Student Question

What's an engaging thesis on Othello using one critical perspective?

Quick answer:

The question requires an analysis of a passage from Othello and the use of the literary terms irony, oxymoron, metaphor, and paradox. Thesis statement: Iago's speech in Act 1, Scene 3 of Othello contains many examples of irony, oxymoron, metaphor, and paradox.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

There are many interesting critical perspectives that could be discussed. Assuming the use of "thesis" in the question means this will be for an essay or other long work, it is important to choose a perspective with a significant amount of evidence that can be discussed. Any of the choices from that list would work; however, some have more material than others.

Perspectives requiring historical analysis can require more external references but also have nearly unlimited arguments that can serve as a thesis. Given the setting of Othello, a postcolonial criticism would be very interesting. Postcolonial criticism looks at the relationship between ruling powers and colonies, generally to show exploitation of the colonies' land. Shakespeare used the long struggle for control of Cyprus between Venice and the Ottoman Empire as part of the setting of Othello. The fact that the hero is an outsider and the villain is a Venetian could be used as the basis for a postcolonial criticism.

A new historicist perspective also incorporates historical evidence. New historicism argues that the social environment of an author when a literary work is written plays a critical role in shaping the meaning of the final piece. Race is prominent in Othello, as the titular character is "Moorish," perhaps African, in a predominantly white city. While slavery in 1604 was not practiced to the extent that it later would be, some Africans had already been brought to England as slaves. These early interactions could be used to analyze Othello's role in the play.

These are just two options from the list, and each criticism has many potential focuses.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What are a few ideas for an interesting focused thesis on Othello employing a critical perspective for an essay? (Deconstruction Criticism, Psychoanalytical Criticism and Marxist Criticism) The essay will be employing only one of these criticisms but multiple ideas would be helpful.

A Marxist analysis of Othello should include a discussion of the class divisions in Othello’s world. Focus on the motivations for the characters’ behavior and the causes of the conflict between them. Othello is a member of the upper class, and Iago is a member of the working class, and Iago is angry at Othello for denying him a promotion and giving it instead to a person of means. Iago embodies the working-class struggle to get ahead, despite the subjugation by the ruling class. He strives for personal advancement, but he is also the victim that responds in a society that institutionalizes oppression. Thus, his actions reflect learned behavior in an unjust and materialistic world.

A psychoanalytical analysis of Othello could focus on the propensity for destructiveness, both in Othello and in Iago. You might discuss whether their destructiveness is the result of trauma or whether it is instead, an instinctive response. Both characters suffer rejection and both exhibit anger and aggressiveness. You might explore whether their responses and reactions are the result of narcissism, and to what extent their failures reflect insecurities they feel about their power and about their desirability in love.

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Last Updated on