Paul Weller Criticism
Paul Weller, a renowned British songwriter, stands out for his influential role in the band The Jam, which, although linked to the Punk and New Wave scenes, distinguished itself through Weller's incisive, socially conscious lyrics. The band's aesthetic borrowed from 1960s mod culture, featuring a minimalist look that contrasted sharply with the flamboyance of 1970s rock stars. While musically influenced by bands like The Who, The Jam's sound remained fresh and energetic, appealing particularly to a younger audience. As noted by Brian Harrigan, Weller's songwriting and musicianship elevated the band beyond their contemporaries. His lyrics addressed themes such as corruption, alienation, and class conflict, resonating deeply with young adults' experiences and aspirations.
Despite The Jam's immense success in England, they achieved only a cult following in the United States. Critics, however, including David Fricke, regard Weller as one of the New Wave movement's finest songwriters. His work often channels articulate anger and working-class concerns, as explored in Adam Sweeting's analysis of Weller's emotional depth and social commentary. Weller's ability to reflect and critique societal issues without succumbing to clichés ensures his enduring significance in contemporary music history.
Contents
-
Who? It's the Jam
(summary)
In the following essay, Brian Harrigan examines the Jam’s commercial potential as a "new wave" band distinct from punk, praising Paul Weller's songwriting and musicianship for elevating their music beyond that of their contemporaries, while encouraging listeners to overcome their biases and appreciate the band's innovative work.
-
Jam Shakes Like This
(summary)
In the following essay, Dan Oppenheimer examines the Jam's debut album In the City, praising Paul Weller's intriguing lyrics and the band's energetic, working-class sound that subtly challenges authority without succumbing to the clichés of rebellion.
-
Dave Marsh
(summary)
In the following essay, Dave Marsh highlights the significant influence of the Who on the Jam, particularly through the creative lens of Paul Weller, while also noting the band's unique penchant for provocative vulgarity that rivals contemporaries like Patti Smith.
-
Jam: Mod and Modern
(summary)
In the following essay, Chris Brazier critiques The Jam's album "This Is the Modern World," arguing that while it attempts to blend modern themes with 1960s influences, the album ultimately lacks innovation and depth, with Paul Weller's songwriting showing potential but needing to move beyond its Sixties roots.
-
This Is the Modern World
(summary)
In the following essay, Ken Emerson argues that Paul Weller's album This Is the Modern World shows a significant evolution in Weller's sensibility towards a more reflective and resigned tone, drawing parallels with the works of Pete Townshend and Ray Davies.
-
The Jam Ain't Punks—Ain't Kinks Either
(summary)
In the following essay, Ed Ward argues that while The Jam's album All Mod Cons showcases both their lyrical prowess and inconsistency, it ultimately represents a transitional phase for the band as they struggle to define their musical direction distinct from punk or new wave influences.
-
All Mod Cons
(summary)
In the following review, Dave Marsh critiques Paul Weller's album "All Mod Cons" for its lack of personal vision, pretentious songwriting, and failure to convey a sense of triumph and identity in rock music, despite its attempts at fantasy and nostalgia.
-
Taking Stock
(summary)
In the following essay, Paulo Hewitt examines Paul Weller's thematic evolution in "Setting Sons," highlighting his shift from punk's rebelliousness to a more reflective exploration of social and political issues through storytelling, particularly focusing on the divisive effects of political systems on personal relationships within the album's concept framework.
-
The Jam: Orwell Rocks
(summary)
In the following essay, Richard Hogan argues that Paul Weller's album Setting Sons showcases his ambitious lyrical depth and thematic exploration of societal issues, suggesting that despite its lack of mainstream American success, the Jam's focus on language and arrangement deserves greater recognition.
-
Winkle-Pickers into the Void: The Jam is Packed Off to America
(summary)
In the following essay, Simon Frith examines Paul Weller's evolution from celebrating youthful street culture to a more sophisticated disillusionment with societal systems in The Jam's music, highlighting the band’s critique of punk romanticism and exploration of themes such as cultural waste and class consciousness.
-
Setting Sons
(summary)
In the following essay, Tom Carson contends that Paul Weller's album Setting Sons marks his artistic maturity, reflecting a complex and literate examination of class conflict and societal decay through vivid, politically charged compositions that balance anger, irony, and vulnerability.
-
Interview with Paul Weller
(summary)
In the following essay, Paulo Hewitt explores Paul Weller's evolving perspective on his lyrics, highlighting Weller's struggle to articulate the meanings behind his songs and his shift towards a more optimistic outlook, despite acknowledging the bleakness and realism in his earlier work.
-
Get Weller Soon
(summary)
In the following essay, Adam Sweeting examines Paul Weller's songwriting, noting the emotional depth and social commentary of his lyrics, while acknowledging that Weller's romanticism can lead to oversimplification, and praising songs like "Ghosts" and "Carnation" for their haunting imagery and introspective revelations.
-
The Gift
(summary)
In the following essay, Steve Pond critiques Paul Weller's album "The Gift" as a solid offering for fans, while highlighting its thematic focus on British workers' issues and noting its varied sound, yet he suggests it lacks the breakthrough potential to widen the band's appeal.
-
David Fricke
(summary)
In the following essay, David Fricke argues that Paul Weller's music, especially with The Jam, effectively channels articulate anger and working-class concerns, while acknowledging the challenges of maintaining authenticity and impact in the face of potential personal and societal complacency.
-
The Long Goodbye
(summary)
In the following essay, Paolo Hewitt argues that Paul Weller's decision to disband The Jam exemplifies their forward-looking ethos and integrity, as "Dig The New Breed," their final live album, encapsulates the band's passion and honesty that resonated deeply with their audience, distinguishing them from other bands of their era.