Mythology and Censorship
Mythology plays a significant role in shaping cultural norms, beliefs, and ideologies across various societies. It weaves the fabric of collective narratives that define a community's identity and morality. Simultaneously, mythology has a profound influence on the mechanisms of censorship, where dominant myths often determine the boundaries of acceptable discourse.
The Nature and Origins of Myths
Myths are imaginative tales of lasting importance, embodying the beliefs and values of a society. Differentiating from philosophical allegories, fables, and parables, myths uniquely encapsulate the central, often religious, beliefs of a people. Mythologies, whether primitive or advanced, are intrinsic to every society and are preserved as part of cultural heritage. They are also foundational for ideologies like fascism, nationalism, and civil religion, drawing their compelling narratives from mythological contexts.
Historically, myths originated in preliterate stages of human societies, passed down orally through the ages before being documented as epics by poets and writers. Even today, many myths remain in uncodified forms in less literate communities. Comparative mythological studies have revealed striking similarities among diverse cultures, leading to hypotheses about universal archetypes within the collective unconscious of humanity. Alternatively, these similarities might be attributed to cultural exchanges. Some theorists suggest that myths emerged as stories to validate the ritual practices of ancient tribes, with rituals predating the myths themselves.
The Multifaceted Roles of Myths
Myths are intricate, layered structures tied to a nation's collective experiences, identity, and self-perception. They often give rise to metaphysical and theological theories, while their ritual enactments lead to cultic practices that emotionally engage participants. Myths serve numerous societal functions, from offering answers to philosophical questions about the universe, human nature, and existential concerns, to legitimizing existing social and political systems. For instance, the Indian caste system is justified by a myth explaining its divine origin.
Myths also provide explanations for rituals and taboos related to various life events and celebrations, embodying a society's cultural ideals. They set standards for how individuals should live, highlighting historical figures who exemplify these ideals. Despite attempts to discredit, reinterpret, or devalue myths, they continue to thrive, energizing human experience and maintaining social cohesion. Scholars like Freud, Jung, and Durkheim have recognized myths' power in shaping art, literature, and even scientific exploration.
Mythology's Influence on Censorship
Mythology significantly impacts the censorship of ideas by shaping a society's collective consciousness and setting the parameters for public discourse. The narratives considered newsworthy and behaviors deemed exemplary or condemnable are often rooted in underlying mythological beliefs. This influence extends to social-political spheres, where myths manifest as civil religion, deeming national symbols and practices sacred and beyond criticism. When dissent challenges these symbols or practices, it is often met with social condemnation and legal repercussions.
Revolutionary movements might use myths to justify overthrowing existing orders, but they frequently establish new myths that suppress criticism as traitorous. For example, the Iranian Revolution of 1979 led to a new regime with extensive censorship of counterrevolutionary ideas. Even in open societies like the United States, the media often legitimizes government actions while minimizing dissent as unpatriotic.
Censorship also extends to the arts and literature, where works are scrutinized for moral and political correctness. Themes involving sexuality frequently face censorship due to their perceived threat to public morality, influenced by mythological foundations. Western opposition to obscenity and pornography derives from mythologies with Middle Eastern origins, transmitted through Judaism and Christianity. These myths frame good and evil as a struggle between spirit and flesh, discouraging sexual expression due to its association with evil.
Religious and Scientific Censorship
Throughout history, religious institutions have suppressed sexual expression in arts and literature, leading to censorship of...
(This entire section contains 915 words.)
Unlock this Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
discussions on sexual development, birth control, and related issues. Christian fundamentalist groups have championed the censorship of sexually explicit materials, viewing them as contrary to moral beliefs entrenched in mythological narratives.
Mythology also prompts societies to censor scientific ideas threatening traditional faith. The Roman Catholic Church's Index Librorum Prohibitorum exemplifies institutional censorship used to protect faith and morals. This practice has historical roots, as seen in the early church's actions against works deemed superstitious or heretical. Such suppression extends to the sciences, with notable events like the Scopes Trial of 1925 highlighting conflicts between scientific theories, like evolution, and religious beliefs. Despite legal victories for science, opposition from fundamentalist groups persists, targeting various academic areas perceived as threats.
Censorship and Worldview Divergences
The drive to censor arises in messianic and prophetic religions like Christianity and Islam, which view history as a battleground of good versus evil, expected to culminate in divine triumph. This worldview compels missionary activities and justifies censorship as part of the divine mission. In contrast, nonmessianic religions, which are more tolerant and pluralistic, often censor for political rather than moral or religious reasons. However, political censorship can be masked as religious fervor, blurring the lines between authority and spirituality.
Essential Readings on Myth and Censorship
For those interested in exploring the intersections of mythology and culture further, several key texts provide valuable insights. G. S. Kirk’s "Myth: Its Meaning and Functions in Ancient and Other Cultures" offers an in-depth discussion on modern myth theories. Burton Feldman and Robert D. Richardson’s anthology, "The Rise of Modern Mythology, 1680-1860," offers scholarly perspectives with detailed commentary. Joseph Campbell’s "The Masks of God" and "Myth and Reality" delve into the relationship between myth and culture, while Mircea Eliade’s "Myths, Dreams, and Mysteries" examines myth's place in modern society. These works illuminate the enduring power and influence of myths across diverse fields and time periods.