Peter Porter Criticism
Peter Porter (1929–2010) was an acclaimed Australian poet who spent much of his life in London, earning recognition for his unique ability to blend traditional poetic themes with innovative forms. His work often grapples with complex themes such as cultural identity, personal loss, and the interplay between art and life. Critics like Michael Wood have noted Porter's potential for depth and wit, particularly in his translations and select poems, despite some glib tendencies. Porter's poetry exhibits a tension between emotional immediacy and artistic distance, as Desmond Graham observes, especially in his collection The Cost of Seriousness, which reflects on grief and loss with poignant eloquence. His ability to merge intellectualism with genuine emotion is highlighted by Anne Stevenson. Furthermore, Emma Fisher explores his struggle to find meaning beyond words, particularly after personal tragedies. Porter's exploration of modern life's complexities, as noted by Douglas Dunn, and his evolving poetic language, analyzed by Peter Washington, reflect a deeply introspective and culturally resonant body of work, making him a significant figure in contemporary poetry.
Contents
- Porter, Peter (Vol. 5)
-
Porter, Peter (Vol. 13)
-
Michael Wood
(summary)
In the following essay, Michael Wood critiques Peter Porter's poetry, suggesting that while his work often leans towards glibness and cleverness reminiscent of Betjeman, there are moments of genuine intensity, particularly in his translations of Martial and in select original poems, which reveal Porter's potential for depth and wit.
-
Peter Washington
(summary)
In the following essay, Peter Washington analyzes Peter Porter's work as a reflection of a tumultuous blend of old and new styles, emphasizing his exploration of landscapes, time, and culture through a "true and disciplined despair" and an evolving poetic language that seeks to capture a world intertwined with divinity and personal perception.
-
Douglas Dunn
(summary)
In the following essay, Douglas Dunn argues that Peter Porter's poetry balances cultural conservatism with artistic adventure, showcasing a mastery of idiom and rhythm while exploring the complexities of modern life and maintaining a strong fictional aspect to express his moral vision.
-
Richard Pevear
(summary)
In the following essay, Richard Pevear critiques Peter Porter's poem "Family Album" for its predictability and superficial depth, arguing that it offers conventional resolutions lacking genuine insight or struggle.
-
Emma Fisher
(summary)
In the following essay, Emma Fisher explores how Peter Porter's poetry grapples with the ordinary yet profound despair of personal loss, particularly through his use of cultural references and the persistent theme of grief that defies resolution, highlighting his struggle to find meaning in art and life beyond words.
-
Anne Stevenson
(summary)
In the following essay, Anne Stevenson argues that Peter Porter's The Cost of Seriousness intertwines themes of personal grief and disillusionment with poetry itself, showcasing Porter's erudition and ability to blend intellectualism with genuine emotion, though it is when he writes humbly that his work is most poignant.
-
Fleur Adcock
(summary)
In the following essay, Fleur Adcock examines Peter Porter's collection The Cost of Seriousness, highlighting how the poet's contemplation of death, particularly following the loss of his wife, refines his style into a poignant and direct eloquence, while also noting Porter's enduring engagement with art.
-
Desmond Graham
(summary)
In the following essay, Desmond Graham critiques Peter Porter's collection "The Cost of Seriousness," noting the emotional depth and pain explored in the poems, while arguing that the attempt to reconcile art with the reality of pain results in an unresolved tension between emotional immediacy and artistic distance.
-
Michael Wood
(summary)
Criticism by Peter Porter
-
Collecting Her Strength
Sylvia Plath Criticism
-
Landscape with Poems
Seamus Heaney Criticism
-
Auden's Cornucopia: The 1930s Texts
W. H. Auden Criticism
-
Peter Porter
Judith Wright Criticism
-
A Month in the City
Peter Carey Criticism
-
Spooked by a Spoof
Peter Carey Criticism
-
Voices from Ulster
Derek Mahon Criticism
-
The World Upside Down
Craig Raine Criticism
-
Out of the Anteroom
James Fenton Criticism
-
Poetry, Politics, Polemics
Tom Paulin Criticism
-
Remembering Ian Hamilton, 1938-2001
Ian Hamilton Criticism
-
Painting in Words
Amy Clampitt Criticism
-
Laundromat Lyrics
Roy Fisher Criticism
-
Peter Porter
Gavin Ewart Criticism