Themes: Identity

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

The theme of identity is central to Monster by Walter Dean Myers. The novel explores the protagonist Steve Harmon's struggle to understand who he is amidst the pressures of a racially biased justice system and his own internal conflicts. Steve's journey is marked by his attempts to reconcile his self-image with the labels imposed on him by society and the legal system, which sees him as a "monster." This theme is developed through Steve's introspection, his interactions with others, and the symbolic use of mirrors.

Steve's internal conflict is a significant aspect of his identity crisis. Throughout the novel, he grapples with his conscience, questioning his morals and decisions. In prison, Steve writes in his diary and examines himself in the mirror, trying to understand his true intentions and character. He is haunted by the prosecution's portrayal of him as a "monster," and he struggles to differentiate himself from the criminals around him. Steve's lawyer, Kathy O'Brien, acknowledges the jury's preconceived notions about him, further complicating his self-perception.

"And I knew she felt that I didn't do anything wrong. It was me who wasn't sure. It was me who lay on the cot wondering if I was fooling myself" (Myers 151).

Steve's self-perception is influenced by his environment and the people around him. He wants to believe he is a good person, but the harsh realities of prison life and the trial challenge this belief. He expresses a desire to show O'Brien who he truly is, stating, "I'm just not a bad person. I know that in my heart I am not a bad person" (Myers 97). Despite this, he continues to question his identity and choices, wondering why society views him as a monster.

"That is why I take the films of myself. I want to know who I am. I want to know the road to panic that I took. I want to look at myself a thousand times to look for one true image" (Myers 284).

The mirror in Steve's cell symbolizes his identity issues and the broader societal context. It reflects the long history of marginalized Black youths who, like Steve, have been dehumanized by the justice system. Steve's difficulty recognizing his reflection signifies his struggle to understand his identity amidst the labels and stereotypes imposed on him. Even after his acquittal, he continues to search for the "monster" within, illustrating his ongoing battle with self-perception and societal judgment.

Expert Q&A

How did prison change Steve Harmon in Monster?

Prison changes Steve Harmon by making him more accepting of his perceived guilt and leading him to question his identity, even contemplating suicide. Initially hopeful and passionate about filmmaking, Steve becomes depressed and desperate in jail but ultimately emerges stronger, with a clearer understanding of himself and his identity, despite continuing to face discrimination.

What does Steve Harmon mean by "It is about being alone when you are not really alone..." in the novel Monster by Walter Dean Myers?

Steve Harmon feels "alone when you are not really alone" due to his isolation in prison, surrounded by strangers he neither knows nor trusts. Despite being physically among other inmates, Steve experiences profound loneliness and fear, exacerbated by the constant threat of violence. His sentiment reflects the psychological toll of imprisonment, where the absence of familiar, supportive connections leaves him feeling isolated even in the company of others.

In the book "Monster", does Steve change, and is it a positive or negative change?

In "Monster," Steve undergoes a significant change in how he views himself, driven by his trial's emotional impact. This change is neither wholly positive nor negative but rather complex. Steve's self-perception evolves through the perspectives of the prosecution, his lawyer, and his family, leading him to see himself in fragmented ways. The novel's format, using script and journal entries, highlights this multifaceted view, reflecting the modern notion that truth is not absolute but made of various perspectives.

In Monster, what does the text suggest about Steve's home life compared to the other robbery participants?

In Monster, Steve's life is different from the other people involved in the robbery in that he hasn't previously committed violent crimes, and he is still loved and supported by multiple people around him.

Can you relate any experiences from your life to the novel Monster?

The novel explores themes of self-identity and morality, which many can relate to personal experiences. Like Steve Harmon, individuals may struggle with identity and regret poor decisions made to fit in or justify actions. Steve's attempt to rationalize his role in a crime parallels how people sometimes try to justify bad choices to cope with consequences. These relatable themes highlight the universal challenges of understanding oneself and the moral ambiguities faced in life.

Why is the novel titled Monster and what does the monster symbolize?

The novel is titled "Monster" to symbolize the label placed on Steve Harmon, the protagonist, by the prosecution and society. The term "monster" is used to describe individuals who lack regard for others, reflecting the prejudice and fear surrounding young minorities in the justice system. Steve struggles with this label throughout the novel, questioning its validity and using his screenplay to explore his identity and challenge the perception of being a "monster."

In Monster, how is Steve Harmon both the protagonist and antagonist?

Steve Harmon is both the protagonist and antagonist in Walter Dean Myers' Monster because he is central to the story and drives the narrative forward as he recounts his trial for felony murder. As the protagonist, Steve is the focal point of the novel. However, he also acts as his own antagonist by making choices that lead to his arrest, such as participating in a robbery, thereby causing his own internal and external conflicts.

In Monster, did Steve enter the store solely for mints, or is he self-justifying his actions?

In Monster, Steve's role in the robbery is not clear. However, it is evident that he had no malign intentions and no idea that the robbery might lead to murder. It therefore seems psychologically likely that he would convince himself that he did nothing wrong and that his intentions in entering the shop were entirely innocent, since he certainly did not intend the harm which actually occurred.

Steve Harmon's self-perception and identity in Monster

In Monster, Steve Harmon grapples with his self-perception and identity throughout the novel. He struggles to reconcile his self-image as a good person with the prosecution's portrayal of him as a "monster." This internal conflict is exacerbated by his experiences in jail and the courtroom, leading him to question who he truly is.

Does Mrs. Harmon perceive her son as a monster? Explain.

Mrs. Harmon does not perceive her son, Steve, as a monster. During her emotional visit to him in prison, she expresses her belief in his innocence, highlighting her unwavering support. She gives him a Bible and assures him that she knows he did nothing wrong, contrasting with his father's doubts. Her actions and words reflect her view of Steve as a loving mother who believes in his innocence despite the allegations against him.

Show another question (5 questions hidden)

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Previous

Themes: Justice

Loading...