Themes: Difference
Through Jim Burden, an orphan who often feels like an outsider, Willa Cather delves into themes of class, nationality, and gender disparities. Even before Jim reaches Nebraska, he encounters bias against foreigners, with Jake believing they carry diseases. However, Cather highlights that prejudice is not unique to America. Otto tells Mrs. Burden, "Bohemians have a natural distrust of Austrians." Similarly, Norwegian Lena feels the influence of her Lapp ancestry from her paternal grandmother. "I guess that's what's the matter with me; they say Lapp blood will out." Throughout the novel, Jim himself reflects the prejudices and social norms of his era. As a youngster, he is annoyed that Antonia, a girl, seems to hold a superior attitude toward him. After earning her admiration by killing a snake, he cannot help but mock her, saying, "What did you jabber Bohunk for?" My Ántonia is not only an examination of human differences but also of the common destiny that connects us all to the human experience. While stargazing with Ántonia, Jim muses, "Though we had come from such different parts of the world, in both of us there was some dusky superstition that those shining groups have their influences upon what is and what is not to be."
Expert Q&A
What are the cultural differences between the families in My Antonia?
The cultural differences between the Burdens and the Shimerdas are significant. The Burdens are prosperous, accustomed to prairie life, and value generosity and hard work. The Shimerdas, European immigrants, struggle with adaptation and are more skeptical, particularly Mrs. Shimerda. While the Burdens are optimistic, Mr. Shimerda is unhappy and misses European intellectual life. Jim is drawn to the Shimerdas, appreciating Mr. Shimerda's cultured background and Antonia's free spirit, which he feels his own family lacks.
The relationship and differences between the Shimerda and Burden households in "My Antonia"
The Shimerda and Burden households in "My Antonia" highlight contrasting immigrant and established settler experiences. The Shimerdas struggle with poverty and cultural adaptation, while the Burdens, more affluent and integrated, represent stability and support for the Shimerdas. This dynamic underscores themes of hardship, community, and the immigrant experience in the American frontier.
Jim's differing views of the hired girls compared to the townspeople and town girls in "My Antonia."
Jim views the hired girls with admiration and respect, appreciating their hard work, independence, and connection to the land. In contrast, he sees the townspeople and town girls as more conventional and less vibrant, often constrained by societal expectations and lacking the same vitality and authenticity he finds in the hired girls.
How does "My Antonia" reinforce and question traditional female roles?
"My Antonia" both reinforces and questions traditional female roles through its setting and characters. Set in the pioneer days, the novel highlights women's traditional duties like cooking and cleaning, while also depicting them working alongside men in the fields. Antonia, a central character, challenges gender norms by taking on farm labor typically reserved for men, but societal pressures eventually push her back into domestic roles, emphasizing the tension between traditional expectations and individual agency.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.
