Pride
This poem primarily evokes a feeling of pride through vivid imagery of battle, fitting given the Constitution's fame was earned in warfare. The scenes depicted, including those inspired by nature, are intense and powerful: “the battle shout,” “the cannon’s roar,” “her thunders shook,” and “the lightning and the gale.” These lively images accelerate the reader’s heartbeat, much like pride is said to do. Especially in the second stanza, the poem presents the narrative in terms of winners and losers: heroes and victors, the vanquished and the defeated. There is no mention of the complex causes of the War of 1812 or the compromises that led to peace, as these details might weaken the sense of pride by making the ship’s military achievements seem less significant. The pride associated with the Constitution in this poem is rooted in reality but is achieved by ignoring specifics and enhancing sensory experiences.
Permanence
This poem laments the possible fading of the battleship U.S.S. Constitution from public memory as it faced dismantling. It also delivers a warning about the changing values that the author believes contributed to the ship's potential demise. The poem connects the ship with images of strength and courage, not only through sensory details like the “cannon’s roar” and the fluttering of a tattered flag, but also through specific ideals such as “the hero’s blood,” “the victor’s tread,” and the deck “where knelt the vanquished foe.” The poem suggests that all the glory associated with the ship is on the verge of being replaced by cowardice, triviality, and weakness, represented by “the harpies of the shore.” The decision to decommission the Constitution was likely driven by financial considerations; the Navy wouldn’t dispose of equipment that was still useful. However, Holmes contends that while the ship’s monetary value may have lessened, its emotional significance remains timeless. Another poem might have focused on the ship’s historical contribution to the nation's development or the potential use of its timbers for new ships, rather than evoking fear that its legacy would vanish with its dismantling. During that era, America was a relatively young nation, not yet fifty years old. It was vital for Americans to hold onto any proud traditions they could identify with, and it was easy to fear that heroic achievements could be forgotten if their physical symbols were disregarded. Such concerns have persisted throughout history and continue today, as people worry about which aspects of human nature might disappear with each new generation.
Apathy and Passivity
In this poem, Holmes employs irony to express a viewpoint that sharply contrasts with his actual feelings. When he exclaims, “Ay, tear her tattered insignia down!”, he truly means that the flag should remain flying, similar to his suggestion of sinking the ship when he actually wishes to preserve it. This approach serves to awaken readers from their indifference toward the ship's destruction, prompting them to see their own lack of determination reflected in his words. In today's post-Freudian world, this technique is known as “reverse psychology”: influencing someone to agree with you by pretending to support the opposite stance. In “Old Ironsides,” Holmes uses the public's apathy in two notable ways. By fervently claiming that the Constitution should not only be decommissioned but also thrown into the sea, he rekindles any lingering feelings people might still have for the vessel. His use of vivid and powerful imagery reignites the excitement that the indifferent public had allowed to dwindle over years of peace. He frames the issue as a battle between the evil of the shore-bound harpies and the heroism represented...
(This entire section contains 215 words.)
Unlock this Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
by the sea's eagle. By adopting a seemingly defeatist stance, suggesting they might as well capitulate to cowardice, Holmes persuades his audience to contemplate saving theConstitution as if it were their own idea.
Freedom
The Constitution was instrumental in the fight against the British, who maintained control over America as a colony until the War of Independence. As a result, it became a powerful emblem of national liberty. Oliver Wendell Holmes strengthens this association by using vivid imagery in his poem to evoke the theme of freedom, particularly through references to flight. He immediately draws the reader's attention upward in the first line by mentioning the ship’s flag, “That banner in the sky.” The Constitution is compared to a meteor shooting through the clouds and described as an “eagle of the sea.” In the poem's final stanza, Holmes suggests that it would be more honorable to allow the ship to drift and sink to the ocean floor than to preserve any part of it, as it has represented freedom.
Implied Theme and Emotional Experience
The poem “Old Ironsides” by Oliver Wendell Holmes evokes a powerful emotional response through its nuanced and ironic structure. Rather than explicitly stating its theme, Holmes weaves it into the fabric of the poem, allowing the reader to experience the emotional resonance of the USS Constitution's storied past. This celebrated vessel, one of the first three frigates built for the burgeoning United States Navy, was a symbol of national pride, especially for residents of Boston, where it was constructed by local craftsmen.
Launched in 1797, the USS Constitution earned its formidable reputation by outmaneuvering and outrunning its adversaries, thereby enhancing the prestige of the United States on the international stage. Its thick oak sides, which repelled enemy cannonballs, earned it the affectionate nickname "Old Ironsides." This moniker, suggestive of its legendary resilience, belied the fact that the use of iron for shipbuilding was a distant innovation at the time.
Holmes captures the imagination by recounting the ship’s legacy, stirring a sense of nostalgia and reverence. Through his artful irony, Holmes invites readers to appreciate the ship's historical significance, allowing them to connect emotionally with its legacy and the craftsmanship of those who brought it to life. The poem serves as a tribute to the ship's valor and the indomitable spirit it represents, echoing the enduring values of strength and perseverance.
Patriotic Response and Preservation Efforts
In 1830, the iconic ship known as "Old Ironsides" faced the grim prospect of demolition, deemed antiquated after years of heavy service. This news inspired a young Oliver Wendell Holmes, at just twenty-one, to pen a powerful poem in response. Crafted in a single morning, Holmes's verses captured the ship’s storied past and the pride it evoked among Americans. Upon reading the demolition notice in a newspaper, Holmes swiftly submitted his poem to the same publication. Once published, the poem ignited a wave of patriotic fervor. Starting in Boston, the advocacy to preserve the historic vessel rapidly gathered momentum as newspapers along the East Coast reprinted the poem, rallying support from Americans eager to safeguard this symbol of national heritage. Through his evocative words, Holmes galvanized a movement that underscored the deep-seated connection between cultural memory and national pride, ultimately contributing to the preservation of "Old Ironsides."
Celebration of Heroism and National Pride
The enduring power of the poem is largely attributed to its poignant celebration of those who courageously manned the storied decks of "Old Ironsides," fighting valiantly for both the honor and the enduring preservation of the United States. In 1812, the nation was in desperate need of a morale boost, and the spectacular victory over the Guerrière provided just that. This triumph was swiftly followed by another significant win: the destruction of HMS Java. These naval victories were pivotal, not just in bolstering the spirits of the fledgling nation, but in ensuring that the United States retained its hard-earned independence, resisting British dominion.
The poem transcends a mere recounting of battles; it venerates the broader history of the country, tapping into the wellspring of national pride and patriotism. It evokes a Romantic sensibility, glorifying the triumphs of war as much as the valor of those who fought. By immortalizing these acts of bravery, the poem serves as both a tribute and a call to preserve the legacy of resilience and freedom that defines the United States. It is a testament not only to past victories but to the enduring spirit of a nation poised to defend its sovereignty.
Cultural Impact and Legacy
In the nineteenth-century classrooms of America, "Old Ironsides" was more than just a poem; it was an exercise in patriotism. Students would stand with one arm raised, reciting Oliver Wendell Holmes's stirring words that immortalized the USS Constitution. Holmes's poignant conclusion, which suggested that the grand ship would be better off shattered in combat than dismantled in port, struck a chord with audiences who valued its storied history. This sentiment spurred a national determination to preserve the vessel, ensuring it remained a tangible symbol of American naval strength and resilience.
Over the years, this legendary ship has undergone numerous restorations, each a testament to the enduring legacy it represents. Since its christening more than two centuries ago, "Old Ironsides" has weathered battles and the passage of time, becoming an emblem of American heritage. Since 1934, the ship has found its home in the Charlestown Navy Yard in Boston Harbor, an integral part of the National Historic Site that marks the terminus of the Freedom Trail. Here, the USS Constitution stands not only as a relic of the past but as a vibrant reminder of the nation's enduring spirit, captivating the imagination of all who visit.
