Themes: Tensions Between Women and Men
Throughout Othello, there is a constant thread of tension between women and men. In its subtlest form, this tension manifests in the somewhat tenuous presence of Desdemona and Emilia in Cyprus, a military encampment that can be viewed as a masculine sphere. In its harsher forms, this tension erupts in expressions of outright misogyny and even violence against women. Throughout the play, discussions occur regarding the differences between man and woman, most notably Iago’s comments in the second act about how all women are prostitutes. This chauvinistic view of women is allowed to exist in the masculine world of the military. It is not surprising that someone as villainous as Iago would maintain this view, and neither Desdemona nor Emilia seem prepared to respond to his claims, whether due to their abhorrence or their baselessness.
It is only in Desdemona’s bedchamber, which can be viewed as a comparatively feminine sphere, that Emilia feels safe to express her own views—namely that women and men are equally sexual, that men wrongfully mistreat their wives, and that sex can be a way for women to reclaim their lives and independence. Unfortunately, there are few such spaces in Cyprus, and Desdemona and Emilia cannot comfortably exist in this masculine world. By the end of the play, both women are killed by the hands of their militant husbands.
Expert Q&A
How does Cassio's view and treatment of women compare to Iago's in Othello?
Cassio's view and treatment of women, while misogynistic, are typical of his era. He respects Desdemona but dismisses Bianca as a mere prostitute, not considering her a serious partner. In contrast, Iago harbors a deep-seated hatred towards all women, viewing them as deceitful and unfaithful. Iago's cruelty extends to manipulating Desdemona and mistreating his wife, Emilia, reflecting his overall misanthropy.
What was the ideal relationship between men and women in Othello?
In Othello, the ideal relationship between men and women is initially based on trust and marital fidelity, as seen in Othello's unwavering trust in Desdemona. However, Iago's manipulations lead to the unraveling of this ideal, resulting in suspicion and betrayal. By the play's end, the relationships are tainted by doubt and mistrust, highlighting the fragility of the idealized bond.
Does the play support or refute Iago's derogatory opinion of women in Othello?
Why is Bianca's survival in Othello, despite being a prostitute, considered ironic?
Bianca's survival in Othello is ironic because, despite being a courtesan, she outlives the "respectable" women, Desdemona and Emilia, who are murdered by their husbands. This twist highlights a social commentary on the unpredictability of fate and the misconception that high social status ensures happiness and safety. Bianca, considered "unclean" and shunned by society, emerges as the sole surviving major female character, challenging societal norms and expectations.
How do Emilia and Desdemona display courage in Othello?
Emilia displays courage in the final scene by accusing Othello of lying and standing up to her husband Iago, despite the risks of challenging men of higher social standing. Her bravery is evident as she defends Desdemona, calling out Iago's deceit. Desdemona shows courage by defying her father's wishes to marry Othello and pleading for her innocence in the face of death, maintaining her integrity even when facing fatal consequences.
How are women represented in Othello and The Duchess of Malfi?
What are contrasting ideas for a thesis about Emilia's independence and rebellion versus Desdemona's submissiveness and naivety in Shakespeare's works?
In Shakespeare's works, Emilia's independence and rebellion contrast with Desdemona's submissiveness and naivety. Emilia, older and more experienced, understands men's complexities and expresses realistic views on marriage and jealousy. Her pragmatic wisdom contrasts with Desdemona's idealistic innocence. This difference highlights two levels of femininity: Emilia's grounded realism versus Desdemona's privileged naivety, reflecting their social standings and marital experiences. Despite her insight, Emilia's actions inadvertently lead to tragedy.
How does Desdemona's divided duty between her father and Othello impact her relationship with Othello?
Desdemona's divided duty between her father and Othello significantly impacts her relationship with Othello, as it introduces doubts and jealousy. Initially, she defies her father to marry Othello, asserting her independence. However, her father's warning that she may deceive Othello too haunts him, leading to mistrust. Othello's perception of Desdemona as a status symbol rather than a true partner further strains their relationship, ultimately contributing to its tragic end.
What are examples of Desdemona and Emilia's abuse in Othello?
An example of Desdemona being abused is Othello killing her because he wrongly believes she has cheated on him. An example of Emilia being abused is Iago bullying her into giving him Desdemona's handkerchief. Iago does not care that it will greatly hurt Emilia to unknowingly be part of a deceptive plot to harm her friend and mistress.
What double standards apply to male and female characters in Othello and two other novels of your choice?
Othello, Middlemarch, and Wuthering Heights are all works that revolve around themes of sexual jealousy in cultures with double standards.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.