Discussion Topic

Analysis of literary devices, approaches, and theories used in "Hearts and Hands" by O. Henry


"Hearts and Hands" by O. Henry employs irony, foreshadowing, and characterization. The story's twist ending reveals the true identities of the characters, highlighting O. Henry's masterful use of situational irony. Foreshadowing hints at the true nature of the characters' relationship, while detailed characterization helps build the narrative's surprising conclusion. These devices effectively engage readers and reinforce the story's themes of appearance versus reality.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What literary devices are used in "Hearts and Hands" by O. Henry?

There are a number of literary devices in the story, but the most important one is irony. The whole situation is profoundly ironic, leading to the surprise ending. In other words, there is situational irony. In turn, there are other kinds of irony in the story, such as dramatic irony. This means that we as readers know something that one of the characters in the story doesn't know. Even if we don't get the twist until it's revealed at the end, we should still realize that all is not what it seems. The marshal is gruff and unkempt; Easton is smooth, charming, and debonair. As they are both headed to Leavenworth prison, we all know who the prisoner must be just by looking at them, right?

There's also verbal irony. This is where a character says one thing, but means something else. For example:

He's taking me to Leavenworth prison. It's seven years for counterfeiting.

Of course, Miss Fairchild naturally thinks that it's Mr.Easton's disheveled companion who is the fraudster.

In some places, Henry combines both situational and verbal irony, as in the following:

I had to do something. Money has a way of taking wings unto itself, and you know it takes money to keep step with our crowd in Washington.

Miss Fairchild thinks that Easton had to become a marshal to make ends meet, but, in actuality, he's referring to his "career" as a criminal.

Irony is a useful literary device for Henry because it allows him to highlight the story's theme of the difference between appearance and reality:

My butterfly days are over, I fear.

Easton's days as a social butterfly are indeed over. However, it is not because he's short of money (as Miss Fairchild thinks), rather, it is because he's about to go to prison.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What literary approaches and theories are used in "Hearts and Hands" by O. Henry?

When discussing literary theories, we refer to the prevailing perception of what makes a literary work "good." Such discussions go all the way back to Plato and Aristotle; since the 1900s many new literary theories have been put forth, as you can see from the resource below. Writing in the early years of the 20th century, O. Henry could have been familiar with the ideas of Plato and Aristotle but not with the other schools of interpretation that came later. In reading this short story by O. Henry, we can see that it jives nicely with both Plato's literary theory and Aristotle's. From Plato's point of view, a work of art should teach morality and ethics. At the end of this story, the other passengers comment on how the marshal is a "good sort of chap," presumably because he prevented embarrassment for both his prisoner and the young woman and because he kept the young woman from baring her heart any further to a man whose hands were tied from being able to assist her in any way. Aristotle described how elements such as "plot, character, thought, [and] diction" work together to produce an emotionally satisfying literary work. The surprise plot ending and the portrayal of the two men and the woman are used skillfully by the author in this story, showing an adherence to Aristotelian guidelines.

Looking at the approaches O. Henry took in writing this story to produce maximum satisfaction in readers, we note a detached third person narration that makes the twist ending possible; carefully chosen words for each character; and delightful situational and verbal irony. By keeping the narration completely external and not allowing readers inside any of the characters' heads, Henry can maintain his sleight of hand until the very end of the story. The marshal times and chooses his words with delicacy so as to avoid embarrassing the young woman in particular, but also the prisoner. The prisoner's words are likewise apt and full of delicious irony: "My butterfly days are over, I fear" and "I must go on to Leavenworth" have a deeper meaning than the woman or the casual reader can know at first. Even the words spoken by the two fellow passengers at the end are subtle enough to create supreme enjoyment in readers when their true meaning dawns.

Henry's masterful use of narration, plot, characterization, and diction make his work highly successful and satisfying when considered through the lens of either Plato or Aristotle.

See eNotes Ad-Free

Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Last Updated on