Student Question
How can you prove that Oedipus Rex is the most perfect Greek tragedy and Sophocles the definitive tragic playwright?
Quick answer:
Oedipus Rex is often cited as a quintessential Greek tragedy, but claiming it as the "most perfect" is subjective and not universally accepted. Aristotle frequently referenced it in his Poetics as an exemplary tragedy due to its noble hero, reversal of fortune, and evocation of fear and pity. However, opinions varied even in antiquity, and other playwrights and tragedies also met these criteria. Sophocles' reputation was enhanced by figures like Richard Claverhouse Jebb in the 19th century.
First, there is an issue here with the passive voice. While you might claim that certain people have considered Oedipus Rex the most perfect of Greek tragedies and Sophocles the definitive Greek playwright, you could not prove that everyone who has ever written about the topic considers this to be the case, as it is not true. As is clearly shown by the evidence of Aristophanes' Frogs, opinions about the relative merits of different playwrights differed even in antiquity, and the Alexandrian canon includes three tragic playwrights.
The argument you can make is that Aristotle, in his Poetics, frequently mentions Oedipus Rex as a positive example, but he also mentions other tragedies, as in the statement:
Now, the best tragedies are founded on the story of a few houses, on the fortunes of Alcmaeon, Oedipus, Orestes, Meleager, Thyestes, Telephus, and those others who have done or suffered something terrible.
You can certainly argue that Oedipus Rex has all the elements of a great tragedy outlined by Aristotle, including a noble hero who undergoes a reversal of fortune, an action of a certain magnitude, and the ability to evoke fear and pity. Thus it is easy to show that Oedipus Rex contains all the elements Aristotle considers essential to a great tragedy. However, not only did Sophocles himself write other plays containing these elements, but so did other playwrights. Thus "most perfect" would probably be an overstatement.
Oedipus Rex was considered a very important example of Greek drama in the Renaissance, but neoclassical critics felt that its construction was flawed. Among speakers of English, Richard Claverhouse Jebb, a nineteenth-century classicist was important in elevating the reputation of Sophocles in general and Oedipus Rex in particular.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.