"Paul's Case" is the story of the artistic soul struggling for survival in an artless world.
Cather's theme of how stultifying Calvinism and the new technology after the Industrial Revolution drowns out the aesthetic side of people is conveyed through setting. Symbolizing Paul's longing for love and sentiment in his life is the embroidered hanging of "red worsted" worked by a mother he does not even remember. This hanging depicts George Washington and the words of John Calvin, symbolizing his deprivation of love and the absence of sentiment and beauty that is absent in his life. Critic David Carpenter writes that Cather places these pictures on Paul's wall to stress that
...the uncreative, superficial and life-destroying values perpetuated in the homes of Pittsburgh are essentially American values.
Living in one of the industrial capitals of the United States, Pittsburgh, is Paul, who sits on the lowest step of the...
Unlock
This Answer NowStart your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
front "stoop" on Sundays as his father talks with neighbors. While most of the conversation does not interest him because it is about the steel industry and money, Paul enjoys hearing of the "legends of the iron kings," whose money buys them passage to Venice and sail on yachts on the Mediterranean. But, this narrative is interrupted by the other men who discuss mundane issues.
This industrial, insensitive world is what Paul rejects; instead, he eschews what he considers "the guise of ugliness." Paul seeks "the fairy world of art" that has "all the allurement of a secret love" because this world feeds his artistic soul that of his teachers only the "drawing-master" has recognized. He sits long hours in the theaters and he frequents the picture gallery at the concert hall, losing himself in the delight of envisioning the streets of Paris and Venice, centers of great art culture.
The theater and Carnegie Hall are where Paul feels he "really lives." This world is Paul's "fairy tale." And, this world is where the natural one seems ugly to him because Paul feels that "a certain element of artificiality seemed to him necessary in beauty." This, too, is an environment which Paul finds impossible to give up as it provides him a "delicious excitement" that stirs his heart and feeds his soul. Outside of this environment, Paul is surrounded by what he perceives in the school and home in Pittsburg as an antagonist setting, one that would steal beauty and aesthetic pleasure from him.
How do the settings contribute to the overall meaning of "Paul's Case"?
After Paul's inquisition at school, he goes to his job as an usher at Carnegie Hall. First, he goes to the picture gallery, knowing it will be deserted. The paintings "always exhilarated him." In school, he is defiant and insular. But in the theater and art gallery, he is enthralled and opens himself up. Prior to the show, he gets "lost" while staring at a "blue Rico." Paul is completely at home and content in the theater:
He was a model usher; gracious and smiling he ran up and down the aisles; nothing was too much trouble for him; he carried messages and brought programs as though it were his greatest pleasure in life, and all the people in his section thought him a charming boy, feeling that he remembered and admired them.
It is not the symphony that draws Paul in. It is the overall atmosphere of the theater. It is the notion that this is a place where an alternate reality, albeit fake, is created. "He felt a sudden zest of life; the lights danced before his eyes and the concert hall blazed into unimaginable splendor."
Paul would hang out near the Schenley Hotel because that's where the more famous actors and actresses would stay. In this environment as well, Paul is able to "leave schoolmasters and dull care behind him forever."
Paul reluctantly goes home to his "horrible yellow wallpaper, the creaking bureau with the greasy plush collarbox," illustrating his distaste for his home and his room in particular. Paul also hates his neighborhood. All of the houses look the same and to him, the culture is "a shuddering repulsion for the flavorless, colorless mass of everyday existence." Everything about his home life is dull, unappealing, and depressing.
Paul wants to escape from his daily life. The theater is a place of art, where music and stories are created and performed. It is literally a place where fiction is created. This is what Paul is infatuated with: the idea of another world:
It was at the theater and at Carnegie Hall that Paul really lived; the rest was but a sleep and a forgetting. This was Paul's fairy tale, and it had for him all the allurement of a secret love. The moment he inhaled the gassy, painty, dusty odor behind the scenes, he breathed like a prisoner set free, and felt within him the possibility of doing or saying splendid, brilliant, poetic things.
The narrator even describes the stage door at the Carnegie as the "portal of Romance." By comparison, Paul finds the schoolroom repulsive. When Paul's parents and teacher bar him from the theater, he must find another alternate world. So, he goes to New York City.
He stays at the Waldorf and revels in the luxury of his room. Here, at the Waldorf and the Metropolitan, Paul feels like he is with "his people." All of his depressed thoughts about school and home are gone:
He was now entirely rid of his nervous misgivings, of his forced aggressiveness, of the imperative desire to show himself different from his surroundings. He felt now that his surroundings explained him. Nobody questioned the purple; he had only to wear it passively. He had only to glance down at his attire to reassure himself that here it would be impossible for anyone to humiliate him.
When Paul learns that his father is coming to get him, he loses all hope. He can not bear to return to his dull, oppressive life on Cordelia Street. Place and culture play a huge role in Paul's story. He can not stand the day to day life of suburban families and the repetitious nature of school as well. He only allows himself to be happy in luxurious buildings and in the artificial world of the theater.