Emma Fisher
Last Updated August 6, 2024.
Peter Porter's poems on the death of his wife, where the agonising minutiae—the appointment card from an optician, other mail after she's dead—are presented in all their nakedness [in The Cost of Seriousness]. He makes Gertrude Stein say:
Nothing can be done in the face
of ordinary unhappiness
Above all, there is nothing to do in words
I have written a dozen books
to prove nothing can be done in words.
Porter does a lot in words but cannot do much about ordinary unhappiness, and this inability is a subject of many of the poems.
Despair and wit mingle uneasily. His cross—cultural jokes—as when Boccherini says:
When I start an allegro
it's planned like those washing programmes
right through to spin-dry
are typical of his rueful sense of himself as a responsive tourist of civilisation, celebrating other people's art and the absurdities of his own. But he keeps coming back from contemplation of some work of art—such as an angel at Blythburgh—to the fact of that death, as if by linking it in he could help heal the pain.
Often the message is 'they believed in God or an afterlife, but I don't and it's very hard'….
There is an irresistible pull in poems about death to come to some sort of resolution or acceptance, even if only a stoical one; but in Porter's poem the grief remains private and unbearable….
There is something tight-lipped about all this. Elsewhere, in The Cost of Seriousness, he says
I have come no closer to my goal
of doing without words, that
pain may be notated some real way.
One suspects that he finds music a real way, although he says in 'The Lying Art' 'Music gets the better of it, since music is all lies'. It may seem unclear why he goes on writing at all; but in one of the best poems in the book, 'The Delegate', he has the answer:
The artist … is being used despite himself. The truth
is a story forcing me to tell it. It is not
my story or my truth. My misery
is on a colour chart—even my death
is a chord among the garden sounds.
He sees his unhappiness in perspective as only a part of a polychromatic, amoral, but inherently beautiful world, and this is his form of reconciliation. (p. 25)
Emma Fisher, in The Spectator (© 1978 by The Spectator; reprinted by permission of The Spectator), July 8, 1978.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.