Themes: The Idea of Utopia
This story opens with a scene of a festival. There is a richness of detail and evocative language by which Le Guin brings this utopia to life, but, at the same time, the narrator makes it clear that this utopia exists solely within the imagination. Even within the story itself, Omelas is not understood as a real place. Rather, the narrator states that different people might imagine their own particular Omelas and that the world they envision is Omelas as it exists to them. The particulars don't actually matter—what matters is that this is utopia: a place of perfect happiness.
Expert Q&A
What type of society is depicted in Omelas?
In "The Ones Who Walk Away From Omelas," Omelas is a Utilitarian society. This means it is based on defining happiness as the greatest good for the greatest number of people. Because the society is based on this principle, people are able to justify the misery of one child whose suffering is considered necessary for everyone else to have happiness.
Why does the narrator doubt our acceptance of the festival, city, and joy descriptions?
The narrator doubts our acceptance of the festival, city, and joy descriptions because they believe readers struggle to imagine a place as purely good as Omelas. This skepticism is attributed to a cultural tendency to view happiness as naive and pain as intellectually interesting. Consequently, to comprehend Omelas, readers might imagine negative aspects like drug use or the misery of a child, making evil seem necessary. The story suggests embracing certainty like those who leave Omelas for an unimaginable place.
How does the poem "Nothing in Heaven Functions As It Ought" compare and differ from the story "The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas" in their views on perfection?
Both X.J. Kennedy's poem "Nothing in Heaven Functions As It Ought" and Ursula K. Le Guin's story "The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas" explore the theme of imperfect perfection. In Kennedy's poem, even Heaven is portrayed as flawed, challenging the belief that it is a perfect realm. Similarly, Omelas's apparent perfection relies on the suffering of a child. Both works highlight that human-created ideals of perfection are unattainable without underlying flaws or sacrifices.
The nature of Omelas as a utopia or dystopia
The nature of Omelas is complex, blending elements of both utopia and dystopia. On the surface, it appears to be a utopia with its happiness and prosperity. However, the underlying suffering of a single child, on which this happiness depends, reveals its dystopian aspect, highlighting the moral cost of the society's perfection.
What theory is considered for Omelas?
The city of Omelas is a theoretical utopia where the happiness of the majority is contingent upon the suffering of one child. This raises ethical questions about the morality of such a society. The story suggests that Omelas is only perfect in theory, as evidenced by some residents choosing to leave, possibly due to guilt over the child's suffering. Omelas serves as an allegory for modern societies and the treatment of disenfranchised minorities in democracies.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.
