Nicholosa Mohr

Start Free Trial

Marilyn Sachs

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Last Updated August 6, 2024.

Little Ray, in "A New Window Display" [one of the stories in "El Bronx Remembered"], is a newcomer from Puerto Rico who marvels at all the wonders in El Bronx: to every new experience, he says, "Qué fenomenal!" His friends have told him about the snow, and he is particularly eager to see it. But he never does. He dies before it comes, and his friends mourn for him in the best possible way—by playing in it themselves, shouting, sliding, turning and crying out for him at its beauty, "Qué fenomenal!"

If there is any message at all in these stories, any underlying theme, it is that life goes on. But Nicholasa Mohr is more interested in people than in messages. Essentially, she is an old-fashioned writer, a meat-and-potatoes writer, whose stories stick to your ribs. No complicated symbolism here, no trendy obscurity of meaning, no hopeless despair or militant ethnicity. Her people endure because they are people. Some of them suffer, some of them die, a few of them fail, but most of the time they endure, or others like them endure.

Most brilliant and tender, perhaps, of all these brilliant and tender stories, is "Mr. Mendelsohn," the story of a lonely old Jewish man who is befriended by a Puerto Rican family. Even though Mr. Mendelsohn dies finally, it is no tragedy because his last years have been enriched by kindness and love. Very different for Doña Nereida in the chilling story, "Princess." She is trapped by a narrow love for a dead animal, love she cannot allow to grow into something wider and healthier.

A couple of the stories are tragic, but most of Nicholasa Mohr's characters are too sturdy and resilient for defeat. Yvette and Mildred, the two friends in "The Wrong Lunch Line," are humiliated by teachers when they try to eat their lunch together in school. Friendship, however, is not such a fragile thing, and the two girls, though hurt and confused, can laugh scornfully at the foolishness of adults.

And Hannibal, Joey, Ramona, Maria and Casilda, who grow up in the course of three of the stories, can laugh too—and survive death, betrayal and religious conversion, as they bounce off the pages in the final story on their way to a dance at St. Anselm's and to a future that will always hold for Nicholasa Mohr's characters some promise, some hope.

In her earlier outstanding novel, "Nilda," it was apparent that if any author could make you hear pulses beating from the pages, Nicholasa Mohr was the one. In "El Bronx Remembered," she has done it again. (p. 30)

Marilyn Sachs, in The New York Times Book Review (© 1975 by The New York Times Company; reprinted by permission), November 16, 1975.

See eNotes Ad-Free

Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Previous

Ray Anthony Shepard

Next

Paul Heins