Lippmann was recruited to develop international policy for peace in postwar Europe.

Cooper, John Milton Jr., Pivotal Decades: The United States, 1900–1920, W. W. Norton, 1990. Pivotal Decades is a history of the United States during the first decades of the twentieth century, the period during which Lippmann’s fundamental political philosophy was developed.

Diggins, John Patrick, ‘‘Introduction to the Transaction Edition: Walter Lippmann’s Quest for Authority,’’ in A Preface to Morals, by Walter Lippmann, Transaction Publishers, 1999, pp. ix–liii. Diggins describes Lippmann’s career as a writer and thinker, as well as factors that make his book an important contribution to American moral philosophy.

Diner, Steven J., A Very Different Age: Americans of the Progressive Era, Hill & Wang, 1998. A Very Different Age is a history of the United States during the Progressive era of the 1890s to 1920s.

Knock, Thomas J., To End All Wars: Woodrow Wilson and the Quest for New World Order, Oxford University Press, 1992. To End All Wars provides a historical discussion of the efforts of President Wilson to formulate a program for international peace in the wake of World War I.

Lamont, Corliss, The Philosophy of Humanism, Continuum Press, 1990. Philosophy of Humanism is an introduction to humanism, a moral philosophy that Lippmann advocates as the most appropriate replacement for religion in the age of modernity.

Reston, James, ‘‘Conclusion: The Mockingbird and Taxicab,’’ in Walter Lippmann and His Times, edited by Marquis Childs and James Reston, Harcourt Brace & Co., 1959, pp. 226–238. The book describes Lippmann’s daily life and work habits, in part derived from the conclusions he drew in A Preface to Morals.

Riccio, Barry Daniel, Walter Lippmann: Odyssey of a Liberal, Transaction Press, 1994. In Walter Lippmann, Riccio traces the development of Lippmann’s liberal, humanist political philosophy over half a century of publication.

Wilson, Edmund, ‘‘Walter Lippmann’s A Preface to Morals,’’ in From the Uncollected Edmund Wilson, edited by Janet Groth and David Castronovo, Ohio University Press, 1995, pp. 108–114. This early review of Lippmann’s book originally appeared in the New Republic in July of 1929.

Wolfe, Gregory, ed., The New Religious Humanists: A Reader, Free Press, 1997. The New Religious Humanists is an overview of philosophies of religious humanism in the late twentieth century.

Zieger, Robert H., America’s Great War: World War I and the American Experience, Rowman and Littlefield, 2000. America’s Great War provides a history of United States participation in World War I.

Previous

Critical Essays

Next

Teaching Guide

Loading...