The New Deal

Start Free Trial

Student Question

Compare the French response to the Depression with the New Deal.

Quick answer:

The French response to the Depression differed from the U.S. New Deal primarily in its delay and approach. France, less affected initially, maintained balanced budgets until 1934, unlike the U.S.'s Keynesian deficit spending. Leon Blum's socialist-led government implemented moderate reforms like wage increases and nationalizing armaments but faced opposition and lacked emergency powers. The U.S. New Deal, however, involved more extensive government intervention. France's economy improved with the rise of war industries by 1939.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

In general, France was not hit as hard or as early by the Great Depression as the United States. In part, this was because the great number of deaths of young French men during World War I meant that unemployment was not as bad in France as it was in the United States. For example, unemployment only reached 5% in France, while it reached a high of 25% in the United States. Furthermore, France did not rely as heavily on the stock market for economic growth, and the Great Depression also hit France later (in 1931), as compared to 1929 in the United States.

In contrast with the New Deal policies of the United States, which encouraged Keynesian deficit spending to spur economic growth, French policies maintained balanced government budgets until 1934. When the government under Laval tried to reduce salaries, popular unrest led to the election of a leftist government under Leon Blum, who came from the socialist Popular Front party. Blum's policies were less comprehensive than those of FDR during the New Deal, because Blum faced opposition from the right-wing Radicals within his coalition. Strikes broke out, and Blum raised wages in response. He also nationalized the armaments industry. Eventually, the government had to devalue the franc, which caused capital to flee abroad. The parliament, however, did not grant Blum the emergency powers he needed to enact broad reforms, though these powers were granted to his successor. The development of war industries caused the economy to improve by the time World War II broke out in Europe in 1939. 

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Approved by eNotes Editorial