In the story "The Parsley Garden," young Al Condraj's impulsive decision to pocket a hammer from Woolworth one August day spirals into a significant internal conflict. Initially driven by a simple desire to build, this act becomes a pivotal point in Al's understanding of societal rules and personal integrity. The incident compels him to confront feelings of shame, powerlessness, and ultimately, the journey toward maturity.

An Unexpected Turn of Events

Al's day begins with the innocent intent to "break the monotony" and create something tangible. However, his seemingly minor theft of a hammer, priced at just ten cents, quickly devolves into a humiliating experience. Though the store manager releases him without further consequence, Al is left grappling with a deep sense of shame and embarrassment. This intense emotional response sows seeds of resentment toward adult figures of authority, propelling him toward a period of self-examination and growth.

The Struggle with Vengeance and Shame

Initially, Al fantasizes about exacting revenge on the young man who apprehended him, but his courage evaporates as he stands outside the store. Frustration mounts as he reasons that if he is labeled a thief, he might as well possess the hammer. Yet, returning home, Al is consumed by feelings of defeat and acute shame. When he confides in his mother, she reprimands him but offers money to purchase the hammer legally. Al declines, insisting he no longer desires it, revealing his complex struggle with pride and morality.

A Solitary Night of Reflection

Al finds himself isolated in his turmoil, with no one to share or understand his predicament. His friend, Johnny Gale, is too engrossed in his work at Foley’s Packing House to lend an ear. As night descends, Al's mind swirls with thoughts of drastic measures like murder and a descent into crime, underscoring his desperation to resolve the conflict within himself.

Resolution in the Garden

As his mother and their neighbor return home and prepare dinner with fresh garden vegetables, Al occupies himself by building a bench. This physical labor provides a space for contemplation and partial resolution. Working a full day at Woolworth to earn the hammer becomes Al's way of reclaiming his dignity. Additionally, he stands firm in his decision to reject a job offer from the very men he resents, despite its attractive pay. His mother, though perplexed, respects his choice. The combination of hard work and the tranquil garden begins to cleanse him of his humiliation, though a lingering animosity toward the men who caught him remains, acknowledging their necessity in doing their jobs."