Analysis
Penelope Gilliatt’s short fiction exemplifies the twentieth-century phenomenon of the de-centered narrative. Her stories often disregard traditional plot structures, focusing instead on themes such as Slavic culture, gourmet dining, and music appreciation, among others. Gilliatt’s works are known for their thematic continuity and recurring motifs, such as the frequent use of the skull image in her collection What’s It Like Out?.
The De-centered Narrative
Gilliatt’s fiction often challenges the traditional Aristotelian narrative structure, which is characterized by a beginning, middle, and end. Instead, her stories eliminate or eschew one or more of these narrative stages, leading to a form of storytelling that lacks a cohesive plot. This de-centering of the narrative also disestablishes classical logic, as seen in stories like "Living on the Box," where the limitations of logic are juxtaposed with inherent chaos.
In "Fred and Arthur," for example, the story does not follow a linear progression but instead presents a dyad of Arthur’s life with and without his comedic partner Fred. The absence of a traditional plot structure allows Gilliatt to explore themes more freely, often focusing on the complexities of human relationships and the passage of time.
Recurring Themes and Motifs
Throughout her collections, Gilliatt frequently revisits themes such as the superiority of human intellect over computerized authority, the significance of old age, and the quirks of language and communication. Her stories often incorporate elements of Slavic culture, gourmet cooking, and music appreciation, reflecting her diverse interests and background.
In What’s It Like Out?, the skull motif is prevalent, with the word "skull" appearing in seven of the nine stories. This motif is often associated with themes of death and the passage of time, as explored in "The Tactics of Hunger" and "Come Back If It Doesn’t Get Better." The collection also delves into the theme of old age as a time of psychological and intellectual superiority, as illustrated in stories like "Cliff-Dwellers."
Influence of Social and Technological Trends
Gilliatt’s work often comments on contemporary social and technological trends, such as anticomputerism and Freudianism, as seen in her collection Nobody’s Business. The opening story, "FRANK (Family Robot Adapted to the Needs of Kinship)," satirizes the rise of cybernetics and the mechanistic displacement of humans. This theme is echoed in other stories within the collection that reflect on Freudianism, socialism, and astrology.
The nine stories in Splendid Lives further explore societal themes. The titular story features a racehorse-owning nonagenarian bishop and his octogenarian sister, offering a subtle critique of the British class system. The collection as a whole juxtaposes trades, professions, and the landed gentry, often highlighting the absurdities of class distinctions.
Existential Themes in Quotations from Other Lives
Quotations from Other Lives explores existential themes through stories that often feature characters experiencing social displacement or grappling with their identity. The collection opens with stories that focus on proper names and identity, such as "Break," where a Czechoslovakian man of Scottish ancestry changes his name to align with Nazi-harassed Jews.
Other stories in the collection, like "Teeth" and "When Are You Going Back?," explore social displacement and identity through the lens of relationships and personal choices. The concluding stories in the collection highlight the insights and vitality of the aged, reinforcing Gilliatt’s recurring theme of the superiority of age.
The Role of Language and Wordplay
Gilliatt’s stories are rich with linguistic observations and wordplay, often exploring the peculiarities of language and communication. Her collection Lingo is particularly focused on this theme, with titles like "Hic Haec Hoc" and "Ex Libris" contributing to the thematic effect. The titular story examines the psycholinguistic differences between referring to...
(This entire section contains 740 words.)
Unlock this Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
oneself as "I" versus "one," showcasing Gilliatt’s fascination with language.
Throughout her work, Gilliatt employs wordplay and linguistic humor to explore deeper themes and character interactions. For example, "Hurricane Ethelred" features a plotless story about an oddly matched couple, where the stormy night is described differently by each character, highlighting the subjective nature of language and perception.
Gilliatt’s Signature Style
Penelope Gilliatt’s short fiction is often described as "snippets," "sketches," or "elegant slivers," highlighting her unique narrative style that eschews traditional plot in favor of thematic exploration and character development. Her stories deliver a cinematic impact, often flashing upon the reader’s mind with almost subliminal force. Despite their de-centered nature, Gilliatt’s stories maintain a deliberate structure and thematic continuity, showcasing her command of language and narrative technique.
Criticism by Penelope Gilliatt
-
The Fastest Anachronism in the West
Satyajit Ray Criticism
-
The Great Ray
Satyajit Ray Criticism
-
Vivid Doldrums
Lina Wertmüller Criticism
-
The Stronger Sex
Lina Wertmüller Criticism
-
Woody Allen
Woody Allen Criticism
-
The Current Cinema: 'Love and Death'
Woody Allen Criticism
-
Woody at His Best Yet
Woody Allen Criticism
-
The Current Cinema: 'See You at Mao' and 'Pravda'
Jean-Luc Godard Criticism
-
Dreams of Tight Corners
Robert Altman Criticism
-
New York, New York
Martin Scorsese Criticism
-
Only a Lodger
Roman Polanski Criticism
-
The Current Cinema: 'Stroszek'
Werner Herzog Criticism
-
The Current Cinema: 'The Mackintosh Man'
John Huston Criticism
-
Exile
Rainer Werner Fassbinder Criticism
-
Japanese Friends, a German Agent Provocateur
Rainer Werner Fassbinder Criticism
-
Exile
Rainer Werner Fassbinder Criticism
-
Exile
Rainer Werner Fassbinder Criticism
-
Passion
Richard Lester Criticism
-
Chabrol's Holy Idiots
Claude Chabrol Criticism
-
The Current Cinema: Light-Years Ahead of the Cuckoo Clock
Monty Python Criticism
-
High Bravado from the Lower Depths
Ralph Bakshi Criticism
-
Sweet Coz
Brian De Palma Criticism
-
Farce, Comedy, and a Sag in the Male Loner's Facelift
Buster Keaton Criticism
-
Telling It Like It Isn't
Melvin Van Peebles Criticism
-
Sweetback
Melvin Van Peebles Criticism
-
Genius, Genia, Genium, Ho Hum
Ken Russell Criticism
-
'The Connection'
Shirley Clarke Criticism
-
Glazed
John Landis Criticism
-
In Passage
Carlos Saura Criticism
-
Briefly Noted: 'No Man's Time'
Vassily S(emenovich) Yanovsky Criticism