Others See Us masterfully delves into a captivating premise, as is the hallmark of many of Sleator's enchanting tales. He uses scientific musings to unravel the tangled web of conflict within seemingly mundane families. The story revolves around Jared, a young protagonist who acquires the extraordinary power to peer into the minds of others. This newfound ability unveils the deepest thoughts and guarded secrets of his kin, leading him to the startling revelation that people often hide their true selves beneath a veneer of normality.

Sleator's signature style shines through in this suspense-laden narrative, where the gripping plot unfurls with swift momentum. Yet, beyond the mere thrill of events, the novel offers intriguing peeks into the minds of its central figures. Annelise, Jared's cousin, emerges as a chilling portrait of a self-destructive sociopath. Meanwhile, Jared's grandmother stands out as a character of rich complexity and moral ambiguity.

Throughout the unfolding tale, Sleator embarks on an exploration of the human psyche, delving into the extreme measures people take to safeguard their hidden lives. True to his form, the novel culminates in an ending that leaves readers both puzzled and contemplative. Critics like M. P. Dunleavy rightfully hail this work as one of Sleator's finest, a testament to his storytelling prowess.