Nikolai Berdyaev Criticism
Nikolai Berdyaev, a prominent Russian philosopher of the twentieth century, is revered for his profound explorations of Christianity, freedom, and creativity. Initially drawn to Marxist materialism, Berdyaev eventually shifted focus to a spiritual philosophy that critiques modern ideologies such as Marxism, capitalism, and socialism, which he saw as dehumanizing. His work centers on the Christian ethic of redemption, advocating for a transcendence of material constraints to establish a divine kingdom based on love and compassion.
Born in 1874 near Kiev, Berdyaev's aristocratic upbringing led him towards a scholarly life after an initial military education. He embraced Marxism at the University of Kiev but was later exiled for revolutionary activities. By 1903, Berdyaev had rejected Marxism in favor of Christianity, aligning himself with the Russian Orthodox Church. His intellectual journey took him through significant historical and philosophical shifts, resulting in his expulsion from Soviet Russia in 1922 due to his critique of Bolshevik ideology. He eventually settled in Paris, where his philosophical and literary work gained international fame, culminating in his recognition by Cambridge University.
Berdyaev's major works reflect his philosophical evolution from Marxism to a comprehensive religious metaphysics. His writings, such as The Meaning of the Creative Act and The Meaning of History, explore the interplay of divine and human freedom and creativity. In works like The Destiny of Man and Slavery and Freedom, Berdyaev critiques modern rationalism and materialism while advocating for the liberation of the human spirit through spiritual freedom. He viewed history eschatologically, as a divine trajectory leading towards a transformed humanity.
Critics such as Lampert and Sorokin have highlighted Berdyaev's unique synthesis of theology and philosophy, focusing on his concepts of 'God-Manhood' and social critiques. Berdyaev's philosophical contributions continue to resonate, influenced by and influencing major figures such as Dostoevsky and Nietzsche, and addressing existential themes of alienation and freedom with an aphoristic and systematic style, as noted by Zenkovskii and others.
Contents
- Principal Works
-
Essays
-
God-Manhood
(summary)
In the following excerpt, Lampert elucidates the concept of 'God-Manhood' in Berdyaev's thought. The idea of God-Manhood summarizes the quintessence of Berdyaev's thought. He begins and ends his reasoning not with God or man, but with God and man, with the God-man, with Christ and God-manhood. This defines both the content and 'style' of his thought. Without bearing this in mind it is hardly possible to discern the inner motives and trace the complex thread of his argument. 'Both philosophy and theology should start neither with God nor with man, but rather with the God-man. The basic and original phenomenon of life is the meeting and interaction of God and man, the movement of God towards man and of man towards God.'
-
Nikolai Berdyaev
(summary)
In the following essay, Sorokin focuses on the social and historical concerns and implications of Berdyaev's philosophy.
-
F. M. Dostoyevsky, V. Solovyov, and N. A. Berdyayev
(summary)
In the following essay, Zenkovskii provides an assessment of Berdyaev as a specifically Russian thinker, examining his complex spiritual evolution and the problems of history that lie at the center of his ideology and creative work.
-
An Evaluation: 'My Ways Are Not Your Ways'
(summary)
In the following excerpt, Vallon offers a critical appraisal of the salient concepts of Berdyaev's religious philosophy.
-
Nicolas Berdyaev, the Philosopher of Personalism
(summary)
In the following essay, Spinka traces Berdyaev's development as a thinker.
-
Nicholas Berdyaev, Captive of Freedom
(summary)
In the following essay, Mohan provides an overview of Berdyaev's life and thought.
-
Freedom and Necessity (The Paradox)
(summary)
In the following excerpt, Nucho explicates the significance of such concepts as freedom, necessity, and personality in Berdyaev's thought.
-
The Twentieth-Century Revolt against Time: Belief and Becoming in the Thought of Berdyaev, Eliot, Huxley, and Jung
(summary)
In the following essay, Wood considers Berdyaev along with T. S. Eliot, Aldous Huxley, and C. G. Jung as representative of modern thinkers whose works express a "revolt against time."
-
The Possibilities of Creativity: Nicholas Berdyaev and Robert Bly
(summary)
In the following essay, Randolph examines the spiritual significance that Berdyaev attached to human creativity, using the work of American poet Robert Bly to exemplify Berdyaev's criteria for genuine creativity in works of art.
-
A Jewish-Christian Rift in Twentieth-Century Russian Philosophy: N. A. Berdiaev and M. O. Gershenzon
(summary)
In the following essay, Horowitz details the reasons for the ideological conflict between Berdyaev and his long-time friend M. O. Gershenzon.
-
God-Manhood
(summary)
- Further Reading