Discussion Topic
Analysis of how Père Goriot critiques and reflects early-nineteenth-century French society
Summary:
Père Goriot critiques early-nineteenth-century French society by highlighting the corrupting influence of money and social ambition. It reflects societal issues such as class disparity, moral decay, and the pursuit of wealth at the expense of human values. The novel exposes how characters manipulate and betray each other for social advancement, painting a bleak picture of the period's social dynamics.
What themes in Père Goriot reflect the French society of its time?
One of the themes of the story is the overriding importance of fundamental values. Père Goriot, once a successful, wealthy man, is now completely down on his luck, forced to sell everything he owns to keep his spoiled, greedy daughters in a style to which they've become accustomed.
In this rapidly changing society, Goriot's experience is by no means unusual. In the France of Napoleon III, there were vast fortunes to be won and lost as France experienced a dizzying economic transformation. In the process, however, many of the old values were lost, and it's the loss of those values that Balzac represents through Goriot's sad predicament. In an ever-changing industrialized economy, where money and status are everything, Goriot's quiet dignity has no place. Nonetheless, he still remains true to himself despite everything. The power of the unrequited love he has for his daughters remains as strong as ever, right up until his dying day.
One of the most significant themes of the novel is the sacrifice that Pere Goriot embraces for his daughters and how it is not reciprocated. While the legend of the old man emerges out of conjecture and presupposition, it is evident that Goriot does just about anything for his daughters. He is of the belief that “Some day you will find out that there is far more happiness in another's happiness than in your own.” This theme of unconditional love and support is repudiated in the Paris that surrounds him. In this world, individuals stake their own territory and embrace the reality of upward social mobility. Goriot's daughters are far more concerned with their own potential advancement and name more than they are with their father's devotion. After he has outlasted his usefulness to them, the girls simply move on from it. Balzac develops this theme of love and rejection in Goriot's characterization:
My real life is in my two girls, you see; and so long as they are happy and smartly dressed, and have soft carpets under their feet, what does it matter what clothes I wear or where I lie down of a night? I shall never feel cold so long as they are warm...
Goriot's love for his daughters and the fact that it is never really reciprocated is a reflection of the Parisian world of the time period. It is a realm where social advancement was shown priority over emotional loyalty and connective bonds. This theme of both love and its rejection is of central importance in the novel and relevant to the time period of post- Revolutionary Paris.
Another theme that is evident in the narrative is the collision between urban and rural notions of the good. Rastignac comes form the rural setting and is awed by what he sees in Paris. He is socially awkward, and viewed as an outsider. Through the tutelage of Madame de Beauséant and Vautrin's insight, Rastignac learns how to manipulate people and settings to his advantage. He recognizes that the world his past is no longer the world of the present and his declaration at the end of the novel, a battle between he and the illuminated world of metropolitan Paris, is a reflection of how he has moved from outsider to insider. Rastignac has rejected his own provincial past and has become the embodiment of the urban social climber. His transformation is the embodiment of a condition of life in Paris and French society of the time.
Why is Père Goriot a critique of early–nineteenth-century French society?
Balzac's novel is a critique of the early nineteenth century, following the fall of Napoleon and the Bourbon Restoration. The drama opens in 1819; Balzac writes:
Now and again there are tragedies so awful and so grand by reason of the complication of virtues and vices that bring them about, that egotism and selfishness are forced to pause and are moved to pity; but the impression that they receive is like a luscious fruit, soon consumed.
Balzac sets the stage for his tragedy of selfishness and self-centeredness—traits that he believes characterize France at this time. The three main characters, M. Goriot, Eugene de Rastignac, and M. Vautrin, all of whom live in Mme. Vauquer's boardinghouse, symbolize the forces in France at the time.
M. Goriot is a character deserving of pity, but, as Balzac writes, "Stately Paris ignores the existence of these faces bleached by moral or physical suffering." Beneath the glamorous facade of the city, Goriot lives in poverty, consuming only soup, vegetables, and boiled beef each day. He lives in penury to support his two selfish daughters, who seem to care very little for their father.
Eugene de Rastignac, a law student, symbolizes the way in which newcomers to Paris during this time yearned for the riches around them and became corrupted by the city. As Balzac writes about Rastignac, "If he begins by admiring the procession of carriages on sunny afternoons in the Champs-Elysees, he soon reaches the further stage of envying their owners." Rastignac begins to envy the wealth he sees around him. He begins to be corrupted by his cousin, Mme. de Beauseant, who tells him, "The more cold-blooded your calculations, the further you will go. Strike ruthlessly; you will be feared." She wants him to befriend Mme. Delphine de Nucingen, one of M. Goriot's selfish daughters, to make her fall in love with him in an attempt to get other rich women to fall in love with him.
Later, M. Vautrin tries to convince Rastignac to kill the son of Taillefer so that Rastignac can marry Mme. Victorine, Taillefer's daughter who will be wealthy once her brother is out of the way. M. Vautrin tries to convince Rastignac that he should use women as stepping stones toward social advancement. Rastignac refuses.
In the end, however, Rastignac, having witnessed Father Goriot's death without his daughters by his side, loses all his idealism. He sets off to be with Delphine, M. Goriot's daughter, who has enchanted him with her beauty. Balzac writes of Rastignac at the end of the novel, "His eyes turned almost eagerly to the space between the column of the Place Vendome and the cupola of the Invalides; there lay the shining world that he had wished to reach." In the end, Rastignac has become like all the other competitive Parisians around him. Balzac's novel is an indictment of the corruption and mercenary attitude of France at the time.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.