While traveling with two friends on a Caribbean cruise, Avatara “Avey” Johnson, a sixty-four-year-old widow, decides that she must discard her plans for the remainder of the trip. She packs quickly in the middle of the night, her movements undetected by her traveling companions.

Avey has grown increasingly uncomfortable aboard the ship. While attempting to eat a peach parfait, she suddenly felt sickeningly full, even though she had eaten sparingly in order to save room for dessert. She has also had a nightmare about her great-aunt Cuney, with whom Avey used to spend a month each summer in South Carolina. Avey’s dream lacked the warmth she shared with her aunt; instead, her aunt beckoned Avey to follow her, then fought Avey when she didn't obey. To her surprise, Avey awakened with real physical pains from this physical altercation in her dreams. Avey has also begun suffering hallucinations with common themes of death and decay.

All of this prompts Avey to hastily decide that she must abandon her planned itinerary, and she finishes packing her belongings just before the sun comes up. Thomasina, her rather overbearing traveling companion, is aghast when she awakens and learns of Avey’s plans. She proceeds to vent her outrage at Avey, hurling one final and demeaning insult before Avey calmly walks away.

Avey had imagined that returning to her home in North White Plains, New York, would be a straightforward undertaking, but her reality does not match those dreams. When she arrives in Grenada, she is overcome by a festive crowd that continues to swell in numbers. They all speak Patois, which Avey cannot understand, as they stream toward decrepit-looking boats.

Finally Avey is rescued by a taxi driver, who has spotted her and determined the nature of her predicament. He is friendly and helpful, and he tells Avey that the people she saw at the wharf were going on “excursion.” He laughs at their tradition, telling Avey that he has never been able to understand the significance of it.

Avey arrives at a grand hotel and books a flight for the following day, as today’s only flight to New York has already departed. As she sits down in a recliner to rest, her deceased husband, Jerome “Jay” Johnson, appears to Avey in a vision, wanting to know if she really wants to end up where the two of them began.

This vision triggers a series of flashbacks about the life Avey shared with Jay. In their early years, they shared intimacy in the daily routines of life. Jay enjoyed putting on records and dancing with his wife in the evenings, and the two relished quiet Sunday mornings, when Jay always ran out for papers and coffee cake. Their sexual intimacy during those years was invigorating and filled with sweetness.

The tone of their home had shifted dramatically by the time Avey was pregnant with their third child. After unsuccessfully trying to dispel the baby from her body, Avey resigned herself to sacrificing her personal goals once more as she cared for another infant. This sacrifice weighed heavily on her and, thus, on her relationship with Jay. She became convinced that Jay was not working long hours but was instead having an affair with one of the white girls at his business. At first, Jay tried to convince Avey that her fears were baseless and even implausible, considering the time period. Avey would not be deterred.

The tension between them came to a head on one fateful winter evening. When Jay arrived home, Avey began berating him as usual. On this night, however, Jay fought back....