Critical Overview
Charles Dickens's "The Pickwick Papers" is a cornerstone of literary history, renowned for its rich characters and comedic genius. At the heart of the novel stands Mr. Pickwick, an iconic figure in literature, whose adventures encapsulate the essence of the lower- and middle-class life in the 19th century. Dickens's creation of the Pickwick Club and its members, especially the dynamic servant Sam Weller, offers not only entertainment but also a commentary on societal norms and personal values.
The Genesis of a Literary Classic
In 1836, amidst his rising fame from "Sketches by Boz," a young Charles Dickens was approached by a publisher to write accompanying text for illustrations by Robert Seymour. Though Dickens had novelistic ambitions, financial necessity led him to accept the offer, shaping "Pickwick Papers" into a monthly serial of humorous vignettes. With limited knowledge of the sporting scenes Seymour envisioned, Dickens cleverly navigated his narrative focus towards more familiar settings, drawing from his experiences as a journalist to craft vivid depictions of elections, inns, and the peculiarities of life on the road.
Crafting Scenes and Characters
While Dickens's lack of enthusiasm for country sports is apparent, his adept selection of scenes showcases his strength in portraying societal institutions such as country elections and judicial proceedings. The "Eatanswill" election scene, for instance, brims with satirical observation, bringing to life the farcical nature of political contests. Equally memorable are the settings of inns and public houses where much of the novel's pivotal interactions occur, including the fateful meeting of Mr. Pickwick and Sam Weller at the White Hart Inn.
Explorations of Law and Order
"The Pickwick Papers" also broaches the theme of legal entanglements, a motif Dickens revisits in later works. The novel paints a picture of a corrupt legal system, with most legal figures depicted as unscrupulous, highlighting the author's skepticism of the justice system. Only Mr. Perker, a lawyer characterized by his cold pragmatism, escapes outright condemnation, yet even he falls short of inspiring confidence.
Complex Attitudes Towards Women
Critically, Dickens's portrayal of women in "The Pickwick Papers" reveals an ambiguous stance. Female characters such as Sam's love interest, Mary, and Arabella Allen, are superficially sketched, often defined by their relationships to male protagonists rather than individual depth. Their roles, largely passive, contrast sharply with the more dynamic male figures who drive the narrative, suggesting Dickens's struggle to transcend the gender norms of his time.
Reflections on Marriage
The narrative's take on marriage further illustrates Dickens's ambivalence toward societal institutions. Through characters like Mr. Winkle and Mr. Tupman, marriage is depicted as a blend of romantic idealism and comedic mishap. Mr. Pickwick himself remains a bachelor, advocating for emotional integrity over societal expectations, a notion reinforced by Mr. Weller's sardonic views on matrimony: "'vether it’s worth while goin’ through so much, to learn so little . . . is a matter o’ taste."
Autobiography in Fiction
Many scholars, including Angus Wilson, interpret "The Pickwick Papers" as an autobiographical piece. Dickens's personal history, especially his complex relationship with his father, finds echoes in the novel. The younger Dickens faced hardship during his father's imprisonment for debt, a formative experience that influenced his portrayal of characters like Mr. Pickwick, who embodies the combined traits of kindness, resilience, and ethical fortitude.
The Father-Son Dynamic
Central to the novel is the evolving dynamic between Mr. Pickwick and Sam Weller, reflecting Dickens's idealized vision of father-son relationships. Mr. Pickwick represents the qualities Dickens admired in his own father, suffused with an added layer of financial and moral responsibility. In turn, Sam Weller emerges as the devoted son, employing his wit and loyalty in servitude to his father figure, both biological and symbolic. This relationship not only ties back to Dickens's personal past but resonates with a universal desire for paternal admiration and filial devotion.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.