Themes: Class and Fate

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Oliver Twist portrays how the socioeconomic circumstances into which one is born inform and determine one’s fate. Being born poor or an orphan results in a particular set of options for a child in Victorian England. Both Oliver and Rose suffer as a result of their identity as orphans. Oliver never knows love or affection until he is nursed by Mrs. Bedwin at Brownlow’s house. The parochial system treats children like him as a burden. Oliver is lucky to fall into the hands of two generous families who sense his inherent goodness and take care of him. However, most poor orphans are not so fortunate. The lives of the child thieves, like Charley and Jack, and young prostitutes, like Nancy, suggest that growing up poor leads children on a dangerous trajectory. 

Meanwhile, those who are neither poor nor rich look down upon the impoverished, in large part because they need to feel superior to someone else. Bumble is a perfect example of this mentality: he exaggerates his own importance and abuses the little power he has to deride and abuse the paupers he surveys. 

On the other hand, Dickens also depicts generous wealthy characters who take pity on Oliver and Rose and welcome them into their families. A small twist of fate could have changed Oliver’s story completely. If he had not been shot during the robbery and remained subject to Fagin and Sikes, Oliver may not have met Rose Maylie. In some ways, the novel implies that Oliver is simply lucky, but on the other hand Dickens encourages readers to see Oliver as an example of good defeating evil. 

While Oliver and Rose both get happy endings that the novel suggests they deserve, social class and circumstances do play a role in those endings. Rose can only marry Harry Maylie because he lowers his social status; otherwise, she would be seen as an impediment to his name and could hinder his professional progress, regardless of how much they love each other. Oliver can only claim his inheritance through the word of his father’s legitimate son, Monks, who must attest that his father left all of his property to Oliver and his mother, Agnes. While the virtuous characters do earn their rewards, the novel suggests that the society to which they belong is flawed and unjust.

Expert Q&A

Societal problems and Dickens' proposed solutions in Oliver Twist

In Oliver Twist, Charles Dickens highlights societal problems such as poverty, child labor, and the criminal underworld. He proposes solutions like social reform, charity, and compassion towards the poor. Dickens advocates for a more equitable society where the vulnerable are protected and supported through both institutional changes and individual acts of kindness.

What are the main differences between the children and the master in Oliver Twist?

The main differences between the children and the master in Oliver Twist highlight power and control. The master is described as "a fat, healthy man," while the children are pale, thin, and timid due to malnourishment and harsh conditions. The children live in fear, intimidated by the master's authority, which is enforced through violence, as exemplified when Oliver asks for more food. This dynamic underscores the oppressive nature of the workhouse system.

What does Dickens convey about charity in Oliver Twist?

The workhouses in Oliver Twist are an example of the corruption caused by the poor law system. The idea that you could be given a stipend in exchange for performing work was at least a good idea, but the government gave no oversight and its employees embezzled most of the money. Thus, rather than working hard to escape poverty, people would do as little as possible for as long as possible, knowing that they were unlikely to be caught or to lose their job. As a result, there was very little incentive for anyone to perform any work whatsoever.

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Previous

Themes: Children in Poverty

Loading...