Illustration of a marlin in the water

The Old Man and the Sea

by Ernest Hemingway

Start Free Trial

Student Question

How does Santiago's reaction to the Portugese Man-of-War differ from previous reactions in The Old Man and the Sea?

Quick answer:

Santiago's reaction to the Portuguese Man-of-War is marked by disdain, calling it "Agua mala" or "bad water," reflecting his hatred for this creature. This reaction contrasts with his usual respect for nature, as he blames it for scaring away fish and causing painful injuries with its poisonous filaments. Santiago appreciates the beauty of the sea but views the Man-of-War as a deceitful and harmful presence, unlike other sea creatures he admires.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Shortly after he has gone to sea, Santiago watches the sky and the water for signs of fish.  As he does so, his glance onto the surface of the water reveals "the purple, formalized, iridescent, gelatinous bladder of a Portugese man-of-war" that floats closely beside his boat. Hurling an invective after naming it in Spanish--Agua mala [literally "bad water"]. 

There are two reasons why Santiago hates the Portugese man-of-war:

  1. Fish do not want to be near this poisonous creature, so it ruins his opportunities to catch fish.
  2. Countless times, Santiago has been injured by this creature when he has brought in line that on which some of the poisonous filament has attached itself.  Stinging "like a whiplash," this poisonous filament has caused his hands and arms to swell and itch from welts similar to those caused by poison ivy or poison oak.

Furthermore, Santiago feels that although there is...

Unlock
This Answer Now

Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

a certain beauty of the "iridescent bubbles," they are the "falsest thing in the sea" because they hold no value for the fisherman, and they are a negative force against fish that are worthy catches.  For these reasons, he loves to watch the sea turtles, who are of "great value," eat them.

This attitude of Santiago's toward the Portugese men-of-war is truly in keeping with the old fisherman's love of the sea and its denizens, even if he does have a "friendly contempt for the huge, stupid loggerheads who happily eat these creatures. For, the "Agua mala" is, as Santiago calls it, a "whore," a negative force that exploits and poisons the fish, unlike the other inhabitants of the sea.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

How does Santiago react to the Portuguese-Man-of-War in The Old Man and The Sea?

Santiago had a strong respect for nature.  He had learned to read natural signs to help him with his fishing.  He followed the birds in the sky and the smaller fish of the sea to locate his big fish.  However, he hates the Portuguese-man-of-war.  When he sees it near his boat, he says,

“Agua mala….You whore.”  (pg 35)

“Agua mala” means bad water.   The Portuguese-man-of-war was swimming so close to the boat that Santiago could see the tiny fish that were swimming between the filaments.  These fish were immune to the poison of the Portuguese-man-of-war, but humans were not.  Some of the filaments would catch on the fishing lines of the boats, and when the fishermen brought in the lines, they would still get stung, even when the filaments were no longer attached to the gelatinous body.  Santiago would get

“….welts and sores on his arms and hands of the sort that poison ivy or poison oak can give” (pg 36)

The only difference was that the poison of the Portuguese-man-of-war was quick, similar to a whiplash.  The old man enjoyed watching turtles eat the agua mala and, after a storm, he loved to walk on the beach and pop them with his feet.  However, that practice is NOT recommended by those who know that a Portuguese-man-of-war can sting you with its filaments even after it is dead.  There was definitely no love lost there.    

Check out the reference below from National Geographic for some stunning pictures of a Portuguese-man-of-war.

Posted on