Peter Handke Criticism
Peter Handke, born in 1942 in Austria, is a seminal figure in postmodern literature, known for his profound impact on German-language works through an extensive repertoire of novels, plays, poetry, and essays. His early career was marked by experimental theatrical "Sprechstücke" that challenge traditional conventions, exemplified by Offending the Audience (1966), where actors blur the lines between performers and viewers, emphasizing the participatory nature of theater, as noted by Nicholas Hern. This approach underscores a central theme in Handke's work: the insufficiency of language as a vehicle for genuine communication, which is vividly illustrated in his "speak-ins," pieces that lack traditional drama structure and highlight language's obstructive potential.
Handke's critical exploration of language continues in Kaspar (1968), a play delving into the connection between language and identity, as discussed by David Barnett. This work, alongside Self-Accusation and Calling for Help, illustrates Handke's focus on how linguistic acquisition can strip individuals of their uniqueness, as further explored by Richard Arthur Firda in Theatrical Experiments. Despite some perceptions of abstraction, these plays are celebrated for their cerebral insights and have significantly influenced modern drama.
Handke's literary evolution is notable, shifting from deconstructive themes of alienation to those of self-discovery and inner transformation, as discussed by Linda C. DeMeritt. His mature works, such as My Year in the No-Man's Bay, venture into themes of connectivity and introspection, praised for their narrative complexity. Handke's approach to language as both a barrier and a medium of profound connection is evident in The Afternoon of a Writer, celebrated by critics like Ursula Hegi and Mark Kamine.
Nevertheless, not all Handke's works have been favorably received. The Hour We Knew Nothing of Each Other was criticized for its lack of dialogue, noted in the Times Literary Supplement, while A Journey to the Rivers sparked controversy for its perceived apologetic stance on Serbian politics, attracting criticism from reviewers like David Rieff. Such debates confirm Handke's role as a provocative voice in contemporary literature.
Handke's engagement with myth and language is further exemplified in works like Das Spiel vom Fragen, where he integrates mythological elements to create fairy tale-like narratives, as explored by Eva-Maria Metcalf. These explorations challenge the boundaries of theater and encourage audiences to reconsider the essence and function of language, affirming Handke's position as a pivotal figure in contemporary literature. Despite criticisms from figures like James Wolcott and Ferdinand Mount, who question the emotional depth of certain works, Handke's exploration of language, identity, and perception continues to provoke thought and discussion in literary circles.
Contents
- Principal Works
-
Handke, Peter (Vol. 135)
-
Peter Handke and the End of the ‘Modern’
(summary)
In the following essay, Hays examines the theoretical and aesthetic principles governing Handke's critical perspectives and dramatic works, particularly his effort to subvert the conventions of modern drama. According to Hays, “Handke's goal is to make art out of artifice while revealing the artifice of that art.”
-
Politics and Poetry: Peter Handke's They Are Dying Out
(summary)
In the following essay, Schlueter examines the deep-seated themes of individual loss and alienation that underlie the political ideology of They Are Dying Out.
-
The Sorrows of Young Writers
(summary)
In the following excerpt, Cook offers a positive assessment of The Weight of the World.
-
Special Subjects
(summary)
In the following excerpt, Enright offers an unfavorable assessment of Across.
-
Peter Handke: From Alienation to Orientation
(summary)
In the following essay, DeMeritt examines the transition from alienation and fear to harmony and happiness in Handke's literary works, drawing attention to such thematic developments in Die Stunde der wahren Empfindung and Die Lehre der Sainte-Victoire.
-
Peter Handke
(summary)
In the following essay, Linstead provides an overview of Handke's literary career and discusses the major themes, artistic preoccupations, and narrative strategies of his novels.
-
A Tale of Rediscovery and Renewal
(summary)
In the following review, Pool offers a favorable assessment of Repetition.
-
A Magic Touch
(summary)
In the following review, Oldfield offers a positive assessment of Repetition. In Peter Handke's new novel, his young narrator describes a painter retouching an unseen mural inside a wayside shrine. He resolves to write “so silently … without ulterior motive of any kind. Whatever this future work might be, it would have to be comparable to this painting, which ennobled the painter and with him the chance witness.” This sanctified, secluded site of creation is just the latest variant on Handke's belief that literature belongs in an “ivory tower”, that it can be an autonomous pleasure-dome of language. His career has been a struggle against the confinements and sclerosis of language and a search for a cleansed, innocent vision.
-
Of What, Then, Shall He Write?
(summary)
In the following review, Hegi offers a positive assessment of The Afternoon of a Writer. Language functions as barrier and bridge in Peter Handke's The Afternoon of a Writer, a fascinating exploration of a man who has distanced himself from his life and, therefore, from the material he draws from in his writing. Though aware of sensuous details in his environment, he remains emotionally detached. His major connection to the world is through language, a sequence of words which—he reminds himself frequently—he has lost contact with before.
-
Tender Is His Plight
(summary)
In the following review, Kamine offers a positive evaluation of The Afternoon of a Writer. This short novel was inspired by F. Scott Fitzgerald’s “Afternoon of an Author.” That story describes one uneventful day in its protagonist’s life, episodically tracking his movements through Baltimore and recording his memory-laden reflections. It opens with the author feeling “better than he had for many weeks” and ends—after he suffers a crisis of confidence—with his resolution to go on writing. The piece is alternately ironic and elegiac.
-
The Afternoon of a Writer
(summary)
In the following review, Leonard offers a positive assessment of The Afternoon of a Writer.
-
Writer-Consciousness
(summary)
In the following excerpt, Updike offers a tempered assessment of The Afternoon of a Writer, which he notes may appear “pompous” and “claustrophobic” to American readers despite its “phenomenal intensity.”
-
Das Spiel vom Fragen oder Die Reise zum Sonoren Land
(summary)
In the following review, Skwara complains that Das Spiel vom Fragen oder Die Reise zum Sonoren Land tends to be abstract and inaccessible.
-
Versuch über die Müdigkeit
(summary)
In the following review, Skwara offers a positive assessment of Versuch über die Müdigkeit, describing it as a wise and beautiful book, quite possibly one of Peter Handke's major works, and exploring the variety and wealth of being tired.
-
Only Disconnect
(summary)
In the following review, Hegi complains that Absence lacks characterization and creates intentional linguistic gaps. The four nameless characters in Peter Handke's latest novel are like paper dolls, suspended against a bleak sky in a chain of silhouettes that block the scant light. Told in a strangely passive voice that appears to rise from a void, Absence is not only about the condition of being absent—it also demonstrates the condition through the absence of words, connections and characterization.
-
Ding-Bild-Schrift: Peter Handke's Slow Homecoming to a ‘Chinese’ Austria
(summary)
In the following essay, Caviola examines the development and significance of Handke's increasingly sober and subjective tone in Langsame Heimkehr and Der Chinese des Schmerzes. Caviola argues that “Handke's solemn tone cannot be taken at face value but has to be perceived in the context of an aesthetic that is allegorically inscribed in the text.”
-
Challenging the Arrogance of Power with the Arrogance of Impotence: Peter Handke's Somnambulistic Energy
(summary)
In the following essay, Metcalf examines Handke's preoccupation with the aesthetic and contextual properties of language, particularly Handke's effort to purify language of its conventional meanings and associations in order to break free from “rationalistic discourse.” Metcalf writes, [Handke's] “impotent power is that of an alert dreamer, who reifies through illusion, who reveals by obscuring and enveiling words and concepts, and who gains in presence by withdrawing.”
-
A Superior Reality
(summary)
In the following review, Hofmann offers a positive assessment of Absence. Peter Handke's descriptions of reality are of two kinds: some are of superior accuracy, some describe a superior reality. After an initial struggle, Absence settles down as a book of the second type. In German, it was subtitled Ein Märchen. The English publisher’s blurb works out an ambitious platform for it as 'a narrative scrutiny of the absence which lies at the heart of human identity and endeavour', but to me it seems a book entirely without and against reason: it could have been any length, about any subject, under any title. Purely aleatory, it allows the author and reader the greatest possible freedom.
-
The Elusive Perfect Day
(summary)
In the following review, White offers an unfavorable assessment of Versuch über den geglückten Tag. Peter Handke's new prose-work is the third in a series of “Versuche”, essays-cum-experimental stylistic explorations of a theme, which have recently become his preferred mode. Handke has taken on a theme so decidedly elusive that he even has difficulty pinpointing a terminology or a repertoire of images appropriate to his material.
-
Versuch über den geglückten Tag
(summary)
In the following review, Skwara offers a positive evaluation of Versuch über den geglückten Tag.
-
Seeing Through the Eyes of the Word
(summary)
In the following essay, Honegger examines Handke's approach to the problem of language and verbal expression in his dramatic works and prose experiments, particularly the use—or absence—of words to reveal both the limitations and interpretative potential of language and its associated meanings.
-
Die Theaterstücke
(summary)
In the following review, Falk assesses Die Theaterstücke and Handke's literary development.
-
Langsam im Schatten
(summary)
In the following review, Skwara offers a positive assessment of Langsam im Schatten, highlighting its richness, diversity, and depth, and confirming Peter Handke as one of the most significant literary figures alive today.
-
New Prose: Meditative Fiction
(summary)
In the following essay, Firda provides an overview of the major themes, narrative presentation, and artistic concerns in Der Chinese des Schmerzes, Die Wiederholung, Nachmittag eines Schriftstellers, and Die Abwesenheit.
-
Times Literary Supplement (review
date 16 September 1994)
-
The Hour We Knew Nothing of Each Other
(summary)
In the following review, the critic offers an unfavorable assessment of The Hour We Knew Nothing of Each Other.
-
The Hour We Knew Nothing of Each Other
(summary)
-
Language and Reality
(summary)
In the following review, Honegger analyzes Handke's literary and aesthetic preoccupations in The Jukebox and Other Essays on Storytelling.
-
Mein Jahr in der Niemandsbucht
(summary)
In the following review, Skwara offers a favorable assessment of Mein Jahr in der Niemandsbucht, arguing that Peter Handke is one of the greatest living authors for his ability to renew himself constantly and present innovative ways to describe the world while maintaining his artistic vision.
-
Words and Serbs
(summary)
In the following review, Timms finds shortcomings in Handke's criticism of Western media coverage of the Balkan war in Eine winterliche Reise zu den Flüssen Donau, Save, Morawa und Drina.
-
Eine winterliche Reise zu den Flüssen Donau, Save, Morawa und Drina oder Gerechtigkeit für Serbien
(summary)
In the following review, Ziolkowski commends Handke's intent but finds his efforts to provide an impartial view of Serbia unsuccessful in Eine winterliche Reise zu den Flüssen Donau, Save, Morawa und Drina oder Gerechtigkeit für Serbien.
-
Question Marks
(summary)
In the following review, Sellar offers a positive evaluation of Voyage to the Sonorous Land and The Hour We Knew Nothing of Each Other.
-
Short Book, Long Apology
(summary)
In the following review, Rieff offers a negative evaluation of A Journey to the Rivers, which he calls a “contemptible book.”
-
Sommerlicher Nachtrag zu einer winterlichen Reise
(summary)
In the following review, Ziolkowski offers a negative assessment of Sommerlicher Nachtrag zu einer winterlichen Reise.
-
In einer dunklen Nacht ging ich aus meinem stillen Haus
(summary)
In the following review, Skwara offers a positive assessment of In einer dunklen Nacht ging ich aus meinem stillen Haus. Each one of Peter Handke's books has taught its readers a lesson, with his latest novel teaching how to take wing and fly.
-
On a Blue Note
(summary)
In the following review, McGonigle offers positive assessments of My Year in the No-Man's Bay and Once Again for Thucydides.
-
Drizzle, Birdcall, Leaf Fall
(summary)
In the following review, Gass offers a positive evaluation of My Year in the No-Man's Bay.
-
Peter Handke and the End of the ‘Modern’
(summary)
- Handke, Peter (Vol. 5)
-
Handke, Peter (Vol. 15)
-
Nicholas Hern
(summary)
In the following essay, Nicholas Hern explores Peter Handke's theatrical works, highlighting Handke's innovative use of language to evoke reality without traditional narrative elements, his rejection of theatrical illusion, and his focus on the audience's awareness, culminating in a critique of conventional theater through pieces like Offending the Audience and Kaspar.
-
Reflections on Recent Prose
(summary)
In the following essay, J. D. O'Hara critiques Peter Handke's fiction, particularly The Goalie's Anxiety at the Penalty Kick and The Left-Handed Woman, as being stylistically contrived and pretentious, drawing unfavorable comparisons to Kafka and Beckett while suggesting that Handke's style is artificially elliptical and overly reliant on literary predecessors.
-
Brief Reviews: 'The Left-Handed Woman'
(summary)
In the following essay, David Blum discusses how Peter Handke's The Left-Handed Woman poignantly portrays a woman's journey to self-discovery and autonomy through minimalist characterization and profound poetic insight.
-
Faust, Inc.
(summary)
In the following essay, Erika Munk critiques Peter Handke's play They Are Dying Out, arguing that despite its portrayal as an overtly political work, it is more complex, blending humor, surrealism, and psychological depth with its satirical examination of the corporate world embodied by the protagonist, Quitt.
-
Metafictional Theater: Handke's 'The Ride across Lake Constance'
(summary)
In the following essay, June Schlueter examines Peter Handke's play "The Ride Across Lake Constance," arguing that Handke's self-referential theater challenges traditional drama by creating a self-contained theatrical reality that questions the conventional relationship between language, character, and reality, ultimately seeking to revitalize both artistic and philosophical perceptions of reality.
-
Nicholas Hern
(summary)
- Handke, Peter (Vol. 8)
-
Handke, Peter (Vol. 10)
-
The Problem of Identity: Theme, Form and Theatrical Method in 'Les Nègres,' 'Kaspar' and 'Old Times'
(summary)
In the following essay, Gay McAuley explores the philosophical and theatrical dimensions of Peter Handke's play Kaspar, focusing on themes of identity, language, and self-awareness, while examining how the character of Kaspar embodies both a social and existential critique through his manipulation by language and his quest for authentic existence.
-
The Critic's Anxiety at Kicking Peter Handke
(summary)
In the following essay, James Wolcott criticizes Peter Handke's novel A Moment of True Feeling for its lack of emotional authenticity and coherence, arguing that despite its lively language and existential themes, it pales in comparison to Handke's earlier, more impactful works.
-
Peter Handke's 'My Foot My Tutor': Aspects of Modernism
(summary)
In the following essay, Bonnie Marranca explores Peter Handke's play My Foot My Tutor, highlighting its departure from traditional drama through its elimination of dialogue to focus on non-verbal communication, thematic exploration of power dynamics, and its minimalist style influenced by cinematic and scientific techniques.
-
Peter Handke, and 'Alienation-Fiction': The Sorrows of Young Outsiders
(summary)
In the following essay, Ferdinand Mount critiques Peter Handke's literary work as derivative yet intense, arguing that while Handke's themes of domination, alienation, and egoism resonate deeply, they ultimately lean on political overtones and lack consistency and honesty in their depiction of free will and individuality.
-
Exorcising Reality
(summary)
In the following essay, Olaf Hansen argues that Peter Handke's novel A Moment of True Feeling challenges traditional literary forms by exploring the philosophical nature of fiction, emphasizing the reconstruction of poetic truth through individual experience, and questioning the legitimacy of language as a medium of reality.
-
William Kakish
(summary)
In the following essay, William Kakish examines Peter Handke's novel A Moment of True Feeling and argues that the protagonist Gregor Keuschnig’s crisis of identity reflects complex layers of perception and existence, leading to a narrative structure that challenges readers with unresolved tensions and demands multiple readings.
-
The Problem of Identity: Theme, Form and Theatrical Method in 'Les Nègres,' 'Kaspar' and 'Old Times'
(summary)
-
Handke, Peter
-
Theatrical Experiments
(summary)
In the following essay, Firda examines the techniques Handke uses to explore language in his plays.
-
Offending The Audience
(summary)
In the following essay, Hern discusses the theatrics involved in Offending the Audience and how this play differs from standard theatrical productions of the time.
-
Criticism: Kaspar
-
Kaspar
(summary)
In the following essay, Hern discusses Kaspar, comparing it to The Living Theatre's production of Frankenstein, as well as to The Bald Prima Donna by Eugene Ionesco.
-
Kaspar
(summary)
In the following essay, Schlueter discusses Handke's study of language in the play Kaspar.
-
Peter Handke's Kaspar: A Study of Linguistic Theory in Modern Drama
(summary)
In the following essay, Herrick discusses language and its limitations in Handke's Kaspar and gives a comparison to The Chairs by Eugene Ionesco.
-
‘Think What You Are Saying’: Verbal Politics in the Early Plays of Handke and Kroetz
(summary)
In the following essay, Malkin compares the play Kaspar to Franz Xaver Kroetz's dramas Stallerhof and Geisterbahn.
-
Dramaturgies of Sprachkritik: Rainer Werner Fassbinder's Blut Am Hals Der Katze and Peter Handke's Kaspar.
(summary)
In the following essay, Barnett discusses how Kaspar has become a modern classic through its exploration of language and unique staging techniques.
-
Kaspar
(summary)
-
Criticism: Der Ritt üEber Den Bodensee (The Ride Across Lake Constance)
-
The Truth about Lake Constance
(summary)
In the following review, Kaufman discusses theatrical stagings in the 1930s, as well as tie-ins to German movie stars whom director John Spitzer uses for his adaption of Handke's The Ride across Lake Constance, performed by the Fradulent Production.
-
The Ride Across Lake Constance
(summary)
In the following essay, Hern discusses the question of sanity versus insanity in Handke's work The Ride Across Lake Constance, comparing it to previous Handke plays such as Kaspar and My Foot My Tutor.
-
The Truth about Lake Constance
(summary)
-
Die UnvernüNftigen Sterben Aus (They Are Dying Out)
(summary)
In the following review, Koehler commends Rolf Brauneis's debut directorial effort for bringing Peter Handke's complex, expressionistic play "The Unreasonable Are Dying Out" to life on a Los Angeles stage, highlighting Brauneis's successful adaptation of Handke's rich, imagistic language and his ability to elicit powerful performances from the cast.
-
Challenging the Arrogance of Power
(summary)
In the following essay, Metcalf discusses Handke's usage of mythology and language to establish a quasi-fairy tale-like structure in Das Spiel vom Fragen.
-
The Drama before Language Intervenes
(summary)
In the following review, Riding discusses the production of Handke's The Hour We Knew Nothing of Each Other and explains how this wordless play, orchestrated by director Luc Bondy, uses sound and actions to evoke profound drama and introspection on the human condition.
-
Die Stunde Da Wir Nichts Voneinander Der WuβTen: (The Hour We Knew Nothing Of Each Other
(summary)
In the following essay, Nordmann compares the works of Botho Strauss with Peter Handke, focusing on Handke's play The Hour We Knew Nothing of Each Other.
-
Die Fahrt Im Einbaum Oder Das Stuck Zum Film Vom Krieg
(summary)
In the following review, Reinhold Grimm critiques Handke's Die Fahrt im Einbaum oder Das Stuck zum Film vom Krieg, arguing that the play lacks a coherent plot and convincing character development, ultimately concluding it is a lightweight addition to Handke's body of work, marred by unoriginal borrowings and ineffective narrative techniques.
-
Theatrical Experiments
(summary)
- Further Reading