"Pray Without Ceasing," the opening story in Fidelity (1992), chronicles a pivotal moment in 1912 when familial and community bonds are tested by a tragic event. Andy Catlett reflects on the day his great-grandfather, Ben Feltner, was senselessly killed by Thad Coulter, a friend and relative driven by misguided anger. The tale is more than a historical recount; it explores themes of forgiveness and the courage it takes to break free from cycles of vengeance.

The Build-up to Tragedy

Thad Coulter's troubles began when his financial world crumbled. He had heavily mortgaged his farm to support his son Abner's grocery business in Hargrave, but when Abner defaulted on the loan, Thad found himself unable to repay the bank. In a state of inebriation and desperation, Thad sought out Ben Feltner's assistance, arriving at his farm early one morning. Ben, recognizing Thad's condition, suggested he return sober, inadvertently wounding Thad's pride, leading to a venomous exchange of words.

The Fateful Encounter

That Saturday, the paths of Ben and Thad intertwined once more in Port William, with each man driven by different intentions. While Ben sought counsel to address the burgeoning feud, Thad was consumed by the thirst for retribution. The confrontation culminated in Thad drawing a gun on Ben, a horrific act committed in front of Ben’s son, Mat. Mat, restrained by his friend Jack Beechum, watched helplessly as his father was murdered. The aftermath saw Thad spiraling into an abyss of guilt and anger, which he directed at his family and his own soul, resulting in further destruction and ultimately, his suicide in a jail cell after fleeing the scene of his crime.

Choosing Forgiveness Over Vengeance

The wake for Ben Feltner was attended by a community on edge, where tempers flared and a thirst for immediate justice was palpable. Amidst this tense atmosphere, Jack Beechum stood by Mat's side, underscoring the importance of Mat's commitment to nonviolence. Miss Della Budge, Jack's former teacher, reminded those present of the spiritual duty to "pray without ceasing," invoking 1 Thessalonians 5:17. When a lynch mob gathered outside Ben's home, intent on enacting their brand of justice, Mat faced them with a surprising offer: they could come inside for food or disperse and abandon their violent intentions.

The Ripple Effect of Peace

"Pray Without Ceasing" demonstrates how the choice of peace and forgiveness can influence and transform a community. Mat's decision not to perpetuate the cycle of violence becomes a beacon of healing, reuniting families torn asunder by an impulsive act of violence. His stance not only mends familial bonds but also lays the groundwork for future reconciliation. Andy Catlett, the narrator, embodies the legacy of this forgiveness, symbolizing the enduring impact of his grandfather's moral courage.