My Brilliant Friend

by Elena Ferrante

Start Free Trial

Student Question

If Elena had told Lila about the incident on Ischia upon her return to Naples, how might their dialogue have unfolded?

Quick answer:

In an alternative version of the story, in which Elena tells Lila what happened with Sarratore, Elena would speak honestly to her close friend. Lila, after all, would know if Elena were lying. Lila would most likely react with anger and disgust towards Sarratore and feel protective of Elena. The volatile Lila would want to tell Sarratore off, but Elena would probably swear her to secrecy.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

At first, Elena does plan to tell Lila what happened with the middle-aged Sarratore, then she changes her mind and decides not to. Her reasons for keeping silent, such as disgust with Sarratore and "revulsion" against herself, would, therefore, become the basis of the imagined dialogue with Lila.

Elena's part of the dialogue would be based on what she records happening in the book: Sarratore coming to her as she slept, kissing her, touching her, and arousing her, then telling her he loves her. Elena would describe how she kept her body still, and try to convey to Lila her conflicting rush of emotions, pleasure at the physical sensations from Sarratore and disgust that she "let this happen." Much of what she says could be paraphrased from the novel. She would tell Lila bluntly and truthfully what happened because the two are so close. There is no use pretending, as Lila would know if Lenu were lying.

Lila's response is trickier, as we don't have a solid guide. We know enough about her to imagine she would be disgusted with Sarratore's behavior. She would be on Elena's side at this point, and might ask her why she didn't fight him, kick him, and scream at him to go away, as Lila would surely have done with an unwanted suitor. Lila would very likely, in this dialogue, feel protective of her friend and offer to intervene and tell Sarratore off. Elena might then have to warn the volatile Lila not to tell anyone what happened and swear her to secrecy.

See eNotes Ad-Free

Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Approved by eNotes Editorial