Ninetieth Birthday

by R. S. Thomas

Start Free Trial

Summary

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

R. S. Thomas's poem "Ninetieth Birthday" intricately weaves the theme of time and memory through its vivid imagery and subtle emotional undertones. The poem, divided into two stanzas of unequal length, traverses both physical and metaphorical landscapes, capturing a poignant visit to an elderly woman, perhaps a familial matriarch, on the significant milestone of her ninetieth birthday. Through this visit, Thomas explores the divide between past and present, isolation and connection, memory and reality.

The Journey Up the Hill

Set on a midsummer day, the poem opens with the visitor’s ascent up a steep hill, meticulously painting a picture of the rural Welsh landscape. The path, likely a dusty dirt road, suggests a more intimate, pedestrian journey rather than one undertaken by vehicle, offering a sense of closeness to the natural surroundings. The landscape unfolds with rugged hillsides where trees surrender to bracken, a distant seascape, and a trickling stream, elements familiar yet detached from the visitor who traverses them. This setting, reminiscent of Thomas’s other works, evokes a sense of timelessness and continuity in nature, contrasting with the transient nature of human life.

The Reunion with the Past

Transitioning seamlessly into the second stanza, the poem shifts focus from the physical landscape to the emotional terrain of human connection. The visitor reaches the crest of the hill, where an old woman awaits, embodying a living connection to a vanished world. Her isolation is underscored by her contemplation of a "lost village," a place preserved solely in her memory, hinting at her detachment from the evolving world beyond her farm. This poignant image of waiting symbolizes the woman's static existence amidst the inexorable flow of time.

The Chasm Between Generations

The poem subtly highlights the chasm between the worlds of the visitor and the old woman. Although the visitor physically stands in the same space, the line "Yet no bridge joins her own/ World with yours" underscores the emotional and experiential distance between them. The visitor's familiarity with the landscape serves only to accentuate their disconnection, as the unchanged natural scenery contrasts with the ever-changing human context. This division is emblematic of the broader human experience, where generations often find themselves separated by time and understanding, despite shared environments.

The Weight of Memories

In the poem's closing lines, the old woman's stories, though attentively heard by the visitor, lack relevance to the present, reinforcing the theme of memory's selective preservation. The visitor listens, yet what the old woman recounts seems to belong to a world that no longer exists, a nostalgic echo fading into obscurity. The poem leaves readers with a sense of lingering melancholy, as the interplay of memory, time, and isolation unfolds quietly yet powerfully, resonating with the universal human experience of aging and the inevitable passage of time.

Style and Technique

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

The poem "Ninetieth Birthday" stands out for its simplicity and emotional depth. Crafted in unadorned language, it manages to evoke complex emotions and vivid imagery without relying on elaborate poetic devices. Through an exploration of simplicity in form and depth in metaphor, the poem captures the essence of aging and the passage of time.

Language and Imagery

The poem employs straightforward language that is deceptively simple, yet effective in evoking clear visual imagery. The sentences, though long, lack syntactical complexity, making the poem accessible. Words are predominantly short, with "history" being the longest in the first stanza. Adjectives such as "green," "warm," and "far" are uncomplicated, reinforcing the vividness of the landscapes described. This plainness gives the poem a contemplative tone, inviting readers to reflect quietly on its themes.

Metaphoric Evolution

In its second stanza, the poem...

(This entire section contains 439 words.)

Unlock this Study Guide Now

Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

shifts to a denser use of metaphors, transcending simple imagery to delve into emotional complexity. The metaphor of lichen writing "history on the page/ Of the grey rock" both strengthens the image of lichen covering a stone and evokes the mountain’s ancient past. In contrast, "time’s knife shaving the bone" is a metaphor that defies literal visualization, opting instead to symbolize the slow erosion of life experienced by an aging woman. This metaphor effectively captures the emotional weight of a life gradually dwindling, rather than merely depicting physical change. Similarly, metaphors such as "bridge" and "abyss" operate on a conceptual level, illustrating the cultural and social chasm between generations.

Use of Second Person

One intriguing formal aspect is the use of second person, a common poetic device, but employed here with subtlety and nuance. Typically, this perspective implies direct dialogue with another person; however, in "Ninetieth Birthday," the tone is introspective, suggesting the speaker might be reflecting internally. The private setting—the presence of only the visitor and the old woman—amplifies this introspective quality, leading the reader to question whether the speaker addresses someone else or is distancing themselves from their memories. Phrases like "all you can do" evoke feelings of helplessness, hinting at the speaker’s emotional detachment as a way to cope with personal sorrow. The visitor’s mixed emotions of gratitude for the old woman’s life and sorrow for her loneliness are made poignant by the speaker’s distancing use of the second person.

The poem’s skillful manipulation of language and perspective creates a layered narrative, where simplicity in expression enriches the thematic complexity. By juxtaposing stark imagery with profound metaphors, and personal reflection with second-person narration, "Ninetieth Birthday" offers a poignant exploration of the passage of time and the solitude of old age.

Previous

Themes

Loading...