Postmodernism Criticism
Postmodernism in literature marks a departure from modernist principles, favoring works that emphasize self-consciousness, irony, and experimentation. This approach often rejects traditional forms such as linear narratives and realist depictions, suggesting the fluidity of truth and questioning reality itself. Postmodern literature frequently features a fragmented, non-linear portrayal of time, merging ordinary events with surreal elements, and often turns the act of writing into a central theme. Concepts like bricolage involve creatively reassembling fragments of existing texts to prioritize innovation over originality, as noted by authors like Cervantes and Borges in Robert Alter's overview. As articulated by Richard Bradbury, postmodern authors like John Barth use self-reflexive techniques to critique cultural narratives, while Charles Russell highlights themes of ambiguity and self-consciousness in the fiction of Thomas Pynchon. The movement emerged from the social upheavals of the 1960s, embodying a skepticism towards historical and cultural traditions, as well as modernist ideals of progress and objectivity. Jacques Derrida's deconstructionism is central to postmodern thought, suggesting that texts can be interpreted in myriad, often contradictory ways, challenging the direct relationship between words and meaning. Through devices such as discontinuous narratives and authorial intrusions, postmodern literature often blurs the line between reality and fiction, as explored by critics like Brian McHale in his examination of postmodern writing. Despite the varied interpretations of postmodernism, its works typically feature recurring motifs of irony and thematic explorations of the artificial and the impermanent, capturing the complex nature of modern human experience, as discussed by Ihab Hassan and others.
Contents
- Representative Works
-
Overviews
-
The Self-Conscious Moment: Reflections on the Aftermath of Modernism
(summary)
In the following essay, Alter presents an overview of postmodern fiction, including works by Cervantes, Borges, Flann O'Brien, Nabokov, and John Barth.
-
The Myth of the Postmodern Breakthrough
(summary)
In the following essay, which was first published in slightly different form in 1973, Graff identifies postmodernism as both visionary and apocalyptic, and asserts that despite claims to the contrary, postmodernism derives from Romantic and modernist literary theory.
-
Pluralism in Postmodern Perspective
(summary)
In the following essay, which was first published in 1986, Hassan discusses the historical aspects of postmodernism, concluding that the postmodern approach is the most appropriate to depict the wide-ranging aspects of human life in the twentieth-century.
-
The Problem of the Postmodern
(summary)
In the following essay, originally published in 1988, Chabot argues that postmodernism exhibits more continuity with traditional literary methods than most critics admit.
-
The Self-Conscious Moment: Reflections on the Aftermath of Modernism
(summary)
-
Essays
-
Postmodernity and Hermeneutics
(summary)
In the following essay, Palmer defends his postulation that postmodernism is an aesthetic movement of limited duration, and that modernity indicates the era beginning with the Renaissance and continuing into the present.
- 1. Outgrowing the epistemological self-portrait of modernity
- 2. Postmodernity and the project of going beyond metaphysics
- 3. Transcending objectivism and technological rationality
- 4. A. "New Gnosticism": Ihab Hassan
- 5. The movement beyond Western forms of reality
- 6. Beyond naturalism
- 7. The apostles of "new consciousness"
- 8. New foundations in psychology
- 9. Radical philosophy of language
- 10. Postmodern literary theory
- 1. Hermes: God of the gaps
- 2. Toward a broader conception of hermeneutics
- 3. Toward a new interpretive self-awareness for teachers
-
Writing about Postmodern Writing
(summary)
In the following essay, Brian McHale evaluates critical perspectives on postmodernist literature by examining works from Christine Brooke-Rose, Christopher Butler, Anne Jefferson, and Alan Wilde, highlighting their descriptive approaches while addressing the distinctions between theoretical and practical art in postmodernism.
-
Postmodern Theory/Postmodern Fiction
(summary)
In the following essay, Johnston surveys the theories of several postmodernist literary critics, including Brian McHale, Frederic Jameson, Patricia Waugh, and Michel Foucault.
-
Postmodernism and American Literary History
(summary)
In the following essay, Hirsch defends New Criticism practices against what he perceives as the failed philosophical underpinnings of postmodern criticism.
-
Critical Literacy and the Postmodern Turn
(summary)
In the following essay, McLaren and Lankshear examine the impact of postmodernist literary thought on education and society.
- Decentering the subject
- Decentering the text
- Further criticisms
- Feminist contributions
- Subjectivity and subjects/agency and agenthood: Problems with identity politics in emancipatory research
- Pedagogy in the postmodern age
- Poststructuralist pedagogy versus political pedagogy
-
Individual Voice in the Collective Discourse: Literary Innovation in Postmodern American Fiction
(summary)
In the following essay, Russell surveys the fiction of several contemporary American authors, including Thomas Pynchon, to convey his belief that postmodernism reflects the ambiguity and self-consciousness of life in the latter half of the twentieth-century.
-
The Name of the Rose' as a Postmodern Novel
(summary)
In the following essay, Parker examines the postmodernist tendencies of Umberto Eco's The Name of the Rose in light of Eco's own literary criticism.
-
Postmodernism and Barth and the Present State of Fiction
(summary)
In the following essay, Bradbury discusses the fiction of John Barth, finding that the author uses self-reflexive techniques to comment on American culture.
-
Postmodern Romance: Don DeLillo and the Age of Conspiracy
(summary)
In the following essay, McClure examines novelist Don DeLillo's adaptation of popular novels of different genres, including science fiction, espionage, and occult adventures.
-
Practicing Post-Modernism: The Example of John Hawkes
(summary)
In the following essay, Unsworth defends Jerome Klinkowitz's assertion that contemporary artists and writers influence each other by examining the relationship between John Hawkes and Albert Guerard.
-
The Postmodern Novel: The Example of John Irving's The World According to Garp
(summary)
In the following essay, Wilson claims John Irving's The World According to Garp as an example of postmodern literature precisely because it borrows stylistically from such diverse writers as James Joyce, John Cheever, and John Barth.
- A literature of exhaustion and replenishment
- The zone of the bizarre
- The turn away from psychological depth in character
- Metafiction
- Reuse of earlier forms
- The zone of the bizarre
- Flatness of character
- Metafiction
-
Surfiction: A Postmodern Position
(summary)
In the following essay, Federman proposes that surfiction is the only contemporary literature that revels in humankind's intellect, imagination, and irrationality because it recognizes life itself as fiction.
- Miriam Marty Clark
-
Languages of Post-Modernism
(summary)
In the following essay, Davidson examines some defining characteristics of postmodernism that have appeared in American poetry and art.
-
What Is Living and What Is Dead in American Postmodernism: Establishing the Contemporaneity of Some American Poetry
(summary)
In the following essay, Altieri finds that contemporary American poetry has to a significant extent divested itself from the stylistic and thematic traits of postmodern critical theory.
- Appendix
-
Postmodernism: Extension or End of Modernism? Theater between Cultural Crisis and Cultural Change
(summary)
In the following essay, Fischer-Lichte distinguishes between Modernism and Postmodernism in the theater.
-
Postmodernity and Hermeneutics
(summary)
- Further Reading