Student Question
What are the similarities between Kino and the Doctor in The Pearl?
Quick answer:
Kino and the Doctor in The Pearl share similarities despite their opposing social statuses. Both characters have dreams, with the Doctor longing to return to Europe and Kino wishing for a better life for his son. Their pursuits reveal susceptibility to greed, leading to moral corruption. The Doctor exploits villagers for wealth, while Kino becomes violent and desperate. Ultimately, both are changed for the worse, with their dreams leading to their downfall rather than fulfillment.
Without question, the differences between Kino and the Doctor in the book are far greater than the similarities. The Doctor belongs to the class of oppressors, while Kino is the oppressed; this fact in itself places the Doctor and Kino at opposite ends of the spectrum in the village of La Paz. Interestingly, however, there are definite similarities in the characters and situations of the Doctor and Kino. Both characters have a dream, and both are susceptible to the ravages of greed in order to achieve their dreams.
The Doctor longs to return to Europe, but lacks the funds to achieve his desire. He lives in constant dissatisfaction, exploiting the village people, serving only those whom he thinks can pay him. The first time Kino seeks his help, the Doctor rudely turns him away because he does not have money, but when the Doctor hears that Kino has found the great pearl, he suddenly goes to his humble home, hypocritically promising to save Coyotito with his medical expertise. The Doctor will go to great lengths in his unscrupulous pursuit of wealth so that he can make his dreams come true.
Kino's situation is of course not the same as the Doctor's. Kino lives a poor, simple life, while the Doctor lives in luxury. Although it can be argued that Kino's dream of a better life for his son is more legitimate than the Doctor's to return to Europe, the depth to which Kino must sink in pursuit of his dream is strikingly similar to that to which the Doctor descends. Kino becomes consumed with the desire to become rich through the sale of his pearl. In his furious quest to attain what he feels he rightfully deserves, he becomes a violent man, beating his wife when she tries to deter him from his objective, and finally, killing a man. Reflecting the inherent tendency of man never to be satisfied with what he has, Kino soon discovers that "the pearl has become (his) soul...if (he) give(s) it up (he) shall lose (his) soul" (Chapter 5). Both the Doctor and Kino want more than they have been given, and are corrupted by the destructive forces of greed.
How are Kino and the pearl similar in Steinbeck's novel The Pearl?
One can find many similarities between Kino and the pearl in John Steinbeck's novel The Pearl. Regardless of the many similarities, only one stands out above all others by the end of the novel.
At the end of the novel, both Kino and the pearl have changed dramatically. Each have undergone a major transformation. The pearl, no longer desired and now hated by Kino, has become "gray and ulcerous." Kino, similarly, is not the same person he was when he found the pearl. He has become a hated man, a murderer, and an outcast. In the end, when throwing the pearl into the ocean, Kino is trying to rid himself of the changes brought on by the pearl.
While he cannot bring back his son, Coyotito, Kino sees how the pearl has ruined his life. The thing which he thought would bring great fortune would, in actuality, lead to his ultimate downfall. Therefore, another similarity would be, the pearl's inability to change Kino's future for the best (in the same way that Kino (himself) could not change his future for the best either).
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.