Nancy Drew Series Analysis
by Carolyn Keene

Start Your Free Trial

Download Nancy Drew Series Study Guide

Subscribe Now


(Beacham's Guide to Literature for Young Adults)

The Nancy Drew books are set in the town of River Heights, which in the 1930 edition of The Secret of the Old Clock was described as being in the Midwest. In subsequent books, however, River Heights seems to be located in the East, only a few hours' drive from New York City.

The lack of change in River Heights gives the books an essentially timeless quality. Nancy encounters modern problems such as the escape of refugees from Warsaw Pact countries, but enemy spies seem no more sinister than the local thieves of earlier books. In fact, Adams revised the entire series in 1959, removing language that might make the books dated or offensive.

Literary Qualities

(Beacham's Guide to Literature for Young Adults)

The Nancy Drew series' greatest strength is its use of varied and exotic settings. Because of the limited possibilities for unusual criminal activity in a town the size of River Heights, Nancy ends up on cases in places like New York, Brazil, Austria, and Greece. Even when the locale is a small town in the United States, the characters are likely to be involved in scientific experimentation or in some unusual occupation such as china-making. In each case the narrative provides enough background information to make the setting or the occupation interesting.

Although conventional, the plots are exciting and filled with fast-paced action. In the opening pages of the book, the problem is described, and Nancy's client is introduced. Tension builds as Nancy follows the successive clues to discover the identity of the criminals or the location of a missing item. At the book's conclusion the mystery is solved, and the criminals apprehended. Throughout, the reader remains totally involved in the action.

The weakest point in a Nancy Drew book is the excessive use of coincidence. Nancy always manages to be in the right place or to meet the right people to discover the information needed to solve the mystery.

Generally, the characters are not fully individualized. Sometimes Nancy's client or even one of the criminals is given one distinctive personality trait; but usually the client will be confused or fearful, and the criminal will be surly or devious. Nancy herself is a multifaceted character, but from the beginning she possesses so many talents and so much knowledge that change in her attitudes is virtually impossible. Because she is so clever and resourceful, some critics consider her less than believable. If Nancy Drew and her adventures are considered as fantasy, however, she still may be representative of the American teenager's idealized self-image.

Social Sensitivity

(Beacham's Guide to Literature for Young Adults)

Nancy Drew mysteries consistently emphasize traditional American values, but the early books in the series reflect the social insensitivity of the time when they were written. There is much talk about manners and breeding, and a maid is described as "willing but somewhat stupid." Likewise, in The Secret of the Old Clock, racial stereotyping is seen in the treatment of Jeff Tucker, the black caretaker at the Tophams' cabin, who is portrayed as a somewhat comic figure easily fooled by the robber gang. Likewise, The Mystery of the Brass Bound Trunk contains some examples of American chauvinism: the maid in Buenos Aires is described as "simple-minded"; Nancy and her friends exchange their money for "native coins"; and Mrs. Purdy, an Argentine, is an appropriate chaperon because she "speaks her native tongue so beautifully." Offensive references of this kind were eliminated, however, in the 1959 revision of the series.

(The entire section is 870 words.)