Themes: Identity
In "Paul's Case," the theme of identity is central to understanding Paul's struggles and ultimate fate. Paul is a young man who feels alienated from his mundane surroundings and is driven by a desire to become someone else. His identity is shaped by his imagination and a longing for a life of beauty and wealth, which he believes can be achieved through performance and illusion. This quest for identity leads him to make choices that ultimately result in tragedy.
Paul's trips to the stock theater and New York are significant in his exploration of identity. At the theater, he is captivated by the actors and the world they represent, seeing them as examples of the life he desires. He believes that identity is a matter of performance and that he can assume any role he chooses. This belief drives him to steal money and escape to New York, where he surrounds himself with the trappings of wealth. In New York, he feels he has finally become the person he was meant to be, but this identity is fragile and based on illusion.
"He had no sooner entered the hotel than he felt it was impossible to go back; it was as though he were being watched."
Paul's sense of identity is also tied to his understanding of the American Dream. His father dreams of conventional success for him, but Paul equates wealth with beauty and fulfillment. He is a misfit in his environment, with fantasies that are far-removed from reality. This search for self-identity causes him significant suffering, as he is unable to reconcile his dreams with his reality. His deception is not only towards others but also towards himself, as he struggles to find his place in the world.
Ultimately, Paul's suicide is a result of his failed exploration of identity. After a disappointing encounter with a rich boy from Yale and the realization that his theft has been discovered, Paul is left completely alone. The thought of returning to his previous life in Pittsburgh is unbearable. His identity, built on illusion and fantasy, collapses, leaving him with a sense of emptiness and despair. Paul's story highlights the destructive nature of pursuing an identity based on superficial beauty and wealth, and the tragic consequences of living a life detached from reality.
Expert Q&A
What clues suggest causes of Paul's unusual personality in "Paul's Case"?
Is Paul portrayed as gay in "Paul's Case"?
Paul is not explicitly portrayed as gay in "Paul's Case." The story, set in a different historical context, does not provide concrete evidence of his sexuality. Instead, Paul is depicted as a dreamy teenager who escapes his mundane existence through art and fantasy. His attraction to theater and music and his inability to accept his humble background highlight his desire to live a life of illusion. His character is more about escapism than sexuality.
How does Cather use point of view in "Paul's Case" to advance plot, develop characters, and shape the theme?
In "Paul's Case," Cather employs a third-person point of view to maintain a critical distance from Paul, allowing readers to objectively analyze his actions and motivations. This perspective advances the plot by providing an unbiased account of Paul's life and decisions, such as his theft and escape to New York City. Character development focuses solely on Paul, emphasizing his internal struggles and shaping the theme of fantasy versus reality through a straightforward narrative style.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.
