My Antonia History of the Text
by Willa Cather

My Antonia book cover
Start Your Free Trial

Download My Antonia Study Guide

Subscribe Now

History of the Text

Cather’s Prairie Trilogy: My Ántonia and its preceding novels—O, Pioneers! and The Song of the Lark—were critically and commercially successful. Though not following the same set of characters, the trilogy is concerned with similar themes of immigrant experiences and coming-of-age stories about finding success in the American West. 

  • Critics have praised not only Cather’s depiction of ordinary, often forgotten people but also her stylized writing, which was inspired by the regional dialect of Nebraska. 

My Ántonia as Semi-Autobiographical Novel: Similarly to the narrator, Jim, Cather’s family moved from Virginia to Nebraska, where Cather was born, when she was nine years old. There, she was exposed to a wealth of immigrant experiences, which many see as having formed the sympathetic backbone of My Ántonia’s portrayal of the Shimerda family and other immigrants. Also, the character of Ántonia is likely based on a Bohemian girl, Annie Pavelka, whom Cather was acquainted with in her youth and reconnected with in middle age. Like Ántonia, Pavelka was left pregnant and disgraced by a fickle fiancé but later found happiness—and had twelve children with a faithful partner on a farm in Nebraska. 

  • Some scholars suggest that Cather, whose long lasting relationships throughout her life were with women, may have been queer. One reading in light of that speculation is that Jim is a stand-in for Cather, and that his admiration of Ántonia and attraction to Lena is representative of Cather’s own sexual identity. Because homosexuality was disapproved of in Cather’s time, it is argued that Cather employed a male character to make the relationship more palatable to contemporary audiences. 

The Mythos of the Wild Frontier: Published in the early 20th century, My Ántonia provides...

(The entire section is 446 words.)