Student Question
Who or what are the "master" and "slaves" in Aristotle's works, and why do slaves exist? How does Aristotle define citizenship, and how does it compare to modern American notions?
Quick answer:
In Aristotle's works, "masters" are those who own slaves, while "slaves" are considered property, lacking legal rights, similar to animals or objects. Slavery exists due to Aristotle's belief in "natural slavery," where some individuals are deemed incapable of rational decision-making. Citizenship in Aristotle's era was limited to free men with specific rights, unlike modern American notions, which emphasize universal rights and equality regardless of status, gender, or origin.
Slavery was a legal institution in Ancient Greece, as was citizenship. Aristotle's account was grounded in the common social and political structures of his period.
In most Greek city-states, people were divided into three categories: citizens, metics (resident aliens), and slaves. Citizens had a variety of rights, such as the ability to own property and bring lawsuits. Slaves were legally classified as property, just like cattle, chickens, or even pottery. A slave had no rights and was not considered a person under the law. Even women who were not slaves were limited in their rights and freedoms, being under the control of their fathers and then their husbands. Metics or resident aliens were neither slaves nor citizens but simply foreigners, who had no legal rights or citizenship. Some cities, such as Athens, had very restrictive criteria for citizenship, leading to something of an underclass of metics. The term "master" simply refers to a person who owns a slave.
Aristotle justified this system with a concept of "natural slavery," arguing that some people were not sufficiently rational to make wise decisions and thus were best suited to lives as slaves.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.