Morley Callaghan Criticism
Morley Callaghan (1903-1990), a notable Canadian writer, has been a significant figure in English literature. His work, spanning novels, short stories, and autobiographies, is characterized by a spare, journalistic style often compared to that of Ernest Hemingway. This stylistic choice, however, remains a point of contention among critics. Some, like Margaret Avison, argue that it undercuts his literary reputation, while others appreciate its clarity and subtlety in exploring moral, psychological, and religious themes.
Callaghan's literary endeavors often delve into complex moral landscapes, examining themes of redemption, salvation, and the tension between materialism and spiritualism. His debut novel, Strange Fugitive, offers a nuanced reflection on Toronto's socio-cultural environment, a perspective explored by Justin D. Edwards. The novel sets the tone for his later works, which continue to explore the dichotomy of the sacred versus the secular, establishing him as a pivotal figure in Canadian literature, as noted by Barbara Pell.
Callaghan's first major novel, Such Is My Beloved, dives deeper into the internal conflict of a priest and is interpreted as a commentary on the "Song of Songs" by John W. Burbidge. In contrast, his memoir, That Summer in Paris, critiques the myth of expatriate life in the 1920s and employs theatrical narrative strategies discussed by Russell Brown and Marianne Perz.
Callaghan's work is also noted for its incorporation of legal language, particularly in his early short stories from 1925 to 1928. This aspect of his narrative technique is examined by Gary Boire. His fiction, while stylistically reminiscent of Hemingway's hard-boiled prose, offers a warm exploration of human relationships, characterized by subtlety and humor, as argued by Horace Gregory. Hugo McPherson highlights Callaghan's exploration of the human condition through the interplay of empirical and spiritual realms, creating a unique narrative duality.
His novel A Fine and Private Place exemplifies his morally focused narrative style, as noted by Howard Engel, reflecting his broader literary contributions. Despite criticisms regarding character engagement and narrative complexity, Callaghan's critique of Christianity and the Roman Catholic Church, as described by Judith Kendle, emphasizes individual insight and creative imagination over traditional doctrine. This personal theology highlights his distinctive approach and enduring literary significance.
Contents
- Principal Works
- Callaghan, Morley (Vol. 3)
-
Callaghan, Morley (Vol. 14)
-
Mr. Callaghan's Medium
(summary)
In the following essay, Horace Gregory argues that Morley Callaghan's fiction, while stylistically similar to Hemingway's hard-boiled prose, reveals a warm and curious exploration of human relationships, characterized by subtlety, humor, and sometimes sentimentality, distinguishing him as an intriguing figure within his literary school.
-
The Two Worlds of Morley Callaghan
(summary)
In the following essay, Hugo McPherson argues that Morley Callaghan's literary significance lies not in his stylistic prowess but in his profound exploration of the human condition through the interplay of empirical and spiritual realms, creating a unique narrative duality despite his earlier struggles with coherence and character depth.
-
Callaghan's World of Criminals and Saints
(summary)
In the following essay, Howard Engel contends that Morley Callaghan's A Fine and Private Place offers a concentrated, morally focused narrative typical of his work, marked by its sparseness, urban setting in Toronto, and reflective of his broader literary contributions, despite criticisms of character engagement and narrative complexity.
-
Callaghan and the Church
(summary)
In the following essay, Judith Kendle argues that Morley Callaghan's critique of Christianity and the Roman Catholic Church is rooted in his aesthetic philosophy, emphasizing individual insight and creative imagination over traditional religious doctrine, thus transforming Christian concepts into a personal theology centered on the artist's vision.
-
Mr. Callaghan's Medium
(summary)
-
Callaghan, Morley
-
Reading Morley Callaghan's Such Is My Beloved
(summary)
In the following essay, Avison provides an appreciation of Callaghan's work, asserting that his spare narrative style may have been detrimental to his literary legacy.
-
Religion in Morley Callaghan's Such Is My Beloved
(summary)
In the following essay, Burbidge elucidates Callaghan's treatment of religion in Such Is My Beloved, viewing the novel as a commentary on the “Song of Songs.”
-
Callaghan, Glassco, and the Canadian Lost Generation
(summary)
In the following essay, Brown discusses how Callaghan's memoir That Summer in Paris and John Glassco's Memoirs of Montparnasse challenges the American-in-Paris myth of expatriate life in the 1920s.
-
Staging That Summer in Paris: Narrative Strategies and Theatrical Techniques in the Life Writing of Morley Callaghan
(summary)
In the following essay, Perz contends that Callaghan employs theatrical techniques in his memoir That Summer in Paris.
-
Strange Fugitive, Strange City: Reading Urban Space in Morley Callaghan's Toronto
(summary)
In the following essay, Edwards considers Callaghan's portrayal of Toronto in his novel Strange Fugitive.
-
Morley Callaghan
(summary)
In the following essay, Pell delineates the defining characteristics of Callaghan's fiction, highlighting his role as a major religious novelist and his portrayal of the tension between the sacred and the secular in modern life.
-
The Language of the Law: The Cases of Morley Callaghan
(summary)
In the following essay, Boire examines Callaghan's use of the language of the law in his short stories between 1925 and 1928.
-
Reading Morley Callaghan's Such Is My Beloved
(summary)
- Further Reading