Neil Young's Unorthodox Live Album

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Last Updated August 6, 2024.

Time Fades Away has its virtues when taken on its own terms and not as the latest major work of a major artist. Here, Young seems to have consciously avoided the sober sense of importance that accompanied After the Gold Rush and Harvest…. For whatever reason, he's made a startlingly unorthodox album….

More than any of his earlier works, this record shows Young's reticence about being a public figure.

Young's privateness has always been at the heart of his writing and performing, right alongside his staunch moral sense. These two elements have been both his prime virtues and his main flaws. Both elements are evident in this new material, with uneven but sometimes positive results.

There is an overbearing sense of self-righteousness in the title song, with its images of nervous junkies strung out on the street. But it's saved by a sharply ironic chorus….

Young's is a pain-dominated, rather Old Testament sensibility, and nowhere is all this more obvious than in "L.A." Young's self-righteousness becomes absolute, and he depicts himself as some neo-Israelite prophet warning the unhearing masses of the inevitable apocalypse. Young's blanket condemnations, "Southern Man" and "Alabama" included, are as simplistic as they are venomous, but their fire makes them compelling nonetheless….

The best song on the album is "Don't Be Denied," which continues the tone but expands the scope of his quiet, personal songs. It is a complete autobiography in four verses, and the most effective part deals with his childhood. In this section, Young cuts rapidly through scenes that depict the private trials of a rather delicate kid in a rugged land. This song seems an explicit re-expression of the emotional content of Young's moving but impenetrably private "Broken Arrow." The latter part of "Denied," in which Young deals with the problems of being a celebrity, forgoes universality for the writer's personal complaints but is no less credible for it. A lack of honesty in his work has never been one of Young's problems; if anything, he's gone too far in the other direction, saying what would have better been left unsaid and looking bigoted or just plain foolish in the process.

He comes off rather silly in "Last Dance," a long, ponderous song that sounds like Young's parody of his own After the Gold Rush hard-rock style. And he's out of control on "Yonder Stands the Sinner," which is self-deprecating in what seems to be a more intentional way….

If Young appears foolish and arrogant at various points on the album, he seems to be allowing us a glimpse of these flaws, rather than letting them slip through and spoil his big moments without his consent, as happened on Harvest. Time Fades Away is an idiosyncracy from one of rock's most idiosyncratic artists. If it isn't a resounding success, the album is still a revealing self-portrait by an always fascinating man.

Bud Scoppa, "Neil Young's Unorthodox Live Album," in Rolling Stone (by Straight Arrow Publishers, Inc. © 1974; all rights reserved; reprinted by permission), Issue 151, January 3, 1974, p. 61.

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Previous

Others

Next

Neil Young: The Sands of Time