Failure of Communism
The novel’s many personal tragedies stem from the victorious communists' efforts to impose Marxist principles on their society. According to Marxism, every society experiences a conflict between the exploiters—such as landowners or factory owners (the bourgeoisie)—and the exploited, which includes peasants and the working class. In the story, the communists' "land reform" disastrously fails, leading to significant injustice and "sowing only chaos and misery in its wake," particularly in Que's village. Here, even those with small landholdings are branded as enemies of the peasants, despite never exploiting anyone. Their land is seized arbitrarily at the command of Que's brother, Chinh, who strictly adheres to Marxist class struggle ideology. Chinh's unwavering commitment to this ideology fosters and perpetuates injustice within his own family. He prioritizes ideology over familial bonds, denouncing his brother-in-law, Ton, merely because Ton’s family employed farm workers, categorizing them as part of the exploiting class. Chinh’s ideological zeal leads to Ton's exile and death, Que's suffering, lifelong animosity from Ton's sister, Tam, and leaves Hang growing up without a father.
In addition to the rigid enforcement of Marxist theories without considering local realities or common sense, the Communist Party in the novel is portrayed as corrupt. Chinh and his Party associates exploit official trips to Russia to profit by trading luxury goods on the black market. This hypocrisy is apparent in Moscow when Chinh, fully aware of these activities, scolds his colleagues, insisting they "must behave in an absolutely exemplary manner while you are in this brother country." Moreover, Chinh enjoys the privileges granted to government officials, owning a new Japanese television set, which he refuses to sell even to help raise funds for his sister Que, who has recently had a leg amputated.
Additionally, there is the corruption of Duong, the vice president of Aunt Tam's village, who unlawfully seizes land. The strongest critique of the communist rulers' hypocrisy comes from a student Hang refers to as the Bohemian. In Khoa's Moscow apartment, the Bohemian criticizes Chinh: "They decreed their thousands of rules, their innumerable edicts, each one more draconian than the last. But, in the shadows, they paddled around in the mud, without faith or law." The Bohemian argues that Party officials were not concerned with the nation's welfare but with power and personal benefits. This theme is evident in Chinh's life. For instance, although he pretends to care about his sister’s well-being, he secures her a factory position because he believes her being a street vendor damages his prospects of advancing in the Party. It is ironic that Chinh lectures his sister about prioritizing her class’s interests over her own, while he himself acts in contradiction to this under the guise of ideological purity.
Loneliness, Love, and the Bonds of Family
The devastation wrought by land reform, which led to the persecution and eventual death of Hang's father, Ton, leaves Hang with deep feelings of isolation and permanently fractures two families. Ridiculed by her neighbors for being without a father, Hang reflects on her childhood, describing it as "like a ball kicked across the road, aimless, without any purpose." She grows up lacking self-esteem, unaware of her father's identity, and likens herself to "an anonymous weed [that] grows between the cracks of a wall." She carries a persistent sense of shame and injustice. One night, she dreams of being beaten, and this feeling of random oppression continues as she matures. She feels embarrassed about her connection to her uncle, who has caused her family significant distress. During a visit to him in Moscow, she describes her life as "this slow torture, this bottomless sadness." At...
(This entire section contains 510 words.)
Unlock this Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
twenty, she notices the "dark circles of misery" under her eyes in the mirror and sees the same despair in an entire generation of young Vietnamese, who feel they have no future in their society.
A child often mirrors its mother's experiences, and Que's life has been similarly shattered by the loss of her husband. For years, she has nothing to live for and no one to love. Hang perceives this, noticing that her mother's beauty and youth faded early, "From sorrow. For nothing. For no one." There is a profound sadness in Que's existence as a widow struggling to survive on society's margins. She attempts to cope with her husband's loss by seeking acceptance from her brother's family, showering gifts on her young nephews, and attending to Chinh's needs as best she can. This is how she finds meaning in her life, by clinging to family bonds, even though Chinh has treated her poorly and is, in fact, the source of much of her suffering.
Aunt Tam also leads a solitary life, continually mourning her lost brother. She carries a sense of injustice with her daily, which significantly affects her peace of mind. As Hang observes about her aunt, "This past had poisoned life for her, taking with it all joy, all warmth, all maternal feeling, all the happiness the world might have offered her." The love that Aunt Tam shows Hang, much like Que's dedication to her brother, emphasizes the importance of family ties. "She's a drop of his blood," Tam remarks about Hang when she first meets her. Aunt Tam even takes in her distant relative, Madame Dua, because "a single drop of our own blood, even a hundred times diluted, is worth more than swamp water."
It is easy to comprehend why both women are so eager to preserve family connections in a culture that highly values honoring and respecting ancestors. In this society, ancestors are often revered and prayed to during challenging times. When Que finds herself alone as a young woman, she lights incense and prays to her ancestors, pleading for their protection. Likewise, Aunt Tam maintains an altar dedicated to the ancestors in the heart of her living room.