orangutan holding a shaving razor

The Murders in the Rue Morgue

by Edgar Allan Poe

Start Free Trial

Additional Commentary

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Poe's fiction does not address social issues. He viewed true reality as a mental process rather than a physical fact. Thus, for Poe, the workings of the human mind held more importance than the social environment. The only aspect of his detective tales that might hint at social relevance is the nature of crime, which inherently disrupts societal order. The role of the detective is to reestablish this order. However, this is not Dupin's deliberate goal when solving crimes. Dupin's aim is to uncover order and meaning within the mysterious reality that surrounds him. If this inadvertently restores social order, it is merely a byproduct of his analytical abilities.

Overview

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Poe's fiction largely avoids tackling social issues. He viewed reality more as a mental experience than a tangible fact. As a result, for Poe, the realm of the human mind is the main stage for action, rather than the social world. The only part of his detective tales that might suggest social significance is the nature of crime as a disruption of social order. The detective's task is to restore this order. However, while solving the crimes may eventually lead to re-establishing social order, it is not Dupin's conscious goal. Dupin seeks to find order and meaning within the puzzling fragments of the reality he encounters. If this also restores social order, it is simply an unintended result of his analytical prowess.

The story "Murders in the Rue Morgue" is set in mid-nineteenth century Paris, France. The police are stumped by the brutal murders of a woman and her daughter. Auguste Dupin, a young nobleman with limited wealth, decides, after reading about the crime in the newspapers, that he can solve what the police cannot. Therefore, the physical setting of the story is less important than the mental landscape — Dupin's mind. The narrative contains minimal direct action; all details of the crime are relayed through newspaper reports. Solving the crime requires no physical activity but follows the detective story tradition of an armchair investigation, where the detective explains the events of the crime based on the clues he has interpreted.

Analytical Reasoning vs. Mere Thinking

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Edgar Allan Poe's "The Murders in the Rue Morgue" introduces readers to C. Auguste Dupin, setting the stage for his intellectual prowess in a trilogy of tales. In this inaugural story, Poe explores a recurring theme: the superiority of analytical reasoning over conventional thinking. Through Dupin's character, Poe consistently contrasts the methodical approach of the analytical mind with the often inadequate methods employed by the police. This opposition is central to showcasing Dupin's brilliance.

In "The Murders in the Rue Morgue," the narrative unfolds around a grisly crime scene that challenges the capabilities of the local police force. Dupin, driven by a keen sense of curiosity and a need to understand the intricacies of the case, visits the crime scene. His observations are meticulous, yet it is his ability to connect disparate pieces of evidence through logical deduction that truly sets him apart. While the police rely on standard investigative procedures, Dupin delves deeper, reconstructing the crime with an imaginative yet rational perspective.

Poe illustrates that physical presence at the scene is not always necessary for Dupin to solve the crime. Indeed, much of Dupin's success stems from his ability to mentally sift through the available facts, identifying patterns and connections invisible to others. His analytical prowess allows him to transcend the limitations of traditional detective work, highlighting Poe’s belief in the power of a cultivated mind to unravel even the most perplexing mysteries.

Creation of the Detective Story Genre

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

"The Murders in the Rue Morgue" stands as a milestone in literary history, introducing the concept...

(This entire section contains 101 words.)

Unlock this Study Guide Now

Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

of the locked-room mystery, a device that would become a staple in crime fiction. Edgar Allan Poe, through this pioneering tale, crafted the first detective story in American literature, laying the groundwork for a genre that would flourish both in England and the United States. His creation of a structured template for detective fiction provided a foundation upon which future writers would construct their investigative protagonists. Thus, with the publication of this tale, Poe earned the title of the progenitor of the detective story genre.

Reason vs. Unreason

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

The narrative of "The Murders in the Rue Morgue" intricately weaves the theme of reason contending against unreason—a struggle between rationality and irrationality. The brutal murders in the Rue Morgue shatter the peace of the neighborhood, creating a ripple of horror and chaos. Into this unsettling disruption steps Dupin, whose keen application of logic serves as a beacon to restore order. In this story, as in others by Poe, reason emerges as humanity’s most formidable ally against madness.

Poe crafts Dupin as a remarkable figure, one whose perception and analytical skills distinguish him as an outsider. This characterization poses an intriguing question: while reason can momentarily triumph over madness, might it ultimately be overwhelmed? Dupin’s extraordinary capabilities suggest that such incisive reason is not common, hinting at its precariousness in the face of pervasive irrational forces.

Previous

Summary

Next

Characters

Loading...