Themes: Good and Evil
Kino's belief that darkness conceals evil is a common perspective. Yet, one of his significant shortcomings is the conviction that he alone confronts a world split between good and evil. He endeavors to invite good fortune into his life. In his mind, he perceives the music of his personal battle. The Song of the Family resonates in his thoughts when everything is harmonious. The sounds of waves crashing against the shore in the morning and Juana grinding corn or preparing meals are integral to this song. However, when the wind shifts or a member of the oppressive class approaches, he hears the ominous notes of the Song of Evil, described as "the music of the enemy, of any foe of the family, a savage, secret, dangerous melody." Kino listens and reacts to these melodies. When the scorpion begins its descent down the rope towards the baby, he first hears the Song of Evil. Yet, when the priest arrives, he is puzzled despite hearing the same song he associated with the scorpion. He has been taught to view the priest as good, so he searches elsewhere for the source of evil. This melodic device, regardless of its origin, is one of many tools Kino has but fails to fully harness.
Juana possesses a more intricate and mystical understanding of good and evil. She is the one who prays for protection against harmful forces. She employs ancient magic and new Catholic prayers to fend off the scorpion. She does the same when seeking a solution to pay the Doctor. She sees the pearl as the root of evil and believes that men become evil because of it.
Because Kino chooses to confront challenges alone and Juana permits him to do so, evil prevails. The Song of Evil echoes loudly in the silence following the deaths on the mountain—one accidental, three brutal. However, instead of succumbing to evil, Juana and Kino make their way home together, passing the charred remains of their house. "[T]hey were not walking in single file, Kino ahead and Juana behind, as usual, but side by side." As they walk together, the Song of the Family resurges, becoming "as fierce as a cry." Kino even offers Juana the opportunity to discard the pearl, but she refuses. He must silence the source of his madness. He throws the pearl, and as it settles, the Song of Evil "drifted to a whisper and disappeared." Although evil is banished, good has not triumphed, as suggested by the bloody bundle within Juana's shawl.
Expert Q&A
What do the Song of the Pearl and the Song of the Enemy mean to Kino in The Pearl?
In The Pearl, the Song of the Pearl and the Song of the Enemy symbolize different aspects of Kino's life and emotions. The Song of the Enemy represents loss, destruction, and disconnection, reflecting the chaos and danger that threaten his family. The Song of the Pearl embodies hope and potential prosperity but also danger and fear, as it signifies Kino's secret wishes and the risks of pursuing his dreams. These songs reflect Kino's cultural heritage and the deep emotional ties to his ancestral past.
Did Kino's discovery of the pearl lead to more good or bad outcomes?
Kino's discovery of the pearl led to more negative outcomes than positive ones. Initially, Kino believed the pearl would solve his problems and bring wealth. However, it attracted deceitful pearl buyers and thieves, leading to violence and loss. Juana, Kino's wife, warned of its evil, predicting it would bring destruction. Ultimately, the pearl resulted in tragedy, as Kino's son Coyotito was killed, fulfilling Juana's fears and demonstrating the pearl's destructive nature.
Justify the statement "Human beings are naturally opportunistic" with reference to The Pearl.
The statement that "human beings are naturally opportunistic" is exemplified in The Pearl by John Steinbeck, where characters seek to exploit Kino's discovery of the pearl for personal gain. The priest, shopkeepers, doctor, and beggars all exhibit opportunistic behavior, prioritizing their self-interest over principles or prior indifference. This reflects the broader human tendency to seize opportunities for benefit, often disregarding ethical considerations, as seen in their desire to profit from Kino's fortune.
Why does Juana in The Pearl believe "it is not good to want a thing too much" and how does this contrast with the American dream?
"It is not good to want a thing too much."
How does the conclusion of The Pearl complete Steinbeck's moral arguments?
The conclusion of John Steinbeck's The Pearl completes his moral arguments that wealth does not bring happiness and that quick solutions are illusory. Kino's discovery of the pearl leads to violence, division, and tragedy, culminating in the death of his son, Coyotito. The pearl, once a symbol of hope, becomes a "malignant growth," and Kino's final act of discarding it signifies the loss of his soul and the emptiness of material wealth.
What is the relationship between wealth and destruction in Steinbeck's "The Pearl"?
Which theme in "The Pearl" illustrates good vs. evil?
In "The Pearl," the theme of good versus evil is illustrated through the motif of music. Kino experiences the "Song of the Family," representing goodness, and the "Song of Evil," associated with threats like the scorpion. These songs symbolize the universal and cultural battle between good and evil. The pearl itself embodies this duality, holding the potential for both hope and destruction, illustrating how greed can corrupt and lead to evil.
How does greed affect the doctor in The Pearl?
What is the meaning of this quote from John Steinbeck's The Pearl?
"And, as with all retold tales that are in people’s hearts, there are only good and bad things and black and white things and good and evil things and no in-between anywhere."
This quote from Steinbeck highlights the human tendency to simplify complex stories into binary oppositions like good/evil or black/white. It suggests that while such dichotomies can aid understanding, they often oversimplify reality. In The Pearl, this theme is explored as characters and symbols, like the pearl itself, embody both good and evil. Steinbeck challenges readers to recognize the nuanced spectrum between these extremes, rather than seeing them as strictly opposed.
How does the quote "Greed is dehumanizing" relate to John Steinbeck's "The Pearl"?
The quote "Greed is dehumanizing" relates to John Steinbeck's The Pearl by illustrating how greed can corrupt and change individuals. In the story, Kino finds a pearl and initially desires to use it for his family's benefit. However, his growing greed leads him to commit acts he would not have otherwise considered, including murder. This transformation highlights how greed can strip away one's humanity and moral integrity.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.