Summary

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

In "The Pagan Rabbi," the story unfolds through the eyes of an unnamed narrator, a Jewish man in his mid-thirties. He's confronted with the shocking news of Isaac Kornfeld, a childhood acquaintance, having taken his own life at only thirty-six. Both men shared a unique connection through their fathers, who were not only friends but also professional adversaries in the rabbinical world. The narrator, having left rabbinical school to marry Jane and work in her father’s fur business, later transitioned into a bookselling career, severing ties with his family in the process.

The Repercussions of a Suicide

The narrator is drawn to the location of Isaac's death—a tree where Isaac hanged himself. Though the two weren't particularly close, Isaac had been a consistent customer at the narrator's bookstore, ordering books and exchanging brief notes with each transaction. This correspondence revealed that Isaac was the father of seven daughters. Despite their distant relationship, the news of Isaac's suicide propels the narrator to piece together the events leading to it.

A Visit to Sheindal

Intrigued, the narrator visits Sheindal, Isaac's widow, whom he had only met once at her wedding but immediately felt a connection to. Sheindal, marked by a harrowing past as a survivor of a concentration camp, recounts her observations of Isaac's peculiar behavior before his death. She inquires about the kinds of books Isaac ordered, specifically those concerning plants or agriculture. Sheindal describes Isaac’s growing obsession with plant life and nature, as well as his tendency to tell odd bedtime stories to their children, suggesting a deep involvement in something beyond his rabbinical duties.

The Mysterious Notebook

Eventually, Sheindal presents the narrator with a small notebook found on Isaac after his death. Hoping for answers, the narrator reads its contents at the park beneath the tree where Isaac died. However, the notes appear to be mundane scholarly thoughts on literature and philosophy, leaving the narrator frustrated and suspecting Sheindal of trying to "punish" him for seeking answers about Isaac's suicide.

Unveiling the "Love Letter"

Feeling upset and deceived, the narrator returns to Sheindal’s home to return the notebook. She then asks him to read a "love letter" from Isaac, initially overlooked. Despite his hesitation, Sheindal reads the letter aloud. It reveals Isaac's philosophical and theological reflections on Nature and the soul, and describes an encounter with a mythical creature, Iripomoñdeeléa, perceived as emerging from Nature at the site of his death. This revelation shocks the narrator, as it suggests Isaac's existential struggle and unexpected turn toward pagan beliefs.

Faith, Love, and Disillusionment

The letter illustrates Isaac's internal conflict between his rabbinical identity and newfound pagan affinities. Sheindal, revulsed by the revelation, sees her husband as a traitor to their faith. In contrast, the narrator feels a certain understanding of Isaac’s philosophical struggles. He urges Sheindal to forgive Isaac, but her resentment is palpable. Initially contemplating a future with Sheindal, the narrator becomes disillusioned by her inability to empathize with Isaac's spiritual crisis. Consequently, he advises her to find peace, stating Isaac's soul remains tied to the park.

Concluding Thoughts

In the wake of this encounter, the narrator returns home, decisively flushing his houseplants down the toilet in a symbolic gesture of severing ties with Isaac’s mystical views. The narrative reflects on themes of faith, existential quests, and the complexity of human relationships, highlighting the narrator's journey from curiosity to a deeper understanding of life's enigmatic nature.

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Next

Themes

Loading...