Part I, Chapter 3 Summary and Analysis
Summary
Chapter 3 begins with Kidder's arrival in Haiti. Farmer sent a truck to pick
him up, and Kidder rides with a group of Haitians along National Highway 3. The
thirty-five-mile trip from the capital Port-au-Prince to the village Cange
takes three hours. Once there, Kidder visits Farmer's clinic Zammi Lasante
(which means "Partners in Health" in Creole). Kidder follows Farmer on his
rounds, watching Farmer interact with countless sick and desperately poor
Haitians. The clinic has seventy community health workers, but it is the main
source of health care for roughly one million peasants, many of whom travel
long distances by foot or on donkey to see "Doktè Paul."
Officially everyone treated at Zammi Lasante has to pay, but Farmer allows
everyone to be treated whether they can afford it or not. The clinic's annual
budget is around 1.5 million dollars. Some of this comes from Farmer directly,
though more comes through donations. (Tom White, from Boston, was the largest
donor.)
Kidder follows Farmer through many rounds at Zammi Lasante. The patients all
seem to know Farmer well; he knows and clearly likes them. In addition to
practicing traditional Western medicine, Farmer gives food and dietary
supplements when he can, just as Zammi Lasante promotes health through building
schools and water systems.
Farmer often narrates his treatments to Kidder. In doing so, he tries to
educate Kidder, but also to speak through him to the larger world, to correct
misconceptions about Haiti and poverty. As part of one of these narrations,
Farmer explains the Haitian belief in sorcery as a way of explaining bad or
tragic events. The most extreme example of this concludes the chapter: while
Farmer is doing a spinal tap on a girl, she cries because she is hungry. He
also explains the world to the Haitians he treats, educating them on the fact
that HIV is simply a virus, not a source of shame.
In addition to getting to know Farmer as a doctor, Kidder learns a bit about
his personal life. Farmer had married a Haitian woman named Didi Bertrand four
years earlier, and they had a daughter. Farmer divides his time between Haiti,
where he lives in a modernized "ti kay" (Haitian peasant house), an apartment
in Boston, and Paris, where Didi is earning a degree in anthropology. Though he
called them regularly, Farmer did not spend much time with his family. Instead,
he dedicated his time to caring for the poor, flying millions of miles around
the world to treat them.
Analysis
In Chapter 3, Kidder shows us how Farmer is positioned between several worlds,
and how he serves as a mediator and communicator among them. Farmer explains
Haiti to Westerners, and Western medicine to Haitians, a little at a time. When
in the United States, he lives in Eliot House at Harvard University, perhaps
the single most powerfully charged symbol of the educated elite. When he is in
Haiti, he lives just slightly better than the peasants he treats. Farmer has,
for example, a bathtub in his house, but no hot water. Such positioning
establishes Farmer as especially trustworthy as Kidder's guide to this world,
and that credibility is underscored by the way Zammi Lasante functions. Kidder
notes that his hospital back in Massachusetts has a budget of about $60 million
to serve about the same number of patients, or 40 times as much, and that
Farmer treated TB for "$150-$200," when it cost "between $15,000 and $20,000"
in the United States.
Kidder's portraits of poverty are delivered with commentary—he allows Farmer to
provide that—but his sympathies are obvious, and an implicit but clear judgment
is communicated: the situation in Haiti is not right, and something should be
done.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.