The Trojan War
Anyone studying Homer’s poetry cannot overlook the pivotal event in both the Iliad and the Odyssey: the Trojan War. Odysseus' adventures occur following his involvement in the Greek campaign at Troy. The domestic issues he encounters upon his return stem from his prolonged absence during the war and his subsequent wanderings. The vast literature dedicated to this unique event underscores its importance to Homer’s contemporaries and subsequent generations.
Homer’s poetry portrays an era that is explicitly not his own, but a heroic age of the distant past. The archaeological discovery of Troy by Heinrich Schliemann in the nineteenth century A.D. has provided significant insights into this event. Schliemann uncovered nine city layers at a site that closely aligned with Homer’s description of the plains of Ilium. The seventh layer, a city destroyed by fire, thrived in the twelfth century B.C., roughly four hundred years before Homer’s time. Modern scholars identify this city as the Troy depicted in Homer’s works.
According to the Iliad, the Trojan War endured for a full decade before culminating in Troy’s destruction. Although it is improbable that such a siege lasted ten years (some scholars suggest it was as brief as ten days!), the event remained significant to future generations. Some critics argue that the portrayal of a unified Greece gave the poems a universal appeal. It is important to note that for most of ancient and classical Greek history, the city-state or polis was the primary unit of government, not a unified nation. Cities like Sparta, Athens, and Thebes operated under distinct systems of governance, although trade and culture were shared among the city-states. Conflicts between city-states were frequent, as was a tendency towards isolationism when external threats loomed over the Greek peninsula.
What stands out in Homer’s poems is not only the depiction of a collective effort by Greek cities but also the impartiality shown towards them. Some scholars believe this is because Homer resided across the Aegean Sea in Asia Minor, allowing him to write without bias towards any particular city.
Homer’s geographical distance from the Greek mainland may also explain why the Trojans, who were his neighbors in Asia Minor, are not portrayed as uncivilized barbarians but as noble figures, equal to their Greek adversaries. Indeed, many modern readers find themselves more drawn to Hector, the prince of Troy, than to the often self-absorbed and arrogant Achilles.
Expert Q&A
What is the significance of Heracles (Hercules) in Homer's Odyssey?
In The Odyssey, Heracles (Hercules) is significant despite limited direct involvement. His legacy as a hero who tamed dangerous forces for civilization reflects the challenges Odysseus faces, echoing Heracles' earlier exploits. Heracles appears in the Underworld, serving as a somber reminder of mortality, illustrating that even the greatest heroes, like Odysseus, cannot escape death. This presence emphasizes themes of heroism, mortality, and the enduring influence of past heroes on the present.
What qualities considered barbaric or monstrous in ancient Greek society can be drawn from Polyphemus' characterization?
Polyphemus embodies qualities considered barbaric in ancient Greek society, such as lawlessness, isolation, and poor hospitality. Unlike the Greeks, who valued laws, assemblies, and the guest-host relationship, Polyphemus lives alone without societal rules and treats guests with hostility, even consuming them. This contrasts with Greek civilization, where hosts were expected to offer generosity and protection to guests. Polyphemus's actions highlight his barbarity and justify Odysseus's revenge.
Based on Odysseus's criticism of the Cyclopes in The Odyssey, what society did the Greeks value?
What does food in the Odyssey reveal about Greek culture?
Food in "The Odyssey" highlights Greek cultural values, particularly hospitality, known as xenia. While the Homeric diet includes wine, cheese, bread, and roasted meats, the emphasis is on the behavior during feasts. Greeks were expected to offer food and drink to strangers before asking their identity, contrasting with barbaric hosts like the Cyclops. Good hospitality was crucial, as failing could anger the gods, while impolite guests, like Penelope's suitors, were frowned upon.
How does The Odyssey contribute to western literature?
The Odyssey significantly influences Western literature by emphasizing individual emotions and experiences, seen through Odysseus's human struggles and decisions. This focus on character interiority has shaped how protagonists are developed, encouraging readers to empathize with them. The theme of homecoming and journey also profoundly impacts the Western canon, inspiring works from Virgil's Aeneid to modern literature like Joyce's Ulysses. These elements trace back to Homer's epic, underscoring its enduring legacy.
In The Odyssey, what double standard does Calypso suffer that reflects Greek society?
Calypso suffers from a double standard in Greek society, where men like Odysseus enjoy freedom and minimal emotional commitment, whereas women like Calypso are expected to offer emotional devotion and passivity. Odysseus can move between relationships without consequence, while Calypso must accept his departure despite offering him immortality. This reflects the broader societal norms of ancient Greece, where men had more freedoms and different expectations compared to women.
The historical and cultural significance of Homer's "The Odyssey."
Homer's "The Odyssey" holds significant historical and cultural value as one of the earliest and most influential works of Western literature. It reflects ancient Greek values such as heroism, loyalty, and the importance of home and family. Moreover, it offers insights into Greek mythology, societal norms, and the human condition, making it a cornerstone for understanding ancient Greek civilization and its lasting impact on Western culture.
Significance of the Trojan War in Homer's "The Odyssey"
The Trojan War is significant in Homer's The Odyssey as it serves as the backdrop for Odysseus's long journey home. The war's aftermath sets the stage for the epic's central narrative, highlighting themes of heroism, perseverance, and the struggles of returning home after conflict. Odysseus's experiences during the war also shape his character and inform his actions throughout the story.
What was the Trojan War and how was it won?
The Trojan War was a decade-long conflict between Troy and the Achaeans, sparked by Paris of Troy abducting Helen, wife of Menelaus of Sparta. The war ended through Odysseus's cunning plan: the Greeks feigned retreat, leaving behind a giant wooden horse as an offering to Athena. Greek warriors hidden inside the horse emerged at night, opening Troy's gates to the returning Greek army, leading to Troy's downfall. Helen was recovered and returned to Sparta.
The significance of omitted cultural values in Homer's The Odyssey and their implications for ancient Greek culture
The omission of certain cultural values in Homer's The Odyssey highlights the complexities and priorities of ancient Greek culture. By focusing on values like honor, loyalty, and cleverness, while omitting others, the epic reveals what the Greeks esteemed most. This selective portrayal implies a society deeply concerned with personal reputation and communal respect, shaping our understanding of their cultural ideals.
Compare and Contrast
-
Late Bronze Age (the era of the Odyssey): Governance is dominated by a few "great kings" (such as those of Egypt, the Hittite Empire, and Mycenae) who oversee vast territories, either directly or through alliances in loose confederations. Some of these alliances are formalized in treaties. Raiding and looting are fairly common, particularly in border regions far from central authority.
Iron Age: While monarchies still exist, many areas have transitioned to aristocratic or oligarchic societies based on family or clan structures. The development of the polis, or city-state, is well underway. Inter-"national" cooperation is beginning to re-emerge following the isolation of the Dark Age.
Late twentieth century: Various forms of government are in practice, with different types of democracies being more prevalent than monarchies. However, a relatively small number of "superpower" or highly influential nations still exist. High levels of cooperation are evident (e.g., the United Nations), though occasional conflicts persist.
- Late Bronze Age: Writing exists but is mostly in
cumbersome, syllabic forms like Egyptian hieroglyphics, Mycenaean Linear A and
B scripts, or Hittite/Akkadian cuneiform. Literacy is likely limited to the
elite aristocracy and a professional class of scribes, bureaucrats, and
diplomats.
Iron Age: In the Greek-speaking world, literacy is beginning to resurface with a new alphabet where each letter represents a distinct sound instead of a whole syllable. Literacy is probably still confined to the upper classes and some professionals, such as rhapsodes and certain artists.
Late twentieth century: The majority of people are literate, at least to the extent that they can manage their own business affairs.
- Late Bronze Age: Religious practices occur mainly in
family or group settings. There may be designated spaces for cultic figures or
idols, but formal, public worship sites are rare and hard to identify, if they
existed at all.
Iron Age: Family religious observances continue, especially in honoring ancestral graves. However, formal cultic centers are beginning to be established and are playing a more significant role as religious practices become more defined.
Late twentieth century: Religious practices vary widely between countries and religions. Most major world religions have specific places designated for formal public worship, which are clearly identified and not used for other purposes. Many believers also have religious objects or items in their homes.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.