Chapter 11 Summary
Ponyboy’s doctors say he has to stay in bed for a whole week. He is not the kind of person who usually sits still, so he has trouble following the doctors’ orders. He reads and draws pictures, but he is bored. One day he looks through Soda’s old yearbooks. He finds a picture he recognizes slightly, but he is not sure why. When he reads the name, he finds out it is Bob.
Ponyboy studies the picture for some time, trying to imagine what kind of person Bob was when he was not drinking and fighting. He knows that Cherry thought he was sweet and funny, a good friend, and a leader. Ponyboy wonders about Bob’s parents. Do they hate Ponyboy and Johnny? Ponyboy hopes so. He hopes that Bob’s parents do not pity the greasers as victims of their environment. He would rather be hated than pitied.
Darry comes in and tells Ponyboy that Randy, Bob’s friend, is there for a visit. Darry does not seem to want to let Randy in, but Ponyboy gives his permission. Randy sits down, looking embarrassed, but Ponyboy cannot bring himself to be ashamed of his humble house and poor neighborhood. After a few conversational false starts, Randy brings up Ponyboy’s hearing, which he and Ponyboy are both required to attend. Ponyboy is trying not to think about the hearing, but Randy insists on discussing it.
Randy is worried about his father, who is disappointed that Randy got himself mixed up in such a bad situation. Ponyboy cannot understand this. He knows Randy’s father can afford to pay any fine the judge levies. To Ponyboy it seems stupid for Randy to worry when he has nothing to lose. Ponyboy explains that his own parents are dead and that he and Soda may be placed in foster homes if the judge decides that Darry is not a good enough guardian. Randy did not know that Ponyboy’s parents were dead, and he is upset when he hears it. He tries to reassure Ponyboy, saying that only Johnny, Bob’s killer, could have gotten in real trouble.
Hearing this, Ponyboy protests: “I had the knife. I killed Bob.” When Randy tries to set him straight, Ponyboy is upset. He insists that he killed Bob and that Johnny is not dead. Darry makes Randy leave. Darry explains that Ponyboy is confused about everything that has happened and that the doctor says he needs time to heal.
Expert Q&A
What does Ponyboy think when he sees Bob's picture in the yearbook?
Upon seeing Bob's picture in the yearbook, Ponyboy begins to perceive Bob as a human being, not just a tough Soc. He ponders about Bob's personal life, questioning if he had a loving family or siblings. Inspired by Cherry's positive view of Bob, Ponyboy contemplates if there were redeeming qualities in Bob. This moment marks a significant shift in Ponyboy's understanding of the Soc and Greaser dynamic, realizing they might be more alike than different.
Why does Ponyboy tell Randy that he killed Bob?
Ponyboy tells Randy he killed Bob due to trauma and confusion. This claim likely stems from his mental state following the traumatic events, including the deaths of his friends. Ponyboy is suffering from possible PTSD, causing him to misremember the incident where Johnny actually stabbed Bob. His denial about Johnny's death further distorts his memory. The judge, recognizing Ponyboy's mental instability, avoids questioning him directly about the stabbing during the trial.
Why did Ponyboy want Bob's parents to hate him and the other greasers in The Outsiders?
Ponyboy prefers Bob's parents to hate him rather than pity him because hatred implies equality, whereas pity suggests condescension and a belief in the greasers' inferiority. For Ponyboy, a proud greaser, pity is degrading and positions him as lesser, while hatred acknowledges him as an equal and worthy rival. He rejects the notion that his socioeconomic status diminishes his worth, believing the greasers are resilient and dignified.
In The Outsiders Chapter 11, why was Ponyboy more comfortable with Randy seeing his house than his friends?
Ponyboy is more comfortable with Randy seeing his house because Randy's opinion does not matter to him, as he is an outsider. In contrast, Ponyboy cares about his school friends' opinions because they come from nicer homes and their views hold significance for him. His house is run-down, making him feel embarrassed in front of his middle-class friends, but not in front of Randy, whom he considers unimportant.
Ponyboy's preference for hate over pity in The Outsiders
Ponyboy prefers hate over pity because he finds pity demeaning and a sign of weakness. He feels that being pitied is more humiliating than being hated, as pity implies helplessness and inferiority, which he resents. Hate, on the other hand, acknowledges his strength and existence, allowing him to maintain his pride and sense of identity.
The significance of what Darry calls Ponyboy at the end of The Outsiders
At the end of The Outsiders, Darry calling Ponyboy "little buddy" signifies a deepening of their brotherly relationship. It shows Darry's affection and his role as a protector, highlighting the bond and understanding that has developed between them throughout the novel.
Ponyboy's Denial of Johnny's Role in Bob's Death
In S.E. Hinton's The Outsiders, Ponyboy denies Johnny's role in Bob's death and Johnny's death itself as a coping mechanism for the trauma he has endured. Exhausted and suffering from shock, a concussion, and grief, Ponyboy is in denial, trying to protect himself from the pain of losing his friend. His insistence on these falsehoods reflects his emotional turmoil and the psychological impact of the recent tragic events, highlighting his fragile mental state.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.
